News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by SmileyRedBall on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:41PM (#20443795)
What would it effect Bezos Net Worth to double the warehouse operatives hourly rate to $22?
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by steveads on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:52PM (#20443912)
Some back of the napkin math: 650,000 Amazon workers. Let's say 600,000 are min(ish) wage and get an increase from $11/hr to $22/hr. That's a 13.2B increase per year. Jeff Bezo's net worth is 165B. Jeff Bezo's Net Worth drops 8% after one year.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by jerf on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:09PM (#20444068)
Jeff's net worth isn't in cash. It's going to be affected much more strangely than your analysis suggests. If Amazon has to raise its labor costs that much, Wall Street will react in a way that is difficult to predict the magnitude, but easy to predict the direction.

Normally I'd suggest analyzing that 13.2B in terms of the profits of the company, which for instance last Jan 2019 was ~$3 billion, which if projected out for the year means you'd be proposing a pay raise larger than the profit margin for the company, which is definitely going to affect the stock price. But Amazon is a weird case where most people think that they can just turn on the spigots anytime they really want to just make money, so it's maybe not the easiest analysis.

But for most companies, they make less profit than people think, especially if they're looking at revenue numbers, and a lot of people tend to suggest things that would make a 6% profitable company (not a terribly uncommon number) become a -25% profitable company or something. Even if you tip all executive compensation back into profit, that doesn't usually do much for these large companies.

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by khawkins on Monday July 15, 2019 @07:12PM (#20446160)
Totally fair analysis and I don't disagree at all. I will add, however, that there are a few points that detract from this take.

First of all, when a company aggressively invests in hard capital, innovation, or advertising, they're building eventual value for the company and stock which improves the wealth of shareholders in the long run but rarely helps the entry-level employees in either the short run or long run. However, those costs are thrown above the line as costs and not financed by what is determined to be company profits.

When this innovation is necessary to stay competitive in the market then this is the invisible hand working properly to balance capital investment against worker living conditions. Eventually, many workers will benefit from the advancements in the form of cheaper/better goods.

However, when capital investment is used to rapidly grab near-monopolistic control of the market in an attempt to wedge out competitors, the invisible hand forces aren't necessarily at play.

If a company's leaders choose to grow at a modest pace and put more money into the well being of their employees they might not be able to grab such a dominant market share, but they'll have treated their employees better. Further, more competitors means that invisible hand forces will naturally improve services.

I think the general problem is that the FTC has been very lax in recent years. Vertical monopolies aren't treated very seriously as the means to establishing horizontal monopolies or oligopolies. On top of that, the companies are trying to jump off shore as quickly as possible to evade serious control.

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by jerf on Monday July 15, 2019 @09:26PM (#20446785)
A lot of this is why I didn't say it wouldn't affect Jeff at all, or try to predict the particular impact, but just that it would be... strange. Even if you could objectively analyze the full business picture, nobody could fully analyze exactly how Wall Street would react; the ability to do that would imply the ability to get very rich on Wall Street very quickly.

I forget where it was, but I also recently read an article musing on the idea that in the modern era we seem to have a new threat emerging where companies establish very, very firm footholds in some particular industry, and then use that to leverage their way into other industries because they can literally out-resource the entire competitor base of that industry. In some sense, in theory this has been possible for a long time, and we've had things like Samsung which are massive conglomerates, so it's not a new problem in quality, but the quantity of money that can be brought to bear this way in the 21st century may still make this a new sort of problem for trust busters to keep their eyes on.

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by bduerst on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:59PM (#20445229)
While you're right about Jeff's net worth, profit is also misleading as many times it's manipulated for tax gains/shield. Amazon is notorious for doubling down on reinvesting into capex and maintaining a thin profit margin.

Either way, Amazon profits would not be hit by the full $13B increase - more likely profits would remain unchanged, while capex and other investments would go down by that amount.

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by fao_ on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:15PM (#20444140)
If a company cannot pay it's workers properly then, to be honest, it really shouldn't exist.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by dmitrygr on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:38PM (#20444382)
The places these warehouses are at usually have low CoL, and $15/hour is GREAT wage there. People line up to get jobs there!
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by icelancer on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:24PM (#20444226)
People keep seeming to apply for jobs at Amazon warehouses making $15-16/hr, so...
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by bad-joke on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:01PM (#20444611)
Hundreds of people applied to work at the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by icelancer on Monday July 15, 2019 @05:32PM (#20445490)
Well, when Amazon warehouses in the United States are not up to code and burn to the ground, killing hundreds, the analogy will be pretty apt.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by jodrellblank on Monday July 15, 2019 @10:28PM (#20447028)
so ... what?

People keep turning up to work on third world garbage dumps for cents/day earnings, so...

