News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by jimbob45 on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:23AM (#20428486)
Can anyone steelman the Elsevier side? I don't want to be caught in the headlights of I have to debate this.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by xamuel on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:42AM (#20428575)
Not exactly steelman, but something you'll want to be aware of if you're going to be debating in this area: The publishers have attempted (and mostly succeeded) to poison the well by equating true open access (free to read, free to publish) with their garbage version of open access (free to read, $3000+ to publish). Once again demonstrating the power of controlling the language. It's going to be a tough battle as long as it's good-hearted activists fighting in their free time vs. full-time Elsevier PR professionals getting a salary to fight.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by titanomachy on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:54AM (#20428634)
So you're not a fan of PLoS? I always thought their model seemed fair.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by gumby on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:06PM (#20428716)
Good question. COnsider:

First, PLoS fees are lower and as a nonprofit only have to support operation (no profit). Also as a nonprofit there is some transparency as to where those fees go, so I assume that publishing there really does cost something like $1600.

Second PLoS's fee rules include the sentence "Authors' ability to pay publication fees will never be a consideration in the decision whether to publish."

Elsevier's "unfair advantage" (something we're supposed to look for on HN) or IP is their ownership of journals that acquired renown over decades. Publication in those journals as opposed to others has, depending on your field, tremendous effect on tenure and grant opportunities. It takes a long time to transfer that repetitional benefit to other institutions like PLoS.

That's why physics (with a more fluid tradition of journal bona fides and a wider use of preprints and passing papers around) was the pioneer field for open access and the like while, say, medicinal chemistry has been a laggard in this area. Doesn't mean the researchers want it that way, but those cultural traditions take a while to change.

If UCB and some other high profile institutions (I'm looking at you, MIT!) can declare a policy away from these journals it will provide cover to allow others to do the same.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by 0815test on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:57PM (#20428965)
> (I'm looking at you, MIT!)

You couldn't choose a worse example than that. MIT famously screwed Aaron Swartz legally over public domain (pre-1923) papers, by baselessly claiming that his access had been "unauthorized" when in fact it was entirely consistent with their own pre-existing policies! They are a bad actor in this whole issue and aren't going to do a thing.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by j1vms on Sunday July 14, 2019 @03:16AM (#20432155)
> famously screwed (over)

infamously is what you mean, particularly considering "screwed (over)" is very much an understatement in regards to the sombre culmination of that legal case. [0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz#MIT

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by gumby on Sunday July 14, 2019 @02:36AM (#20432012)
I'm an alum and I agree and I mentioned MIT because I think it should take a stand to atone for that.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by aj7 on Saturday July 13, 2019 @05:05PM (#20430157)
Greatest stain on MIT since Poole and Pyle.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by titanomachy on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:36PM (#20428851)
Physics has always been a pioneer when it comes to information. Didn't physicists basically invent the internet to make collaboration easier?

Also I guess some (theoretical) physics/math papers kind of stand on their own. If you proved the Poincaré conjecture, it doesn't matter if you post it in Science or on your WordPress blog: anyone in the field can verify the correctness of your work. Contrast with life science where reproducing work is hard and bona fides count for much more.

There's no inherent reason a non-profit can't provide those bona fides just as well, though. I also hope institutions do the right thing here.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by marcosdumay on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:30PM (#20429118)
> Didn't physicists basically invent the internet to make collaboration easier?

You mean the Web? For the Internet, no they didn't. It was created by a US military organization.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by xamuel on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:03PM (#20428696)
PLoS is less egregious since they "only" charge $1600 and waive it for authors who can't afford it. With Elsevier/Springer on the other hand, the author has to opt-in and pay about twice that amount or more, no waiver in sight. Of course, even $1600 is fantastic highway robbery for what you're paying for, which is essentially to store a static document on their website. (These days, most authors already prepare camera-ready copies of their submissions, and the additional edits journals make are often a net harm.)
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by titanomachy on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:28PM (#20428820)
They do charge $3000 for some of their journals (although the flagship is $1600 as you say). The waiver is probably the more important bit here.

It's not hard for me to imagine that a professional high-quality academic hosting service costs something like what PLoS charges. Their budget is probably publicly auditable. I work in enterprise software, though, so I've become kind of inured to seemingly absurd costs for technical solutions.

