News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by m_myers on Monday December 27, 2010 @12:55PM (#2043074)
Hmm. I wanted to post a link to one of the comments (currently the second-newest), but apparently his comment system doesn't have permalinks. So here's a copy-and-paste:

---

MikeStansky (http://dilbert.com/users/MikeStansky)

Dec 27, 2010

I saw an amusing analogy on taxation:

Suppose that every evening, 10 men go out for beer and the bill for all ten comes to $100. If they paid their bill the way we pay our taxes, it would go something like this:

The first four men (the poorest) would pay nothing.

The fifth would pay $1.

The sixth would pay $3.

The seventh would pay $7.

The eighth would pay $12.

The ninth would pay $18.

The tenth man (the richest) would pay $59.

So, that's what they decided to do. The 10 men drank in the bar every evening and were quite happy with the arrangement, until one day, the owner said "Since you are all such good customers, I'm going to reduce the cost of your daily beer by $20". Drinks for the 10 men would now cost just $80.

The group still wanted to pay their bill the way we pay our taxes. So the first four men were unaffected. They would still drink for free. But what about the other six men? The paying customers? How could they divide the $20 windfall so that everyone would get his fair share? They realized that $20 divided by six is $3.33. But if they subtracted that from everybody's share, then the fifth man and the sixth man would each end up being paid to drink his beer.

So, the bar owner suggested that it would be fair to reduce each man's bill by a higher percentage the poorer he was, to follow the principle of the tax system they had been using, and he proceeded to work out the amounts he suggested that each should now pay.

Therefore, the fifth man, like the first four, now paid nothing.

The sixth now paid $2 instead of $3 (33% saving).

The seventh now paid $5 instead of $7 (28% saving).

The eighth now paid $9 instead of $12 (25% saving).

The ninth now paid $14 instead of $18 (22% saving).

The tenth now paid $49 instead of $59 (16% saving).

Each of the six was better off than before. And the first four continued to drink for free.

But, once outside the bar, the men began to compare their savings. "I only got a dollar out of the $20 saving," declared the sixth man. He pointed to the tenth man, "But he got $10!" "Yeah, that's right," exclaimed the fifth man. "I only saved a buck too. It's unfair -he got 10 times more benefit than me!" "That's true!" shouted the seventh man. "Why should he get $10 back, when I got only $2? The wealthy always win!" "Wait a minute," yelled the first four men in unison, "we didn't get anything at all. This new tax system exploits the poor!" The nine men surrounded the tenth and beat him up. The next night the tenth man didn't show up for drinks, so the nine sat down and had their beers without him. But when it came time to pay the bill, they discovered something important. They didn't have enough money between all of them for even half of the bill!

And that, boys and girls, is how the tax system works. The people who pay the highest taxes will naturally get the most benefit from a tax reduction. Tax them too much, attack them for being wealthy, and they just may not show up anymore. In fact, they might start drinking overseas, where the atmosphere is somewhat friendlier.

---

The comment id is 75340, if anyone knows how to hack the URLs.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by Daishiman on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:11PM (#2043123)
I don't buy this argument. The most prosperous nations have what might be considered "outrageously" high taxation rates on the rich, which the US used to have as well not that long ago. The countries which tax the rich to their favor are mostly tax havens and third-world economies that are plundered for their natural resources and the populance gets nothing in return.

Seriously, there are forms of wealth which don't add value to societies, and if those people aren't willing to get into markets because it hurts their bottom line too much, so be it. "The Rich" are not a universally good group that adds value to all the economies where they do business; they too have their part in fucking up a huge number of locations around the world.

Just as an example, Germany is one of the most prosperous nations in the world, and their economy is as socialist as it gets (in the European, modern use of the world, not the classical Marxist usage). Their labor force is highly skilled and sheltered, and its manufacturing base is strong. I don't see the same thing happening in the dirt-poor Caribbean tax havens.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by TomOfTTB on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:34PM (#2043206)
Germany's unemployment was 12.6% before Merkel took office in 2005 (http://www.icmrindia.org/Short%20Case%20Studies/Business%20E...). That's hardly prosperous.

