News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by izzydata on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:36PM (#20422560)
That seemed obvious to everyone though so how did they ever get valued so highly? Is the whole point of companies like this to fool investors into giving them money and then keep the sham up for as long as possible?
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by DoreenMichele on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:45PM (#20422677)
Business is complicated, so some people earnestly believe that if they have a bit more time they can work out the bugs. In some cases, this is true. In others, it's not.

When it's not, it may seem like they are deluded or scammers. Maybe they are, but a more charitable interpretation is that business -- especially new businesses -- are like six blind men and an elephant, which means people can strongly disagree about the nature of the beast while both parties are simultaneously right about the pieces they know and understand and both are equally wrong in the aggregate.

You make a paper airplane. You toss it into the wind and see if it flies. No amount of debate (concerning what should fly) changes whether it did or did not actually fly.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by docker_up on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:39PM (#20422596)
VCs are generally greedy and stupid at the same time. They follow the herd more than any other industry. The fact they invest in something means little as to how savvy they are or how successful the product will be. 90% of all startups fail, and there have been plenty of spectacular implosions in the past and there will be plenty of spectacular implosions in the future. Bird will be the WebVan of this business cycle.
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by mushufasa on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:46PM (#20422689)
(edited to consolidate my comments) Here are the reasons I can think of

1) compelling if it all works out. Invest clear-eyed and hope the founding team figures out the roadblocks. Greedy but not stupid; most successful startups start by 'doing things that don't scale.'

2) Pattern-matching / top-down portfolios. Mobile apps. Sharing economy. Subscription businesses. Electric Vehicles. Internet of Things. A lot of investors decide on themes for portfolio before they look at investments. Scooter sharing ticks a lot of boxes.

3) Adverse selection. It's a simple idea - anyone can grasp scooters as subscription. So the simplest-minded investors chose this rather than more subtle ideas.

4) as another comment suggested, investors are playing a game of musical chairs between funding rounds. Chamath Palihapitiya claims this as the reason his firm is stepping back from VC -- so he's walking the talk here https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/10/start-up-economy-is-a-ponzi-...

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by tenpsafdl on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:56AM (#20426710)
I agree with Chamath Palihapitiya. VC money is like taking steriods. You get the muscles, but it will disappear once you stop taking them.

I have come to the realization that VCs are really bad at distributing resource. For all these pedigrees to show for, they all seems to be playing musical chairs.

Part of the problem I see is that most VCs don't have a founder background and most of them you meet are pretty arrogant.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by hef19898 on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:17PM (#20423019)
So, point two would mean that, in an environment that regards VC finding as success, any good idea, in the sense of getting VC funds, would optimize to tick the right boxes, wouldn't it?
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by mushufasa on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:59PM (#20423373)
If you think of VCs / founders as a marketplace, which it kindof is, then yes. You have a larger 'market' for selling your startup idea, and optimize the 'product' for 'fit'.

If you think of VCs as totally independent, open-minded, critically thinking professionals, dutifully providing a financial service, then no. You pick the VC for the idea rather than the idea for the VC.

The second case is the ideal, but assumes highly-competent VCs and founders with equalish leverage. I think the perverse incentives for VC partners (read Palihapitiya) and the lack-of-prestige factors for first-time founders break the model. But this seems to be more true for second-time founders with moderate success under their belt.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by tedmiston on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:54PM (#20423334)
Given the high percentage of startups that fail, I wonder what percentage of VC funds fail, where perhaps we can define fail as "return less than the S&P 500 over the same timeframe". I imagine the true answer is a much more difficult number to come by. Easier to get late money in a successful company and claim "qualitative success".
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by MegaButts on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:37PM (#20424273)
There's better data on this than there is for startups. Between 85 and 90 percent of VC funds (which is distinct from VC firms) lose money.
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by MegaButts on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:42PM (#20422635)
> 90% of all startups fail

There's no way it's that low. Maybe 90% of VC-backed startups, and even then I think it depends on how you massage the definition of 'fail'

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by tedmiston on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:59PM (#20423383)
It also depends on how you define "startup".

The informal definition we think of day-to-day is fairly fuzzy. There's nuance in differentiating a small business operated by a few people from a startup. Being venture-backed is a simple differentiator but there are still legitimate startups this would exclude, e.g., serial founders who don't need to raise or products that make money early.

With respect to "fail"... is an acquihire or an even-money, 1-3x exit etc a "failure". Probably, yes for the VC, but not necessarily for the founder. Accelerators are incentivized to count "successes" liberally as well.

With a more broad definition of startup, it's easy to see the failure rate at 99%+.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by jeron on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:49PM (#20422729)
https://www.failory.com/blog/startup-failure-rate

90% failure rate comes from research by Small Biz Trends

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by MegaButts on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:01PM (#20422865)
A cursory glance at that data tells me it makes no sense. They cite several industries with failure rates substantially below 90%, don't give a single instance of a failure rate greater than 90%, but tell us it averages out that way.

Also real estate businesses only have a 42% failure? So I have a greater than 50% chance of becoming a real estate mogul? I just don't buy it, and I don't believe those other numbers either.

And the only source they cite on the website, http://www.moyak.com/papers/business-startups-entrepreneurs...., doesn't really lend any explanation to their numbers.

I think their data is wildly skewed by sampling bias, as they claim to get their data from interviewing failed founders. Welp, they never interviewed me - how many other people have they never interviewed because they simply never knew the company existed? How many founders, after failing, go out of their way to talk about their failure?

