Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea
by greglindahl on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:52PM
(#20501074)
The money spent on Apollo would support a large number of robotic missions, including sample return. And they could visit a bunch of different areas.
If we were trying to maximize science per dollar, every manned program would have a lot of robotic preparation. Are we doing that? No. We've spent almost nothing on the Moon and only a tiny, tiny fraction of the manned budget on robots to Mars.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea
by smaddox on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:27PM
(#20500779)
I don't see how it would be cheaper to send a human to the Moon to retrieve samples than it would be to send a robot.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea
by avmich on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:41PM
(#20501556)
Some arguments are here: https://phys.org/news/2005-11-unmanned-space-exploration_1.h...
Retrieving a sample is cheaper with a robot - Luna-24 costed a fraction of Apollo. Knowing what to retrieve while having flexibility of choosing surface regolith, separate rock, samples dug out from a better place or else - that's where humans win.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea
by mopsi on Monday July 22, 2019 @05:10PM
(#20502361)
Indeed. Apollo 17 even flew an actual geologist to the surface of the Moon and gave him 20 hours to explore it.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea
by ticmasta on Monday July 22, 2019 @03:02PM
(#20501188)
and that's really just the cost the actual mission. Consider the impact of having to prepare a program that meets acceptable risk levels for humans vs. machines. This is a huge consideration. I'm not suggesting unmanned exploration can take a trial and error approach, but losing a robot is sad & expensive while losing a human astronaut can terminate the entire program.
Re:NASA’s Lunar Space Station Is a Great/Terrible Idea
by checktheorder on Monday July 22, 2019 @04:39PM
(#20502114)
I would bet good money that when Starship makes its first safe return to Earth after a manned lunar landing mission, there's going to be some serious-as-a-heart-attack talk within the worlds' universities about pooling cash for manned missions.
There is a POV that robots are good for scientific missions up to certain price point. After that manned missions become more cost effective.