She's done almost nothing but move the country further away from socialism and unemployment now stands at 6.7%. So I don't see your example as being very accurate.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by ceejayoz on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:44PM (#2043245)
Germany is still significantly more socialist than the US currently, and US unemployment is higher than 6.7%.

Also, apparently the lower German employment is due to a socialist program in which the government gets companies to lower your working hours and makes up the salary difference.

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/04/business/global/04dmark.ht...

> Part of the answer is that, in Germany, Trumpf could take advantage of government incentives to reduce worker hours rather than lay off people, a system known as short work. In the program, the government gives workers partial compensation for the lost wages.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by TomOfTTB on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:52PM (#2043272)
The question here is one of degree. The "short work" program was an austerity measure. It was put in place after Merkel steeply cut welfare payments.

Edit: Just to quote facts...

Welfare Cuts: http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20050104/business/...

(Though Germany's made further cuts since)

Short-Work Program: http://www.german-info.com/press_shownews.php?pid=1638

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by ceejayoz on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:24PM (#2043372)
You're still ignoring the fact that Germany is significantly more socialist than the US with a lower current unemployment rate. Using them as an example of how moving away from socialism is beneficial seems odd in that context.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by borism on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:34PM (#2043578)
second time you claim Germany is "significantly more socialist" than the US.

how does one measure "socialism" exactly?

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by ceejayoz on Monday December 27, 2010 @04:02PM (#2043651)
Level of social services, like social security, universal healthcare, etc. Are you disputing the claim?
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by borism on Monday December 27, 2010 @04:59PM (#2043781)
Yes I do.

First of all, Germany is social democracy, not "socialist". On the other hand US is liberal capitalist country - even slightest hints at turning it more towards European-style social democracy are instantly attacked as "communism" there.

Secondly, even if Germany is more of a social democracy than US, it's "a little more", not "significantly more".

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by mhd on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:09PM (#2043330)
"Kurzarbeit" is part of the reason, where the government pays 60% of the difference. But a lot of the low rate of unemployment is due to considerably less socialist reforms i.e. more lenient labor laws (compared to the previous German norm, of course). Temp jobs especially have seen a significant rise, with the usual lower wages, short-term contracts and avoidance of union restrictions.

And a lot of that has been initiated during the time when Schröder was in power – then head of the Socialist Democratic Party.

So it's really not that easy to ascribe it to certain political leaders or certain political ideologies. Unless you count pragmatism…

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by lkrubner on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:42PM (#2043237)
Germany has undergone a heroic transformation, absorbing East Germany and trying to modernize it. Considering that a quarter of the country was a complete basket case due to 60 years of Communist misrule, the miracle is how far Germany has managed to come in the last 18 years.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by TomOfTTB on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:44PM (#2043244)
Right but the fact that it cut it's unemployment in half in 5 years time while the rest of the world sank into a depression leads you to ask what they were doing that caused that. The fact that "what Merkel was doing" was moving the country away from Socialism contradicts the initial assertion that "Germany is a socialist as a nation comes and they're one of the most prosperous countries in the world"
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by Daishiman on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:24PM (#2043548)
I'll agree that many of Merkel's measures are not "socialist", but let's also keep perspective and realize that her measures do not shift the underlying social dynamics away from modern socialism's tenets, and that the changes appear as a general global trend of globalization and an aging population that makes maintaining the benefits more difficult than before.

Considering the fact that many countries have paid a much, much heftier price on their social welfare than Germany and have not improved substantially means that the balance need not shift as much as many people claim.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by lkrubner on Monday December 27, 2010 @05:07PM (#2043798)
Without a very precise definition of "Socialism" it is hard to engage in this conversation at a serious level. Germany has a number of features that people from English speaking, Common Law countries might find surprising. Germany still has the "co-determination" laws that gives every union an automatic seat on the Board Of Directors of large firms, and it has laws that make it mandatory that any company with more than 300 workers have one union member work full time on matters relation to those decisions that come under the review of the co-determination laws, including all hiring and firing. Germany still has laws that would seem extremely pro-union from the perspective of, say for instance, the USA. In Germany it is still assumed that the state should play a leading role in managing the interface between industries, schools and the apprenticeship programs. In Germany, the social safety net is extremely rich compared to English speaking nations such as England, Canada, the USA, New Zealand or Australia. To go 20 years without working a job, living on welfare, is common in some areas, especially in the still-recovering East. Education remains heavily subsidized. It is extremely difficult for a firm to fire anyone.

