News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by blakesterz on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:01PM (#20414418)
“A company like Facebook and others are expanding because they are running out of talent in Silicon Valley and San Francisco,” said Paul Leonard, a managing consultant at CoStar.

Honest question... is that really true? It reads like hyperbole or certainly an over simplification.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by kcorbitt on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:09PM (#20414521)
Facebook already pays its median employee $240k (https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/networth/article/Yes-me...). You can assume that at those salaries, they've already hired a large percentage of the Bay Area software engineers who meet their bar and are willing to work at Facebook.

So if they want to hire another, say, 5k engineers, they either have to somehow convince 5k people to move to the Bay Area or expand in satellite offices. Word on the street from local recruiters is that you can still get new grads to move to the Bay Area (for a few years at least), but it has become nearly impossible to get senior talent to move in because of cost of living and quality of life issues. So depending on the type of engineer they're looking for, yes, they may be effectively forced to expand in other locations.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by oarabbus_ on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:23PM (#20414720)
Strongly disagree. Have people here actually worked with former Facebookers or Googlers (or people who left for Facebook et)?

They are very likely to be very good and very unlikely to be bad. But they are not gods walking amongst us. There are hundreds if not thousands of professionals in the Bay Area who have the talent FB is looking for AND are working at nearby, lower-paying companies. Facebook pays higher than Amazon, Uber, and all kinds of "sexy startups". So I can't buy the scarcity of talent excuse.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by kcorbitt on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:30PM (#20414825)
I'm actually not sure how much talent Facebook could pick up locally by just opening the floodgates, which is what I believe you're advocating? I'm a former Facebook intern and Google employee, and don't plan on returning to either company even if it were the income-maximizing move for me (luckily, it isn't). Anecdotally, I've met many other local engineers who feel the same way.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by ohaideredevs on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:39PM (#20414962)
What didn't you like about working for Google?
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by blakeley on Thursday July 11, 2019 @09:02PM (#20417265)
What do you consider to be more income-maximizing than Facebook and Google?
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by blakesterz on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:14PM (#20414587)
I can believe that, but NYC is just as bad, maybe even worse, isn't it? Seems like "out of the frying pan into the fire".
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by kcorbitt on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:22PM (#20414699)
Software engineer salaries are fairly comparable between NYC and the Bay Area, although most quantitative sources I've seen have NYC coming in slightly lower. But NYC could have a large number of engineers who (1) are willing to work for Facebook (2) for $240k but (3) are unwilling to leave NYC.

Expanding their NYC office will allow Facebook to hire more of those engineers without lowering their hiring bar or further fragmenting campuses.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by ghaff on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:58PM (#20415200)
At a minimum, NYC is just very different from SF and the South Bay. Leaving aside costs and salaries, which are both probably a bit higher in the Bay Area, the environments overall are just a lot different.

Lots of people who love the access to nature, the climate, etc. in the Bay Area would never move to NYC. And lots of people who consider anyplace that's not Manhattan to be a provincial hick town would never move to the Bay Area.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by tombert on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:10PM (#20415295)
> Lots of people who love the access to nature, the climate, etc. in the Bay Area would never move to NYC. And lots of people who consider anyplace that's not Manhattan to be a provincial hick town would never move to the Bay Area

I'm closer to the second camp (though I live in Brooklyn).

Something a lot of people don't seem to realize is that there are a lot of very smart people working on trading apps for big banks on Wall Street that absolutely hate it. High Frequency Trading apps require a ton of programming talent, but a lot of the engineers who work on this stuff really dislike the bank atmosphere. When I worked at Jet.com, I had several coworkers who were substantially smarter than me, who actually took a paycut to work for Jet, simply because they hated the bank environment so much.

I think some of the tech companies know this fact, and feel that they can probably poach some of this talent by offering competitive salaries while having a more interesting atmosphere.

EDIT: DISCLAIMER

I work for one of these "primarily California companies expanding stuff to NYC".

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by ghaff on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:24PM (#20415439)
I actually like visiting Manhattan but I don't think I could ever tolerate living there. I spent a summer interning in Midtown for a small consulting firm while in business school. We're admittedly talking pre-Giuliani New York in the summer with very little money but it still wore on me to the point where I pretty much decided I wasn't interested in working there.

I do, on the other hand, understand the attraction of the Bay Area given enough money although, in this case, the negative side of the balance sheet has gotten much longer and redder.