VCs have a strong incentive to create a story that starting a company has a greater chance of success than it does, because it's low-risk for them and they want a churn of potential investment prospects.

I think 1% is a much more realistic number than 10%, unless we're limiting ourselves to Sequoia-backed post-Series A companies.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by bongobongo on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:41PM (#20422621)
Just because people have money to burn does not mean they earned it or acquired it through hard work and good thinking. Most people with money are absolute idiots just like everybody else. In fact, in many cases, and especially with wealth inequality as it is, they can afford to be stupid.

I am not joking-- I'm willing to bet that there is a direct correlation between inequality and stupid products/business models making it to market. When you can just keep trying new things until something sticks, you're not going to try very hard or act with much caution.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by JumpCrisscross on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:39PM (#20422605)
> how did they ever get valued so highly?

Bird isn’t WeWork. Yes, they’re unviable on a unit basis now. But that’s a hardware problem. They’ve grabbed market share; now they must build margins through R&D. The traditional model is R&D first market capture second, but there isn’t a fundamental reason not to go the other way when the R&D is reasonably feasible.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by organsnyder on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:46PM (#20422692)
How is their market share at all secured? It's not hard for anyone else to dump a bunch of scooters in a locale already swamped by Bird. Yes, users would have to install a different app, but my hunch is most users will use whatever scooter is closest and/or in the best repair (even if it means installing another app).
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:07PM (#20424521)
I doubt the app will matter long-term. Mapping and transportation will be dominated by Google, Apple, and maybe Uber. City bikes, scooters, ride hailing, and any other alt transit options will eventually be forced to completely integrate into those apps and be forced to operate as a commodity.
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by likpok on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:56PM (#20422815)
It's pretty irritating to install a new app and go through a new-user onboarding. I know that I've walked past scooters for a competing app in favor of one I'm using.

If I start seeing them around enough I might go to the trouble, but that requires a fair amount of density to start working.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by zucked on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:18PM (#20423563)
That works - to a price point. There's a threshold where the described behavior is overcome. I'm sure there's a marketing term for it (I don't know it) but the OP is not off-basis.

If some new company with deep enough pockets starts promising No Unlock Fee and $0.15/min, they could quickly capture a lot of Bird, Lime, etc's market share. They'd be burning cash at an unsustainable rate, but there is no moat between these businesses at the moment.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by Psyonic on Sunday July 14, 2019 @02:19AM (#20431963)
I could see this -- except Lyft and Uber are both getting in on the game, and people already have those apps, so if this is true, it's actually an argument against Bird, not for it.
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by lkbm on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:08PM (#20423470)
> But that’s a hardware problem.

I think it's a social engineering problem. If the scooters didn't get routinely destroyed by people 1. smashing them into curbs because it's fun or 2 tossing them in the river because they're obnoxious / blocking the sidewalk, I believe they'd be already be profitable, or at least close.

People hate the scooters. People who ride the scooters hate the scooters. Hell, I like the scooters, and I hate the scooters. :-)

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by xenospn on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:17PM (#20425907)
I was walking my dog down Santa Monica Blvd in West Hollywood when I was almost clipped by an idiot riding on the sidewalk while snap chatting. He was perfectly silent and was behind me, so I had no idea he was coming. He could've killed my dog and I would've been in prison for killing him immediately after. Since then I've come to hate scooters with a passion.
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by goobynight on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:22PM (#20423593)
A 3 month period of the police targeting this property crime would be awesome.
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by kumoflow on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:21PM (#20424633)
I would rather see the police spend 3 months ticketing everyone for littering. They are leaving shit on the sidewalks with no licences to do so.

I would also like to see them ticketing the riders for reckless driving/endangering of the people. I almost had an accident 2 weeks ago because some stupid riders decided to race on the street. I also see some of them riding in the sidewalks zipping through pedestrians and many times hitting their bags.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Saturday July 13, 2019 @07:12AM (#20427505)
Agreed. That part bugs me. Cities are effectively subsidizing sidewalk space for these scooters that we paid for with tax revenue (and continue to pay to maintain). Most business that want to capture a parking spot need to pay for that privilege, and scooter companies should have to pay for that as well.

And you’ll see that most scooter riders on sidewalks are going max speed. It has made walking in cities with these things a lot more annoying, and it was already bad enough with cars but at least cars are separated from walkers.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by sambroner on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:45PM (#20422671)
This is my thinking as well... however, my assumption is that the majority of R&D will need to go into operations innovation and brand new last mile mobility strategies.

Strong operations will allow bird to continue to cut costs.

(I'm hoping) There's still room to innovate on winterized, electric, single person products.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by docker_up on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:44PM (#20422664)
Their primary business is unavailable to them for half the year in most of the world because of weather, and half of the day. How is this multi-billion dollar business, if they already have 700M in funding and they want another 300M?
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by lkbm on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:11PM (#20423495)
I saw them used in the winter. I still see them used all the time in the dead of summer, in Austin.

They mostly replace walking, which people do year-round, throughout the day, and well into the late night. At least this is true in my neighborhood.

Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by alpha_squared on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:43PM (#20422644)
Is that the Theranos model?
Re:Hit by Big Loss, Bird Seeks $300M in New Funds by temp-dude-87844 on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:44PM (#20422669)
Fear of missing out. These risky bets fit into the long-shot side of part of a balanced portfolio, and if they do make it, those who have backed them are positioned to make good money. When the appetite of VCs cools, these get dumped on the public stock markets, where the cycle repeats once more.