I would prefer it if people in this thread could avoid lazy labels like "capitalist" or "socialist" and instead speak specifically about what policies you think help or hinder German competitiveness.

I have trouble imagining that anyone would look at Germany and see it as a model of what an economy can do when the government does nothing - rather, in Germany, the government is everywhere. The state plays a leading role in all aspects of civil society. This does not mean that private sector players have no influence, however, the role of the state is large.

I'm uncertain what the original author may have meant by this:

"Germany is a socialist as a nation comes and they're one of the most prosperous countries in the world"

However, if you recall the debates that happened in Britain and the USA during the 1970s, Germany raises many interesting questions. Both Thatcher and Reagan came to power in a political environment where the labor unions were blamed for the competitive decline of Britain and the USA, respectively. Given the very strong unions in Germany, and Germany's competitiveness, some revision of the 1970s debate in the English speaking countries seems warranted. Apparently it is possible to have very strong labor unions and yet remain competitive.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by cma on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:56PM (#2043633)
Germany paid workers to work less hours. Socialist as hell and extremely effective.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by lkrubner on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:40PM (#2043226)
I have difficulty understanding why any discussion of taxes in the US becomes a conversation about the income tax. There are many, many taxes in the US. A rational discussion of taxes would include all of the taxes together. Most states have a sales tax, and the tax is regressive. Several states (North Carolina, Alabama and many others) make the sales tax much more regressive by putting a cap on it. I recall, when I lived in North Carolina during the 90s, the sales tax had a cap at $100. So the kind of everyday items that poor people have to buy would face the full tax, but plenty of consumer goods that the middle class bought (lots of consumer electronics, for instance) did not face the full tax since the items cost over $100. In essence, the poor were the only ones who had to the full sales tax on nearly everything they bought.

In almost all 50 states, the overall tax code is regressive - the middle classes are taxed more heavily than the rich. The regressive nature of the state taxes is offset by the progressive nature of the Federal taxes.

Imagine re-doing the above scenario of 10 men in a bar, but doing it in an accurate way, where there is sales tax on those beers - then the story comes out rather differently.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by simonsarris on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:47PM (#2043257)
This is why I prefer the New Hampshire model of no sales tax and no income tax. Instead, a large property tax and a (small) capital gains tax are in place.

This is far from the whole story, and NH isn't perfect, but the model of these four taxes seems to hurt the poor much less.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by scottostler on Monday December 27, 2010 @04:08PM (#2043663)
A 2006 NBER paper claimed that when taking into account a wider set of taxes (state income/sales taxes, federal/state corporate taxes, payroll taxes, etc), the US has roughly a flat 40% tax rate across all income brackets.

relevant msn article: http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Taxes/Advice/YourRealTa...

full paper: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.148...

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by amalcon on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:46PM (#2043430)
Here's the thing: just re-write the end of the story, and it makes the exact opposite point.

--

But, once outside the bar, the men began to compare their savings. "I only saved 16% out of the 20% reduction," declared the tenth man. He pointed to the sixth man, "But he saved 100%" "Yeah, that's right," exclaimed the ninth man. "I only saved 22%. It's unfair -he got much more benefit than me!" "That's true!" shouted the eighth man. "Why should he get 100% back, when I got only 25%? The poor always win!" The eighth, ninth, and tenth men got together and talked to the bartender, who (because their money was keeping him in business) agreed to no longer serve the group unless they adopted a less progressive schedule.

And that, boys and girls, is how the tax system works. The people who pay the highest tax rate will naturally get the least benefit from a tax reduction, but they have the most power to explicitly direct a reduction to themselves.

