News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by throwaway5752 on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:34PM (#20443167)
Why is there so much attention on Google?

It's market cap is $800B. Amazon and Microsoft are roughly $1T. Facebook is $600B.

We're not a bunch of rubes here, to have this many articles proposing sanctions and/or breakup of Google has all the fingerprints of coordinated action. It's less than a month after the US president saying he would sue them because he felt they didn't give conservative sources favorable enough index ranking.

This has a stink to it.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by ijpoijpoihpiuoh on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:37PM (#20443205)
Some of the accusations are pretty thin too, this one included. Last I checked, Google doesn't make money off of organic Google Maps results, except inasmuch as Maps acts as a halo product.

What exactly is Google supposed to do here? Are they to require a validated business license to update one's listing on Google Maps? Besides the non-trivial expense associated with that, it would act as a barrier to entry for smaller businesses that don't have one, and you can bet there'd be articles on here hating that too (just like there have been about the GMail API changes).

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by CiPHPerCoder on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:49PM (#20443320)
> Why is there so much attention on Google?

Amazon declared tomorrow "Prime Day" and a lot of workers are striking today and/or tomorrow.

Throwing shade at Google would be a good way to keep technical people from paying attention to the plights of workers.

But it could also just be a coincidence.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by notriddle on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:09PM (#20444071)
> But it could also just be a coincidence.

It's not Prime Day, and there's bad press about Google. It's Prime Day, and there's still bad press about Google. Prime Day is over, and there will continue to be bad press about Google.

The word I'd go for isn't "coincidence." It's something more like Captain Obvious.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by djsumdog on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:58PM (#20443402)
I was thinking they were all guilt of this within the first paragraph. You use to have to beware on eBay, but the Amazon marketplace is just as full with counterfeits and bad products that it's like the new Wal-Mart. Newegg and Reverb both do the marketplace thing too, but their volume seems to be low enough to be hit with unsavory shops.

I heard about the problem with Google and locksmiths and was very careful the one time I locked my keys in my car without a backup a few years ago. I refused any locksmith that didn't quote an absolute price and found a local one that only charged $60.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by false-mirror on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:25PM (#20444868)
I'd love it love it love it if the richest companies had this little class solidarity. A nice change of pace.

I'd guess many anti-corporate sentiments are rising, and there's just some overlap in scheduling

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by chvid on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:55PM (#20443378)
I don’t know. But one should not be naive about it. The political machines have massive resources, strong connection to media and have nailed information campaigns down to an art.

I noticed a similar thing about a year ago when Facebook was in the crosshairs.

Having said that. These companies are obvious monopolies prone to abuse their power.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by 0xDEFC0DE on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:36PM (#20443190)
>This has a stink to it.

TBH so does using market cap to dismiss criticism of Google

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by ddalex on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:43PM (#20443260)
But it's not dismissing criticism. It's acknowledging that other big companies that have pretty similar issues are not coming under fire for the said issues.
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by eitland on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:43PM (#20445040)
As I have pointed out elsewhere (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20444182) Microsoft and Facebook has been under fire as well.

And yes, it was deserved for them as well.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by 0xDEFC0DE on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:46PM (#20443291)
Maybe they should talk about those issues and not bring up market cap because market cap really has nothing to do with any of this
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by opportune on Monday July 15, 2019 @01:38PM (#20443215)
Big news and small news alike have both been viewing Google with dollar signs in their eyes for the last 10 or so years, believing that their failure to adopt their business models to the internet is somehow Google's fault.
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by KirinDave on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:22PM (#20443622)
There is a major boycott of Amazon this week after it came out they're directly competing for military contracts that Google declined to take [0].

It's almost certainly the case that Amazon is helping and urging people to post negative stories about other high profile competitors, Google included, right now. That's just how tech journalism works. Amazon is just much better at it than less successful attempts like the "scroogled" campaign.

This does not dismiss the bad things Google does. However, it does mean that it's a good week to remind people to boycott Amazon any way they can in addition to holding Google accountable.

[0]: Although that outcome was largely driven by collective action from employees and reports of some employee retaliation were public as a result of it.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by ocdtrekkie on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:40PM (#20443774)
"It's almost certainly the case" without any evidence whatsoever? I mean, there's a lot of companies who have a reason to promote Google's fraud-based business model (mostly, companies being defrauded by it).

What would you say makes it "almost certainly" about Amazon?

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by KirinDave on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:40PM (#20444404)
Forgive me if it's a case of mistaken identity, but I seem to recall last time we talked you started harassing me on other social media sites demanding I answer your arbitrary questions and attempting to solicit distributed harassment.

Don't you think it's better for both our mental health and the tone of HN if we not argue about this, and perhaps agree both companies do bad things and scheduled boycotts of both can be a good example of collective action?

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by eitland on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:20PM (#20444182)
> Why is there so much attention on Google?

Because they’ve been behaving badly for years and a number of people like me will upvote anything that gives them a pounding (of course only if I think it makes sense.)

A better question should probably (again IMO) be why they’ve gotten away so easily for so long.

> Amazon and Microsoft are roughly $1T. Facebook is $600B.

Facebook has taken a lot more beating. All very deserved IMO, in fact I think they deserve a fair bit more, but at least they got more than Google AFAIK, which is reasonable.

Microsoft has been beaten so much by sysadmins like me, governments etc, both for fun and for profit that I don’t think anything Google or Facebook has experienced yet really compares.

Amazons time hasn’t come yet I guess.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by chrshawkes on Monday July 15, 2019 @03:37PM (#20444372)
Google's been stinking a long time my friend. The other companies you mentioned are also dealing with one bad publicity piece after another. Amazon strikes going on today for instance. 5 Billion dollar fine to Facebook etc...
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by ceejayoz on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:01PM (#20443433)
There's been a substantial amount of criticism for fraud on Amazon's ecommerce arm, here on HN and generally.

Microsoft's market cap is largely software/services, where fraud's largely going to impact Microsoft themselves. Bing Ads are likely peanuts compared to Google's offering.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by asark on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:32PM (#20444939)
Don't worry, there's plenty of room in my heart to hate and wish ill upon all the scummy fraud-enabling private dragnet spy corporations.
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by AJ007 on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:59PM (#20445225)
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by asdff on Monday July 15, 2019 @08:06PM (#20446443)
The top 10 tech companies are interchangeably flamed here and all over the internet and for good reason. This isn't a google problem, you just happen to be in a google thread.
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by throwaway5752 on Monday July 15, 2019 @11:21PM (#20447238)
Appreciate your comment, but I've been posting here in various capacities for about a decade and employed in tech for about twice that long.

I am not talking about HN's reaction, but the wider pattern of calls from high levels to investigate and break up Alphabet. It is functionally the same as AT&T and Time Warner - using the threat of antitrust and other powers of the FTC to get favorable treatment and harm adversaries. It is new and dangerous.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by forgottenpass on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:01PM (#20443428)
There is attention on all of them. And every time one of them gets bad press, someone is ready to point out that the current target is unfairly singled out from the others.
Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by catacombs on Monday July 15, 2019 @04:51PM (#20445145)
> It's less than a month after the US president saying he would sue them because he felt they didn't give conservative sources favorable enough index ranking.

Keep in mind that this is a hunk of crap.

Re:Google Legally Profits from Fraud on Its Platform by eclipxe on Monday July 15, 2019 @02:50PM (#20443891)
Charles C. Johnson