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by marcusverus on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:40PM (#20445016)
Reducing demand for labor to increase wages? What could go wrong?
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by vecter on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:36PM (#20444358)
Define "properly"
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by zaksoup on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:25PM (#20444237)
This so much. All of this analysis is predicated on the idea that Amazon has made this value for its owners through legitimate means and not by underpaying, overworking, and dehumanizing vast swathes of their workforce. It's so bizarre to me that people think it's a reasonable argument to make that "X company couldn't do Y if they payed better" and the response is just a giant shrug and "I guess their workers will have to pee in bottles and get second jobs" and not "X company therefor can't reasonable do Y"
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by fao_ on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @09:21AM (#20449749)
You're getting downvoted but your point is bang on. I don't think people realise how horrible the conditions in Amazon's warehouses are. A year or so ago they hired ambulances to wait outside rather than turning the AC on in the warehouse. They would rather their workers risk death as opposed to paying money to cool them.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by zaksoup on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @11:25PM (#20456150)
> They would rather their workers risk death as opposed to paying money to cool them.

Or rather, it’s cheaper to hire EMTs than it is to climate-control fulfillment centers. Frankly, that seems like the strongest indictment of profit-as-sole-motive I’ve heard, but of course the HN thread can’t handle much in the way of criticizing capitalism or FAANG.

Comments spreading FUD that some sort of deep tech attach of google is responsible for all the negative press get upvoted to the top when the simplest explanation is maybe tech isn’t the perfect good thing everybody wants to believe it is?

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by steveads on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:14PM (#20444122)
You're totally right. Just wanted a quick easy way to estimate the minimum hit he'd take in an admittedly fictitious world where net wealth isn't tied to the company's stock price.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by OscarCunningham on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:08PM (#20444064)
If people expected Amazon to make a loss long-term then its share price would drop to zero immediately, taking most of Bezos' wealth with it.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by agsamek on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:52PM (#20443908)
Yep. The situation is similar to what Ford had. Salary increase might happen if they have a shortage of candidates. But will there be a shortage? Or are they just the best employer for a lot of people?
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by mparramon on Monday July 15, 2019 @06:26PM (#20445862)
Very relevant film about the topic: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5688932/
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by notatoad on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:25PM (#20444860)
What would it effect bezos's net worth to halve the required number of items picked per hour but keep the pay the same? Pay should be determined by the market, decent working conditions are what we should be fighting for. Amazon workers aren't poorly compensated, they're just working shitty jobs regardless of the compensation. Paying people more doesn't make abusing them okay.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by electrograv on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @01:04AM (#20447608)
If each employee was paid the same to pick half the items, then they’re effectively being paid twice as much to do the same amount of work. Amazon would have to hire twice the workers (if not more) to fulfill their order volume, which means shipping items becomes more expensive.

So the real question is: Who is going to pay the bill?

And the problem I see here is, whoever you ask this, the answer is always “not me!” Everyone wants to reap the benefits of cheap labor (e.g. cheap, fast shipping), while proclaiming they want to treat the labor force well, but without a willingness to actually “put their money where their mouth is” and pay for it when it actually comes down to it.

For example: If you could willingly add 50% to the cost of every Amazon purchase if it gave workers better conditions, would you? If your first reaction to that is “Hey, that’s not my problem! The [government/market/unions/etc.] should have to solve that!” ... then yeah, we’ll the thing is that’s what everybody says when asked these sorts of problems.

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by dlgeek on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:50PM (#20445130)
They have a $15 hour/minimum, so $22 isn't double.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by honopu on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:49PM (#20443880)
not relevant, free market, they decide to work there, or not.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by SmileyRedBall on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:55PM (#20443938)
> not relevant, free market, they decide to work there, or not ..

Yea they can decide to move to the next low-pay job, zero-hour contract, no benefits, wages barely pays the rent, on food stamps ..

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by switch007 on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:45PM (#20444452)
Exactly. The implicit argument is that there is always some magical high-paying job with awesome benefits just round the corner if they just simply make the simple decision of switching jobs and/or pulling themselves up by their bootstraps. Right...
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by bduerst on Monday July 15, 2019 @05:02PM (#20445244)
Rising tides lift all boats. The largest employers changing their hiring practices forces other employers to change as well, to remain somewhat competitive.
Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by jodrellblank on Monday July 15, 2019 @10:35PM (#20447056)
A free market would allow the employees to unionise to negotiate more effectively the employee side, like Amazon the company uses many people collectively to negotiate the employer side. But Amazon is anti-union and spends money to that effect.

If the free market is a fair market, unionising wouldn't make any difference as the negotiated rates would already be fair and couldn't be any more fair. Amazon wouldn't be spending money to block union efforts, because that would be wasted money. Therefore either this isn't free market, and your comment is wrong (not free market), or this is free market but it isn't fair so your comment is wrong (free market, yet still relevant).

Re:Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day by bancars on Monday July 15, 2019 @05:39PM (#20445553)
That’s an awfully easy position to take when you don’t have to work at an Amazon warehouse. How many times have you been fired for using the bathroom?