--

Note that however it may seem, I don't mean to argue a particular position by this. I'm only pointing out how changing a little piece at the end completely changes the message of the parable. It's a complete hypothetical either way. I've been calling this the "Fallacy of the Parable": using a parable in place of a reasoned argument.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by hnal943 on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:00AM (#2044784)
You can re-write the parable if you wish, but it no longer mirrors reality. Any reduction in tax rates is commonly decried as "Tax cuts for the Rich." No one says anything like , "the poor always win!"

Obviously, a parable is only as good and the truth it illustrates. If the parable is implausible (like your revised version), it obviously carries no weight.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by amalcon on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @09:07AM (#2045459)
It doesn't matter how "plausible" it is, only whether or not it's actually happened. If it has not actually happened, then it carries no weight in an argument.

Parables are good for teaching children lessons, but not as evidence for a particular viewpoint.

(Also, you may not hear people say things like "The poor always win." That's because that side prefers to a different sort of emotional appeal; I hear things that express the same sentiment all the time. Nobody discusses economics in good faith, which is part of the problem.)

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yequalsx on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:37PM (#2043218)
Suppose the tenth man controlled 99% of the wealth. Would his/her reaction be justified in going to another bar? Would the reaction be justified if at least part of the wealth of the tenth person came from the work of the other nine? If it came from being in a country with roads, education, national defense, and smart worker then is it proper for the tenth person to view all of their wealth as theirs alone with no obligation to other?
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yummyfajitas on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:55PM (#2043454)
If it came from being in a country with roads, education, national defense, and smart worker then is it proper for the tenth person to view all of their wealth as theirs alone with no obligation to other?

Ok - the tenth worker has an obligation to pay for this stuff. But about 60% of the government budget is just wealth transfers, and has nothing to do with the public goods you mentioned. Why does the tenth worker have an obligation to pay for that?

(I'll ignore the fact that education is a private good. I'll also ignore the many wealth transfers hidden inside the public goods you describe, e.g. inflated teacher comp packages, unnecessary military spending which funnels money to various congressional districts.).

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html (All #s taken from official sources. I use this link because it is t he only source I've found which combines both state and federal numbers into one chart.)

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yequalsx on Monday December 27, 2010 @04:05PM (#2043658)
One shouldn't include Social Security in government expenditures because it's a pension system that is funded largely by the recipients. It's also not in trouble. Medicare and Medicaid have problems but not Social Security. Social Security is a government run pension system so it is included in budget numbers.

It is for the reasons I've stated that Social Security is not part of the discretionary budget. The discretionary budget is dwarfed by defense related spending. And this is just the 'on the books' spending in defense related activities. When one factors in the supplemental spending on defense activities then the share of defense spending is even greater.

Highways, national defense, and education are a large majority of the discretionary budget.

Edit: I'm only talking about federal spending as that is what the topic of discussion appears to be.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yummyfajitas on Monday December 27, 2010 @04:18PM (#2043688)
SS is a redistribution scheme which funnels money from the young to the old. It's also not funded by the recipients - the recipients voted to borrow money from it, spend that money, and now expect other people to pay back their debts. It's a transfer no matter how you slice it. All pyramid schemes are about redistribution - they have no other purpose.

Same thing for medicare, medicaid, welfare, and even big portions of defense and education. See the numbers I linked to - most government spending is redistribution, not public goods.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yequalsx on Monday December 27, 2010 @04:36PM (#2043723)
Social Security is a pension system very much like any other pension system. It is currently actuarially sound. Like all pension system it assumes a certain percentage growth per year and part of the pension payout a person receives will come from such growth. It is not a redistribution scheme. It's a pension system. It is well funded in an actuary sense. It is not properly a government expenditure and therefore is not counted in the discretionary fund.

You may count it as a government expenditure and count payouts from this pension system as a government expenditure but this is contrary to how this is normally considered.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by hnal943 on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:15AM (#2044819)
Virtually every private pension system in the United States has been stopped for the reason that they are not actuarially sound. The reason for this is that population is not growing steadily as the model predicts. The baby boom was an anomaly that will wreck the system.

