News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by smaddox on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:13PM (#20499415)
As far as I can tell, the primary purpose of manned space missions is to redirecting taxes to congressional districts and defense contractors. The secondary purpose might be to inspire interest in STEM, but it seems much less successful at achieving that objective.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by BurningFrog on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:36PM (#20499695)
The other cynical view is that the moon program was really military.

As in, if the Soviets got to control the ultimate "higher ground", they could rule the world from it. Apollo made sure no one could control space, and we now have peace in space.

I kinda believe in this, though I don't know how historically verified it is. It's of course not what you ever say in your rousing speeches to the nation and the world!

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by wongarsu on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:49PM (#20499802)
There was fear that if the Russians got to the moon first they might set up a base, and having a base they could shoot down any other landing attempt (literally, with guns mounted in their moon base). Thus the moon could become Russian domain, which would not just grant them great research opportunities but also a virtually unreachable weapons platform. (Remember that the first crewed space station was 2 years after the moon landing, and also Soviet)

On that basis the military was advocating for a moon mission years before Kennedy's speech. It's hard to tell if this actually played a big role in the decision to go to the moon, but it was the cold war after all.

Also the Soviet Union was winning most of the relevant milestones in space (first satellite, first animal in orbit, first human, first woman, first space walk, etc), and this was a great source of national pride. Beating them had great propaganda value.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by jandrese on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:33PM (#20500843)
Shooting people from the moon is probably the least practical military endeavor ever seriously contemplated, and that is saying a lot.

The Cold War resulted in a lot of really nutty thinking so I can't rule it out entirely, but it's hard to imagine what such a base would look like, especially with 1960s tech.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by wongarsu on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:50PM (#20501058)
Getting from the moon to earth is trivial when compared to launching anything from earth. Using some back-of-the-envelope calculation a Atlas B ICBM from 1959 has enough fuel and thrust to deliver over 5 tons of warheads from the moon to earth. If you launched from the far side of the moon I imagine early warning and interception aren't on the table with 1960/70s tech, providing excellent first strike and second strike capability.

Of course actually getting ICBMs on the moon is a whole other endeavor.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by jandrese on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:06PM (#20501225)
Early warning satellites would be a heck of a lot easier to install than the missiles. Basically once someone started building such a plant it would be impossible to hide what you're doing.

You'd never get first strike launching from the Moon, regular ICBMs would be all over you long before the moon IPBMs made the 1 day journey back to Earth. Even with the faster travel speed from only having to accelerate out of the Moon's gravity well, you're talking about a distance of 384,000km vs. 8,000km. Your missiles arrive to a planet that is already a radioactive moonscape.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by wongarsu on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:17PM (#20501326)
It doesn't have to be a one day journey. With a 3 ton payload the Atlas B seems to have > 8000km/s delta-v. Getting from moon to earth took Apollo about 4800km/s delta-v, leaving our little Atlas 3200km/s spare fuel. If you use that to accelerate to 3200km/s travel speed you arrive on earth after about 2 minutes (if we ignore the time it takes to accelerate).
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by AcerbicZero on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:43PM (#20501588)
I think we can simplify this further. It seems reasonable to assume that any weapon deployed on the surface of the moon would be devolved and dedicated specifically for that purpose, so we can ignore playing theoretical math games :).

It would also be fairly obvious that someone was trying to move several thousand pounds of hardware onto the moon, and launch detection satellites would be even more effective at monitoring the moon. So you've got a first strike, that will be detectable basically immediately, and weapons that now need to travel ~385,000 km and survive even more serious re-entry than the ICBM's based on Earth. Or you've got a second strike capability that cost you billions of rubles/dollars.

Once you look at it like that, its pretty easy to see why the submarine launched weapons were the preferred method for threatening rapid first strike while providing a guaranteed second strike capability.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by pmontra on Monday July 22, 2019 @04:55PM (#20502244)
Can a missile survive reentry at 3200km/s? From https://www.grc.nasa.gov/WWW/BGH/hihyper.html LEO reentry speed is 17500 mph = 28000 km/h = 7.7 km/s. It's 415 times the speed.

I didn't do the math but at that speed you don't need a warhead to destroy a target. Let's try with 1000 kg steel or whatever won't melt down

1/2 mv^2 = 500 * (3200 * 3600)^2 = 345,500,000,000 J

1 J lifts about 100 g mass by 1 m on the surface of Earth. That energy would lift 345,500,000 kg by 100 m.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by ynik on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:49PM (#20501641)
A two minute travel time is ridiculous. Even light takes more than a second to reach us from the moon.