I used to work in academia, where I became inured to PIs spending crazy amounts (millions per year) on equipment and lab services, which makes me think $1600 for a publication really isn't that big a deal for most developed-world STEM labs. Although I'd rather they spend it on making post-doc salaries livable.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by lacker on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:54AM (#20428641)
The steel man for the Elsevier side is that nobody is forcing scientists to submit content to Elsevier journals or to read Elsevier journals. It’s a product that they create, so they have the right to price it as they see fit.

If Elsevier was really providing no value, why don’t scientists simply submit their work elsewhere? Clearly scientists and universities don’t really care about open access. If it was that important to them, they would just stop submitting content to non-open-access journals. The truth is that scientists care more about prestige than about open access. Elsevier puts a lot of work into making their journals prestigious, and scientists want that.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by braythwayt on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:28PM (#20428819)
It's not "prestige." Framing it that way makes it sound like Elsevier is in the vanity business, and academics are vain.

In actual fact, Elsevier is a gatekeeper to obtaining funding and making a living in research. Elsevier is rent-collecting, not selling an intangible feeling.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by kevinventullo on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:47PM (#20429229)
To be fair, Elsevier has no direct say in how that funding gets distributed. This is decided by various foundations, NSF, etc., who choose to use publication in Elsevier-owned journals as a proxy for quality.

(N.b. I am no fan of Elsevier, just trying to figure out how their power can be unwound)

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by im3w1l on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:45PM (#20429209)
So let's go to the root of this. What is it that the funding agencies value in Elsevier publications? That if it's published there it's a mark of high quality research.

Assuming Elsevier is killed off, someone else will have to put in the work of sifting good from bad. And that's not an easy problem, especially when many try to pervert the process for ideological gain.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by a3_nm on Sunday July 14, 2019 @08:04AM (#20432979)
> Assuming Elsevier is killed off, someone else will have to put in the work of sifting good from bad.

All of this work is performed by unpaid reviewers, not by Elsevier themselves.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by im3w1l on Monday July 15, 2019 @12:29AM (#20438124)
Elsevier delegates yes. But the buck still stops with them. They pick the reviewers, for one.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by Vinnl on Saturday July 13, 2019 @05:26PM (#20430263)
It might not be an easy problem, but it's not a problem that has to be tied to publication, and it's not a problem that has to be pay-to-win.

(Disclaimer: I'm part of a project that tries to sift the good from bad without those things.)

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by cybert00th on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:43PM (#20428891)
>Elsevier is rent-collecting, not selling an intangible feeling

Got it in one! And until that changes, the status quo remains - regardless of sites like schihub

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by hutzlibu on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:37PM (#20428857)
Because prestige mostly equals funding in research ...
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by warnick on Sunday July 14, 2019 @11:54AM (#20434077)
And makes a difference in tenure decisions
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by mirimir on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:37PM (#20429475)
That's exactly backwards.

Elsevier didn't create the high-prestige journals. They were originally published by universities and not-for-profit academic societies. And became prestigious over time, in one way or another.

Elsevier just bought them, and has been raising prices and bleeding them out.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by a3_nm on Sunday July 14, 2019 @08:02AM (#20432972)
> If Elsevier was really providing no value, why don’t scientists simply submit their work elsewhere? Clearly scientists and universities don’t really care about open access. If it was that important to them, they would just stop submitting content to non-open-access journals.

The problem is coordination: everyone would like to stop, there would be a huge collective benefit if everyone stopped, but the first ones who stop will be penalized, so no one wants to be among the first.

> Elsevier puts a lot of work into making their journals prestigious

This gives the impression that the journals are prestigious thanks to Elsevier. In fact, what makes the journals prestigious is the hard work of paper authors and reviewers over the last decades, none of which were paid by Elsevier.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by apo on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:52AM (#20428623)
Elsevier owns copyrighted material, which it licenses to individuals and institutions for a fee. The fee is negotiated on a case-by-case basis, which is no different than any other intellectual property such as movies, music, books, or software.

If a customer is unable or unwilling to pay the prevailing rate, then no access will be granted.