The major reason that US car companies struggled so much over the last decade is that they are saddled with pensions that foreign car manufacturers are not (e.g. Toyota). They sold as many cars, but their profit per car was less because of pension obligations to workers no longer producing for the company.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by johngalt on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:21PM (#2043361)
Even if the wealth came from a weekly poker game where purely chance determined who was wealthy, and it was zero sum. Wouldn't it still be reprehensible to expect the winner to pay the tab just because he won?
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yequalsx on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:57PM (#2043461)
Just about everyone who makes a great deal of money does so because of the type of society we live in. Does so because of the type of workforce we have. Is protected by the police and our military. The analogy you've given is a bad one because of these facts. Living in a society is not analogous to a poker game.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by johngalt on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:56PM (#2043634)
You put the cart before the horse. Society doesn't create wealth, wealth creates society. Consider the ghost towns of the southwest. Strike gold and an entire town springs up overnight with theatres, shops, bars, schools, etc... When the mine runs out it all dissappears as quickly as it came; regardless of how large the workforce of the miners, or effective the law enforcement.

I do agree that it's not analogus, because it's not zero-sum, and it's not decided by chance to the same degree. If anything making the scenario more unfair.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by eftpotrm on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @04:59AM (#2048400)
You're talking about society at the micro-level though, not the national level. Some of them were immigrants from outside but a large proportion were moving from other communities in the nation and their ability to do that while retaining their previous prosperity was insured by the society they were investing in through their tax code.

I actually think insurance can be quite a good model of the tax system. I'm insuring my assets against a total societal breakdown and confistcation, a la the Bolshevik revolution. I pay more than some because I have a higher asset base to lose but less than others who have more than I.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yequalsx on Monday December 27, 2010 @04:09PM (#2043670)
Whenever humans congregate in sufficient numbers a society is formed. This has been going on for at least the last 10,000 years. This has nothing to do with wealth as far as I know. At least, not in the sense that the term is colloquially used.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by richcollins on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:06PM (#2043321)
It's a fallacy that all wealth is controlled and not created
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by billjings on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:34PM (#2043579)
Likewise, it's a fallacy that all wealth is created and not controlled.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by luigi on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:34PM (#2043208)
Why do arguments against progressive taxation always involve hypotheticals? "Suppose that blah blah blah..."

Why can't they use real people and real numbers?

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by lkrubner on Monday December 27, 2010 @05:19PM (#2043828)
You write:

"Why can't they use real people and real numbers?"

I would suggest that simple models can help clarify things, in a way real situations do not. People use simple models in math, physics, medicine, sociology, statistics, economics, finance, chemistry, ecology, climatology, astronomy, etc. In almost every field of inquiry, people attempt to build simple models to try to get at the underlying truth of some situation. Real events are full of complex interactions, which often involve more variables than can be easily understood. The human brain is not set up to understand real events in which 200 variables all have some influence.

Issac Newton was offering a simple model when he said all matter attracts matter, proportional to its mass and inversely proportional the square of the distance - his model does not explain everything in the Solar system, it especially failed to describe the orbit of Mercury, but it did offer wonderful insight all the same.

Lister and Pasteur were both offering a simplified model when they advanced the germ theory of illness, and yet their model offers wonderful insights into disease.

Gauss offered simple models for more things than I could possibly list here - some have argued that he was the most important mathematician of all time. He contributed something to group theory, geometry, analysis and he largely invented statistics. And what is statistics, but a set of methods for quantifying simple models or sorting relevant data from the irrelevant?

With only slight exaggeration, I could make the argument that the progress of science is the progress of simplifying models.

That is the argument for not using "real people and real numbers".

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by Vivtek on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:02PM (#2043303)
That would be economics. Nobody in American politics listens to experts like economists - they only listen to "real people", who are above all that elite liberal claptrap they teach in schools.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by m_myers on Monday December 27, 2010 @06:15PM (#2043962)
If you'd stopped at the last comma, I'd be right there with you.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by napierzaza on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:28PM (#2043382)
"guys drinking beer" is highest amount of complexity that american politicians are willing to use. It's so simple, they're all the same people with the same opportunities, some are just poorer than others... right? There's not barrier to entry, plumbers just don't apply for the CEO positions.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by hnal943 on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:06AM (#2044797)
There are also barriers to entry to becoming a plumber. And there's no reason a plumber couldn't easily become the CEO of his own plumbing company.

