News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by Gracana on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:08PM (#20462946)
What's the difference between putting webfonts on your public website vs putting them on your public github? This seems like a distinction that only lawyers would care about, but I'm not a web developer (and I don't know much about webfonts) so maybe there's something I'm missing.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:40PM (#20464335)
The people who draft these licenses are pretty smart and explain VERY CLEARLY what is and is not allowed. For instance!

> The following are allowed by this agreement; you may:

> 1b. Use the WOFF, WOFF2, and EOT web font formats provided by Process to style text on your websites via the CSS @font-face rule for an unlimited number of websites whose content is controlled by you. You agree to use reasonable measures to ensure the fonts are available only for the process of styling text on websites. At a minimum, and by way of illustration not limitation, reasonable measures include i) preventing unlicensed third-party access, i.e. hotlinking and, ii) not allowing direct download of the fonts unrelated to the process of styling text for your website.

and

> This agreement expressly prohibits the following; you may not:

> 2e. Store or use the fonts in any way that makes them accessible to the public or non-licensed third parties, except where such use is expressly allowed by this Agreement. This includes, but is not limited to, distribution of the fonts through file sharing services and online version control repositories accessible by the public.

https://processtypefoundry.com/help/base/webfont-license-agr...

Seems pretty clear!

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by lol768 on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:56AM (#20467730)
>At a minimum, and by way of illustration not limitation, reasonable measures include i) preventing unlicensed third-party access, i.e. hotlinking and, ii) not allowing direct download of the fonts unrelated to the process of styling text for your website.

It's not clear. How on earth are you supposed to implement ii)?

I'm not interested in answers which mention the Referer header. There are a myriad of factors which can prevent it being sent with the original request required the style elements on the site.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Thursday July 18, 2019 @11:34AM (#20470888)
Yes, that one's a bit tricky, isn't it? You might inspect the user-agent to at least try and only serve the font to browsers. You might also make sure that if there is a Referer, isn't not someone else's referer. I don't think it has to be foolproof to satisfy the terms of the license.

It might also just be: you have to check the referer. If your website has technical issues such that sometimes the referer isn't available, you have to change it so it always is. Or host it on one of the approved third-party hosts referenced in the license.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by wnevets on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:11PM (#20462976)
IANAL but I believe you may have a license (paid money) to use the font on your site but you may not have a licence redistribute the font. You paid for the right to air the latest UFC fight at your bar but that doesn't grant you the ability to sale DVDs of it.

However a user of yours could just download the font from your web server or record the fight on their phone.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by c3534l on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:14PM (#20463001)
But it's not like a webpage renders an image for you and then you rend an image: you send the user a font so that they can render the page themselves with that font. It's being distributed either way.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:39PM (#20463207)
Licenses can totally distinguish between the two scenarios. Providing a clickable link to "Download Font Here!" is probably not allowed, but linking to the font for the purpose of displaying the actual webpage is fine. Even if they're the same url.

This is just bit coloring again: https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by Nightshaxx on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:28PM (#20464227)
But that's what the GitHub problem is. People are adding the font so people can use the application they made.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:35PM (#20464295)
Font licenses make the difference very, very clear.

> The following are allowed by this agreement; you may:

> 1b. Use the WOFF, WOFF2, and EOT web font formats provided by Process to style text on your websites via the CSS @font-face rule for an unlimited number of websites whose content is controlled by you. You agree to use reasonable measures to ensure the fonts are available only for the process of styling text on websites. At a minimum, and by way of illustration not limitation, reasonable measures include i) preventing unlicensed third-party access, i.e. hotlinking and, ii) not allowing direct download of the fonts unrelated to the process of styling text for your website.

and

> This agreement expressly prohibits the following; you may not:

> 2e. Store or use the fonts in any way that makes them accessible to the public or non-licensed third parties, except where such use is expressly allowed by this Agreement. This includes, but is not limited to, distribution of the fonts through file sharing services and online version control repositories accessible by the public.

https://processtypefoundry.com/help/base/webfont-license-agr...

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by Aeolun on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @09:17PM (#20465743)
They make the difference clear, but they don’t make a lot of sense.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by zaarn on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:53AM (#20467712)
Makes perfect sense to be, tbh. Licenses are just contracts and they can exactly describe what you're allowed and not allowed to do, including allowing use cases based on intent and presentation.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by usaphp on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:32PM (#20463145)
Website also sends copyrighted photos, it does not mean you can re-use them on your own site.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by wnevets on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:31PM (#20463136)
Doesn't licensing images like stock photography have the exact issue?

technically the font is just a bunch of 1s and 0s but here we are.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by teknopaul on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:02PM (#20463385)
Yes. Dont upload stock images to open source code projects either. Or any other copyrighted material like your mp3 collection.

I think what would be useful would be to highlight the many fonts that can be used. E.g Google's open source fonts.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by christoph on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @10:08PM (#20466058)
For some reason, reading your comment gave me a flashback (no pun intended) to the dark days of sIFR.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scalable_Inman_Flash_Replaceme...

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by toomuchtodo on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:19PM (#20463041)
Correct. Article OP is making the argument for a font to be treated as a secret when it is not a secret. Intent and context is important; users aren't putting them up on torrent sites in this case, but simply storing them alongside the rest of their assets in source control.