The argument that Elsevier uses unpaid academic labor and therefore should fall under some other system is a red herring. Authors signed over their copyright to Elsevier, and like any other copyright holder Elsevier can license its property toward any legal purpose that advances its business interests.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:40PM (#20429175)
Elsevier attempted - successfully, for quite some time - to create a gate-keeping oligopoly by inserting it as a choke point into academic publishing while providing no real added value.

This isn't about copyright, because original authors are forced to pay-to-play.

In a genuine copyright market, creators are paid in exchange for exploitation of copyright.

If they have to pay up to sign over their rights, that's not a copyright issue - that's extortion.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by TehCorwiz on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:05PM (#20428710)
It's not unpaid academic labor, it's actually exploitative labor. They charge the academics ~$3000 - 5000 to publish via any of their journals.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by rsfern on Saturday July 13, 2019 @09:03PM (#20431052)
The other unpaid labor is peer review — keep in mind that reviewers don’t get paid!
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by amluto on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:33PM (#20429735)
> Authors signed over their copyright to Elsevier, and like any other copyright holder Elsevier can license its property toward any legal purpose that advances its business interests.

I have two counter arguments here:

1. Funding agencies should not permit this. If I were to fund public research, the results should be public under an appropriate license.

2. Something is very wrong with the system if authors are willing to do this without being paid. If Elsevier paid the author $3k, that would be another story. (And possibly unethical.)

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by Vinnl on Saturday July 13, 2019 @05:28PM (#20430273)
> 1. Funding agencies should not permit this. If I were to fund public research, the results should be public under an appropriate license.

And more and more are they doing that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plan_S

Unfortunately, the US is still not on board - that would make a major difference.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by mirimir on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:16PM (#20429055)
> If a customer is unable or unwilling to pay the prevailing rate, then no access will be granted.

Sure, but access can still be obtained. For free. So they can sod off.

Edit: Elsevier and the like are predatory scum. They bought top academic journals, and have increased prices dramatically in recent decades. They're bleeding out the industry, as they ride it down to irrelevance. Just as some have done with the newspaper industry.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by hyperpape on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:49AM (#20428610)
My best attempt: without journals charging fees for access, there is a free rider problem where only a few institutions will support journals. By allowing Elsevier to charge, you force everyone to share in the costs. In a weird sort of way, the fact that universities haven’t yet put Elsevier out of business is evidence for the collective action problem.

I don’t really think it works, and the publication fees model might already be a good enough counter-argument, but it’s my best try.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by jhbadger on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:39AM (#20428560)
I would imagine that Elsevier would argue that they (and their fellow for-profit journal publishers) are providing a valuable service of being the gatekeepers of scientific knowledge and without them science would collapse in a chaos of confusion and misinformation. (Not that I really believe that's the case; things like ArXiv show that science can work without the involvement of journals open or closed at all, but that's not how the publishers see it).
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by dbmueller on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:59AM (#20428678)
I'm not sure arXiv is an example of doing without journals. arXiv doesn't involve peer review, so that any result published there are to be taken with a big grain of salt.

On the other hand, there are open access journals that essentially act as a layer above arXiv, so that the main added value is review.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by patrick5415 on Saturday July 13, 2019 @06:44PM (#20430611)
I don’t think science would suffer too much if we just abandoned peer review and committed to the arXiv route. Peer review does little to ensure research is actually rigorous. Rather, it mostly ensures the authors know how to play game: use the right language, cite the right people, and don’t stray too far from the current fad while simultaneously selling what they’ve done like it’s the hottest thing since relativity.

Once you’ve read enough papers, you don’t even have to invoke the replication crisis to see that most papers should be taken with a grain of salt.

Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by riku_iki on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:01PM (#20429585)
In AI field such layer is recognizable conferences, researchers compete to get their papers accepted, and conference committees are doing peer review.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by brighter2morrow on Sunday July 14, 2019 @03:46AM (#20432265)
My Steelman for Elsevier: they coordinate the peer review (giving your work more legitimacy), the marketing, and the distribution of your work. We all take Dropbox/Google Drive/iCloud for granted but actually keeping a searchable and relevant archive of your work on place forever is also a fairly involved process.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by ghostpepper on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:56PM (#20428961)
I can't believe I've never heard of this expression.
Re:Elsevier cuts off UC’s access to its academic journals by dredmorbius on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:18PM (#20429062)