People are largely in charge of their own destiny in America (as well as many other countries). No one is made a CEO by birthright.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by Semiapies on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:19PM (#2043530)
Simplest reason? Hypotheticals can be simple enough to talk about without spinning off a dozen side discussions about the details of a real situation.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yummyfajitas on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:41PM (#2043410)
Most political arguments involve hypotheticals - arguments against progressive taxation are nothing special. See, for example, Krugman's continual use of the baby sitting coop example.

The real data is usually not as convincing as toy examples, analogies, or assertions that your political opponents are pure evil.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by jcl on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:09PM (#2043499)
Actually, the babysitting co-op is a bad example of a hypothetical situation, since it uses real people and real numbers.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_Hill_Babysitting_Co-op

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by yummyfajitas on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:21PM (#2043538)
But using it as Krugman does, namely as a predictive model of the real economy, is little but analogy.

So technically that's an analogy, rather than a hypothetical. My bad. It's still a far cry from using real people and real numbers to argue for inflationary monetary policy.

(Incidentally, one very common liberal hypothetical is that "tax cuts for the poor have a higher velocity than those for the rich, since the poor live hand to mouth and must spend everything they get." It turns out this is false - the poor pay down their debts with tax cuts, while the upper middle class spend it. http://www-personal.umich.edu/~shapiro/TaxRebates.pdf http://papers.nber.org/papers/w16246 )

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by borism on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:33PM (#2043577)
inflationary monetary policy

which other monetary policies you know of? inflation is the underpinning of monetarism - very little to do with Krugman or liberals.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by hnal943 on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:10AM (#2044806)
I suppose the alternative would be a stable monetary policy.

The difference would be that under a stable policy you would only print money to keep the currency stable as inflation occurs, rather than printing money to fund government initiatives.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by borism on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @04:03AM (#2045031)
And how exactly would you differentiate between printing money "to fund government initiatives" and printing money to fuel the economy?

The fact is, even if all the money printed would be given away to non-governmental entities (that is, central bank would not be engaging in Quantitative Easing), it will still be funding the government (e.g. some of it will be collected back as taxes).

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by antidaily on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:32PM (#2043203)
attack them for being wealthy...

/groan

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by jread on Monday December 27, 2010 @03:06PM (#2043492)
Let's add to this hypothetical... assuming a similar distribution of wealth as in the US and these 10 men had a total wealth of $1000. The top 2 would hold $425/each, the next 2 $50, the following 4 around $10, and the remaining 4 $2.25.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by gnosis on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:56PM (#2043286)
"Tax them too much, attack them for being wealthy, and they just may not show up anymore. In fact, they might start drinking overseas, where the atmosphere is somewhat friendlier."

Laws could be passed to keep wealth from moving overseas without being taxed first.

It's very simple. All it takes is political will.

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by bcrescimanno on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:11PM (#2043337)
So the answer is for the government to rob people of what they've earned? Doesn't sound very American to me.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by gnosis on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:18PM (#2043357)
Well, whether they've "earned" that money is debatable. And really immaterial to the question at hand.

As for using terms such as "rob" and accusations of not being "American" enough, let's save the ideology and inflammatory rhetoric, shall we?

Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by bcrescimanno on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:30PM (#2043383)
What word would you use to describe the government taking money from people who decide it's no longer in their best interest to participate in that government?
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by gnosis on Monday December 27, 2010 @02:39PM (#2043404)
Tax.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by hnal943 on Tuesday December 28, 2010 @01:18AM (#2044826)
Theft.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by TheSOB88 on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:40PM (#2043229)
A perfectly self-consistent view. But it says nothing about reality - how do we know this is really like what we have here?
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by alf on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:47PM (#2043259)
Except the rich man in this case is still drinking beer (benefiting from government services) while not paying any of the bill.
Re:Scott Adams: Tax the Comfortable by gthank on Monday December 27, 2010 @01:55PM (#2043282)
The scenario explicitly says he didn't show up to drink with the other nine.