News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by theDoug on Monday December 27, 2010 @07:45PM (#2044169)
It'd be nice for Newsweek and other outlets to cover Mayer and her good work without it repeatedly being yet another spin of the old "Girls can do it, too!" trope.

Yes, they can do it, they've always been able to do it. Stop pretending it's surprising or 'news,' and you'll have fewer people incorrectly feel women are out of place in technology.

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by ars on Monday December 27, 2010 @07:53PM (#2044203)
Till that 15 to 17 percent changes (and it doesn't look like it will any time soon), that won't happen.
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by gregable on Monday December 27, 2010 @09:29PM (#2044385)
I'm curious if this is not only an effect, but also a cause. If the news reports that it is unusual for women to be in computing, doesn't that in a small way reinforce that message within popular culture? Newsweek should know better.
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by ars on Monday December 27, 2010 @09:40PM (#2044404)
So basically you want newsweek to lie in order to promote a social cause? Because right now it is unusual, so that is how they should report it.

Isn't that called propaganda, and is the job of the government and ad agencies? (And they've both certainly done it successfully for plenty of causes they've decided were important.)

Journalistic integrity is important - even if it goes against your social cause.

This is a very common complaint about journalists, that by reporting on it, they are causing it. It might be a valid complaint, but any attempt to fix it makes it worse.

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by dannyb on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:04AM (#2044793)
I think that article was essentially a propaganda piece, albeit unintentionally. My guess is that Newsweek puts out blurbs like that in order to reach out to a targeted demographic, in this case women.

The whole question of media bias really comes down to the bottom line. If a format of words plus carefully chosen images favored traditionally conservative causes (which for the most part they don't) there would be widespread complaints about right wing media bias. AS it is, I think there is very little remanent of journalistic ethics in mass media.

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by scott_s on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @09:04AM (#2045454)
It's unusual, but it's also obviously unusual. So, do you take the obvious story, or do you figure out something new? Not that I'd expect Newsweek to do anything else.
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by baddox on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:21AM (#2044832)
Will the industry actually benefit if additional women join its workforce, rather than anyone (regardless of gender) who is competent and wants to? I suppose it's possible that there's something to gain from diversity, perhaps from morale or just diversity of mindsets/ideas/backgrounds, but that seems like a bit of an immeasurable stretch.
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by pbiggar on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @04:03AM (#2045033)
From the article:

> Larry [Page] and Sergey [Brin] said, “You know, we have seven engineers, and they’re all guys. But we’ve thought a lot about how we want to start our company, and we’ve read a lot of books, and we know that organizations work better when there is gender balance. So it’s important to us that we have a strong group of women, especially technical women, in the company.”

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by lucasjung on Monday December 27, 2010 @09:03PM (#2044337)
Interestingly, that's about the same as the percentage of women in the military. I wonder how much of that is coincidence, and how much is driven by common factors (culture/climate? self-selection?).
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by _delirium on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @02:53AM (#2044955)
In tech's case, the extreme imbalance is fairly recent, though. Women are currently around 18-20% of new CS degrees, but in the early 1980s, they were 35-37%. Still a minority, but 2:1 rather than 4:1.
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by lucasjung on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @10:12AM (#2045626)
That's very interesting. Is this happening because fewer women are going into CS, or because way more men than women have gone into the field? A good way to answer this would be to look at some different statistics: what percentage of women college graduates majored in CS in the early '80s vs. today, and the same comparison for men. Of course, that doesn't answer the underlying question of why more men than women choose to major in CS.

CS was a relatively young discipline in the early '80s, so its share of total graduates has probably grown significantly since then. I'd be willing to bet that growth is due to both more men and more women entering the field, but disproportionately men. CS graduates back then were, in a sense, all "early adopters," so both the men and the women in the field were outside of the mainstream. It could be that men now consider CS to be mainstream, but women don't: among men, the discipline has grown as one would expect, but among women the discipline is stuck at an earlier stage. Of course, this just leads to further questions about why this disparity in adoption exists.

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by Jun8 on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @10:50AM (#2045728)
In addition to the media bias, I'm also thinking that Google is using Mayer as their "look how diverse we are" showcase. In almost all such stories about Google I see Mayer, aren't there equally accomplished women in Google? With a great 40-60 ration of women to men they should be.

Also, why have her wear that photomodel outfit? This is like asking Larry or Sergei wear a suit for photo shoot. I've seen her in many videos from her talks and she tends to wear normal stuff.

Edit: Here's an extensive look at Meyer's outfits: http://gawker.com/5174126/lesley-stahl-investigates-marissa-...

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by taylorbuley on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @12:16AM (#2044723)
I agree with your point, but before you bashed Newsweek did you read any of their previous Mayer coverage? http://www.newsweek.com/search.html?q=marissa+mayer

I think you'd have a hard time putting together a collection of "Girls can do it, too!" articles that outweigh all the regular coverage of Mayer and her work at Google

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by Qz on Monday December 27, 2010 @08:15PM (#2044246)
Yeah, this definitely seems like old news to me. Many of the girls I know consider themselves geeks in one way or another (and most of my friends aren't in the tech circle, so that's not an issue).
Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by haploid on Monday December 27, 2010 @10:56PM (#2044571)
And therein lies the problem with a definition whose meaning has been diluted to near meaninglessness.

"Geek" doesn't mean the same thing it used to, or even close to it. Teenage girls running around calling themselves geeks because they spend a lot of time playing angry birds on their phone is a far cry from the MIT Media Lab.

The same goes for latte-sipping hipsters who can use Garage Band on their MBP, or any other person who uses consumer technology as an end-user, then proceeds to proclaim themselves a geek, or FSM forbid, a hacker.

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by Qz on Monday December 27, 2010 @11:19PM (#2044612)
I don't see dilution of the definition as a problem. Video games used to be geeky. Now everyone plays video games. Everyone is geeky. To paraphrase Gordon Gekko, 'Geeky is Good.'

And for the record, many of them consider themselves geeks for legitimately geeky things, not 'playing angry birds on their phone' as you so derisively mention.

Re:Google's Marissa Mayer: Girls Can Be Geeks, Too by coderdude on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @10:29AM (#2045663)
Are you slightly angry at the outside world? Whenever I hear someone ranting about teenage girls and "hipsters" I think "social issues."