The lunar orbit->earth delta-v is 4.8km/s. I didn't check your other numbers but they seem to be off by a factor 1000 too.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by bbojan on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:40PM (#20501548)
You are off by at least 3 orders of magnitude.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by packet_nerd on Monday July 22, 2019 @04:47PM (#20502189)
Besides acceleration at the moon side, wouldn't there need to be deceleration before entering the atmosphere? I'm thinking an IPBM traveling that fast would rip apart in the upper atmosphere and/or explode too high to cause any real damage.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by abfan1127 on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:04PM (#20501199)
If you can land a ship on the moon, you can land an ICBM on a house in Moscow. It was less about launching from the moon. It was more about getting it to land where you want.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by dTal on Monday July 22, 2019 @06:15PM (#20502801)
>Also the Soviet Union was winning most of the relevant milestones in space (first satellite, first animal in orbit, first human, first woman, first space walk, etc), and this was a great source of national pride. Beating them had great propaganda value.

I would rather say that the Soviet Union was winning the irrelevant milestones, precisely for the propaganda value. First woman in space means nothing, really - you put a woman on your spaceship, wham, easy win. The moon landings forced the USA to tackle real engineering challenges - rendezvous and docking, piloted spacecraft and piloted orbit changes, functionally useful EVAs, keeping humans alive in space for long periods, etc.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by DiogenesKynikos on Monday July 22, 2019 @11:57PM (#20504300)
First satellite and first man in space are not irrelevant. They're very challenging engineering problems.

First woman in space is technically easy, but it does say something about the two cultures that the Soviet Union put a woman in space almost immediately, whereas the United States didn't do so for decades.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by novaRom on Monday July 22, 2019 @06:53PM (#20503037)
Oh boy, you underestimate the power of feminism. First woman in space is a lot, especially if you go back to 60th of previous century.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by dTal on Monday July 22, 2019 @08:52PM (#20503583)
That's the point - it's a propaganda win, not a technical achievement in any way. Not to belittle the symbolic importance of it, but cmon - first dog murdered by being launched in a rocket, first time running two manned missions at the same time, first nap in space - a large proportion of the Soviet "firsts" were just low-complexity stunts.

One of the last major "firsts" was "first organisms to circle the moon" - they barely squeaked this one in a few months before Apollo 8, and they accomplished it by shoving some tortoises into a Soyuz (no food or water required!).

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by greglindahl on Monday July 22, 2019 @04:04PM (#20501794)
Do you have a source for this claim? A base on the moon is a sitting duck for an incoming missile -- it's easier to figure out how to guide a missile near the moon than to shoot down an incoming high-velocity missile.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by NikolaeVarius on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:46PM (#20499781)
The moon program was quite explicitly a showboat for American Engineering vs Soviet.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by rtkwe on Monday July 22, 2019 @01:38PM (#20500333)
There's also a lot of value in the research NASA/JAXA/ESA/Roscosmos does in space. Some experiments are only really doable under long term microgravity The US runs it as a national lab and many companies use it for experiments. Maintaining it that way makes it way easier for companies to run experiments in space, with out the ISS each company would have to design, build and launch their own satellite for each experiment they wanted to do. That could be done but it would be very complex and quite fragile compared to having an established station where humans can do the work.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by Retric on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:04PM (#20500548)
The catch 22 is any experiment that you can only do in microgravity is also only really relevant in microgravity. That’s fine if we have a larger goal, but not really useful on it’s own.

Sure simply learning this stuff is interesting, but the costs are so extreme it’s effectively a vanity project.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by greglindahl on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:43PM (#20501584)
This generalization isn't true. One modern example is manufacturing optical fibers like ZBLAN[1] -- they work great when you bring them back to Earth. Another new example is 3d printing organs in microgravity[2] to take them back to Earth.

The traditional example is doing basic physics that needs long duration microgravity.

These sorts of research aren't a large fraction of what's currently done on the ISS, but it's also not zero.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZBLAN

2: https://www.asme.org/topics-resources/content/growing-human-...

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by Retric on Monday July 22, 2019 @06:09PM (#20502758)
The need for microgravity to manufacture these things is demonstrating my point.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by greglindahl on Monday July 22, 2019 @06:20PM (#20502843)
Then I totally didn't get your point. These are things that you manufacture in microgravity that are then usable in gravity. Isn't that what you said did not exist?
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by Retric on Monday July 22, 2019 @06:37PM (#20502933)
I am saying testing say crystal formation in space is only relevant for crystal formation in space. If that’s what you’re going to do aka manufacturing in space then sure experimenting in space is required. Getting the economics to look promising for actually manufacturing in space then that’s a separate thing.

Aka Manufacturing would be that larger goal I was referencing.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by rtkwe on Monday July 22, 2019 @08:12PM (#20503403)
It's not though the crystals are used to determine the structure of the molecule itself through XRay crystallography. We have to grow larger crystals that are then used to determine the shape of the individual molecules. Some crystalize easily and we were able to study them using crystals grown here on Earth but others were more difficult and had to be grown in space. Just because the research takes place in space doesn't mean it's only applicable in space!
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by Retric on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @07:06AM (#20505806)
You can do that same XRay crystallography on the same substances on earth. Going to space is pure cost benefit analysis for growing crystals, not some exclusive experiment you can only do in space.