EDIT: TLDR Downloading a publicly available font you don't have a license to use violates copyright.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:53PM (#20463304)
Accidentally exposing a folder of copyrighted font files over FTP would probably technically violate the license, even if it was by accident. You're serving the files outside of the licensed use (serving and rendering a webpage).

Same as if you accidentally exposed to the internet your home server of legally-created DVD backups. You'd still be violating the license under which you bought the DVDs.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by toomuchtodo on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:56PM (#20463338)
Show me an attorney willing to pursue accidental violators for damages, especially when the asset in question is intended to be publicly served in the course of its use.

I would genuinely be interested in case law's stance on this. Also interested in what happens to the value of non-public domain fonts if you require the digital asset to be handled as a secret (and all of the hassle that goes along with that).

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by wnevets on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:02PM (#20463379)
>Show me an attorney willing to pursue accidental violators for damages, especially when the asset in question is intended to be publicly served in the course of its use.

There are some pretty sleazy lawyers out there.

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/grandmother-sued-downloading-...

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by toomuchtodo on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:06PM (#20463430)
Usually the sleaziest are dealt with accordingly, but it is a fair point. Anyone can be sued for anything.

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/07/prenda-law-porn-...

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by mbreese on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @06:45PM (#20464796)
> non-public domain fonts

Why would anyone use a non-public domain / CC / open source font in a publicly available project? If the project has an open source license and is in a public repository on Github, why would there even been non-public resources (fonts, icons, images, etc) in the repository at all?

If you have any private resources (code or otherwise) in the repository, it shouldn't be in a public repo to begin with.

Are there any examples of open source projects that are including commercially licensed fonts?

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by teknopaul on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:28PM (#20463629)
Its pretty easy to get decent fonts that are cc licenced.

Toomuchtodo you are not an acidental violator after publishing this comment on hn :)

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:07PM (#20463441)
That's why I said "technically". Whether there are any damages or what they would be, I don't know.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by djsumdog on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:05PM (#20463413)
I guess the distinction is oh Github, a project might have an MIT License with a commercial font. Maybe the focus of this article should be, "be sure to include the license for your fonts, images and other assets in the LICENSE file" ?
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:28PM (#20463627)
This is inadequate with a commercial font: You aren't allowed to redistribute it at all. What you are speaking of is just an issue with open source fonts: Usually open source fonts have different licenses than software, and your license info needs to detail both.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by wodenokoto on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:21PM (#20463062)
The analogy you are looking for is: You can give away DVD's of the fight inside your bar, but not outside.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:35PM (#20463171)
Well, sure. The bartender can sell alcohol inside the bar but not outside the bar. Licensing can make these distinctions.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by traderjane on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @04:14PM (#20463503)
If another company performs backup on your data, is that redistribution? A lot of people use Github as backup.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @06:11PM (#20464554)
Yes, if it's public-facing. A private backup is probably fine. https://processtypefoundry.com/help/base/webfont-license-agr...
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by snek on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:24PM (#20463082)
Even better, what if I have it on github because github pages is my site host?
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by roywiggins on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:44PM (#20464376)
People who write font license agreements are not entirely morons. It's pretty clear what is and isn't allowed! https://processtypefoundry.com/help/base/webfont-license-agr...
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by zrobotics on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @08:22PM (#20465435)
I don't host w/ github pages, but when I was looking I don't remember there being any restriction on the repo being private. Why does the repo need to be public?
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by snek on Thursday July 18, 2019 @09:42AM (#20469649)
it costs money to be private
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by lr on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:30PM (#20463126)
As Steve Jobs would have said, "Boom!" Perfect example!
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by thaumasiotes on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @06:25PM (#20464665)
> What's the difference between putting webfonts on your public website vs putting them on your public github? This seems like a distinction that only lawyers would care about

As you suspect, there is no practical difference. The difference being perceived is that when you put them on your website, you're doing that for the purpose of displaying text using the font, whereas when you put them on github, the purpose of github is file sharing. The first purpose is good, the second purpose is bad, so the first use should be allowed and the second use shouldn't be, even though -- technically -- they are exactly the same thing. That's just a detail; they're spiritually different.

Unfortunately, this point of view is very much not limited to lawyers; it is how most people think about most things.

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by egypturnash on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @10:01PM (#20466025)
To use a font on the web, you have to munge it into a special web font format, which only a browser(1) knows how to display text with.

The files this article is talking about are not in that format. They are all TTFs, which you can drop into your system’s font directory and use anywhere on your computer.

Also, these TTFs are linked in a public manner rather than being a file whose link is buried deep in the page source where no human is ever intended to see it.

1: or font conversion tools

Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by hbosch on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @03:38PM (#20463193)
Github is searchable and has a big green “Download” button. I know, technically, getting a font from a website is more or less just as “easy”… for people without the ability to click “Inspect Element” and follow a link in the CSS, Github is far easier.
Re:Github became the web's largest font piracy site (2017) by mjbmitch on Wednesday July 17, 2019 @05:27PM (#20464219)
Distribution licenses are something people other than lawyers ought to care about.