That said, when you get a massive subsidy by NASA, these costs are less obvious.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by rtkwe on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @04:22PM (#20509892)
You can't currently because we've not been able to grow sufficiently high quality crystals here on Earth with gravity. Basically anything that needs more than 30-60 seconds of microgravity can't be done anywhere on Earth no matter how much money you want to spend. NASA is already up there to learn about the effects on the human body (which again we can only really do holistically actually IN space) so trying to put the whole cost amortized over all the experiments isn't going to come up with a reasonable number.

But even beyond that this is precisely what governments are supposed to do, gather and distribute costs that would make little sense for individual companies or even massive conglomerates to do.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by rtkwe on Monday July 22, 2019 @04:07PM (#20501825)
Actually not true in the slightest. Microgravity removes one more confounding variable present in all experiments gravity. One example, in addition to those already mentioned, is crystallography; where it's much easier to grow the crystals we need for experiments in space than it is on Earth where gravity is constantly present affecting the growth. Those results are useful here on Earth but can only so far be achieved in space.

Even beyond things like that the only real way to study the effect of space on the human body is to put people up there for a long time and test. There are some analogues available here on Earth but they can only really test a few things at once like fluid redistribution and not the entire set of effects.

https://www.nature.com/articles/npjmgrav201510

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by bbojan on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:44PM (#20501596)
Researchers discover cool-burning flames in space that could lead to better engines here on earth

https://jacobsschool.ucsd.edu/news/news_releases/release.sfe...

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by jemorya on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:56PM (#20501130)
I'm not sure that the information from such experiments is only really relevant to applications in microgravity environments. (Hopefully I'm not misunderstanding your point too much.)

The data points from microgravity experiments don't exist in isolation; presumably there are data points for similar experiments at surface gravity. Removing gravity from a system could say very much about how gravity affects the system, and thus how the system works on Earth.

We also might discover effects so important that it would be worth going to microgravity to get them. Stepping out into the unknown just to learn how it works is important.

(Disclaimer: I know jack about what kind of microgravity experiments are going on.)

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by mcguire on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:31PM (#20500829)
You could say the same thing about experimental high-energy physics.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by goodcanadian on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:25PM (#20499545)
I almost down voted you in a knee jerk reaction. I believe that manned space exploration serves a very important purpose in advancing humanity . . . however, from the typical Congress critter's point of view, I suspect you're right.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by avmich on Monday July 22, 2019 @12:57PM (#20499888)
I suspect GP underestimates the scientific value of Apollo missions. It's so much difference to e.g. study samples brought from the Moon (and taken with reasonable care) in Earth labs than to send robots to do the same.

There is a POV that robots are good for scientific missions up to certain price point. After that manned missions become more cost effective.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by greglindahl on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:52PM (#20501074)
The money spent on Apollo would support a large number of robotic missions, including sample return. And they could visit a bunch of different areas.

If we were trying to maximize science per dollar, every manned program would have a lot of robotic preparation. Are we doing that? No. We've spent almost nothing on the Moon and only a tiny, tiny fraction of the manned budget on robots to Mars.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by smaddox on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:27PM (#20500779)
I don't see how it would be cheaper to send a human to the Moon to retrieve samples than it would be to send a robot.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by avmich on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:41PM (#20501556)
Some arguments are here: https://phys.org/news/2005-11-unmanned-space-exploration_1.h...

Retrieving a sample is cheaper with a robot - Luna-24 costed a fraction of Apollo. Knowing what to retrieve while having flexibility of choosing surface regolith, separate rock, samples dug out from a better place or else - that's where humans win.

Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by mopsi on Monday July 22, 2019 @05:10PM (#20502361)
Indeed. Apollo 17 even flew an actual geologist to the surface of the Moon and gave him 20 hours to explore it.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by ticmasta on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:02PM (#20501188)
and that's really just the cost the actual mission. Consider the impact of having to prepare a program that meets acceptable risk levels for humans vs. machines. This is a huge consideration. I'm not suggesting unmanned exploration can take a trial and error approach, but losing a robot is sad & expensive while losing a human astronaut can terminate the entire program.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by checktheorder on Monday July 22, 2019 @04:39PM (#20502114)
I would bet good money that when Starship makes its first safe return to Earth after a manned lunar landing mission, there's going to be some serious-as-a-heart-attack talk within the worlds' universities about pooling cash for manned missions.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by joquarky on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @10:43AM (#20507091)
What disappoints me is that we could be paying the same organizations to build things to expand space exploration rather than warfare.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea by ticmasta on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:57PM (#20501137)
especially when you look at the scientific pay-off from relatively cheap unmanned space exploration vs. what we get from shooting humans onto the space equivalent of the front step of the house.