I agree with your basic point. Another reason I never seriously went after an investment banking job was that the sort of thing I was interested in was pretty much viewed as grunt stuff that techies did, i.e. not really respected.

(ADDED: I was using Manhattan as a term for the [nice uber-urbanized] parts generally although I know that's not accurate. I don't think I ever set foot in Brooklyn until relatively recently.)

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by bobthepanda on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:59AM (#20418596)
The nice thing about New York is that the transport infrastructure, while unreliable, exists so that you could live anywhere in the five (well, four) subway connected boroughs that pleases you. Want to live in a leafy suburb with a modest front and back yard? Head to Queens!

The Bay Area’s transit system is a joke in comparison; if companies have to resort to a private shuttle system to get anything done, it’s reflective of a failure in planning.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by opportune on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:21PM (#20415409)
I think big tech companies are so large that they've realized that if they keep pumping $200k-$500k/yr employees into the bay area (that weren't there before):

1. Housing prices will continue to increase since the supply is not changing yet demand (and ability to pay at current prices) is increasing

2.1 Gentrification happens and existing bay area natives get more adversarial to tech companies

2.2 Existing employees experience a decrease in QOL if comp packages remain the same

3. Tech companies keep having to increase TC packages to keep their employees' abilities to purchase homes

Also by expanding into other large markets tech companies can hire people who have lots of ties to an area and don't want to move. This has an added benefit of perhaps not having to offer as much TC since these markets might be less competitive.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by novok on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:26PM (#20415465)
NYC TC is fairly close to SF TC.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by i_am_proteus on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:34PM (#20415545)
However: 1) Software (&c.) is not the dominant industry, so rising salaries in software does not have an outsized effect on the real estate market.

2) The NYC housing market, unhealthy as it is, is healthier than the SF Bay Area's. NYC is somewhat less geographically constrained and, importantly, has excellent public transit infrastructure for long-distance commutes from lower-cost outer suburbs.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by novok on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:26PM (#20422458)
So it's even better, not considering the bad career effects of not being at HQ?
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by opportune on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:40PM (#20415604)
The NYC housing market is larger and healthier so an increase in X employees there will have less of an impact than an increase of X employees in SV
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by thorwasdfasdf on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:44PM (#20415038)
They can certainly find more talent in the bay area, if they were willing to pay even more.

In SV and SF, half the paycheck goes to the GOv and the other half goes to real estate.

If you want to cut labor costs, Simply find a city with a lower cost of labor. There's plenty to choose from: Austin, Dallas, Houston, Chicago, etc. All of these places sport roughly 100K salaries for senior devs. They could hire all the engineers they wanted.

And of course, there's always the final (least palatable) option: Improve your highering process. It's pretty ridiculous when half the employees of your own company wouldn't hire the other half.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by i_am_proteus on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:28PM (#20415479)
California's tax code contributes to housing illiquidity in the SF Bay Area.

A dev who bought a home eight years ago has a substantially different net income after housing and taxes from a similar dev who would be moving to the area.

So there's some merit to the idea that SV/SF have a fixed number of developers for whom salaries in the $150k-250k range are excellent, and another pool of "new arrivals" for whom that salary is decent/good, but results in a substantially lower quality of life. Further raising salaries distorts the real estate market even more.

Since SV/SF/California seems uninterested in the political moves necessary to improve the housing supply (sensibly, as these market changes would negatively impact the voters who have bought into the current system) the natural result is to move to other geographic markets for talent.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by pat2man on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:46PM (#20415064)
Not if the engineers don't want to live there...
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by thatonedevguy85 on Thursday July 11, 2019 @05:06PM (#20415849)
There's plenty of engineers that already live in those cities though?
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by coolio2657 on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:09PM (#20415280)
Which, in all likelihood, is the primary reason why Silicon Valley does not want to move out of Silicon Valley.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by dba7dba on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:10PM (#20414530)
I've seen more than a few posts at here where candidate for jobs in Silicon Valley is given an offer but turns it down because they don't want to move to Silicon Valley/San Francisco for various reasons.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by RhodesianHunter on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:15PM (#20414600)
Various reasons usually boiling down to an obscene cost of living. For most of the other major cities in the US (excluding maybe NYC, Boston, Seattle, DC) a salary doubling wouldn't make you whole for a move to the Bay Area.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by mikeash on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:44PM (#20415034)
DC here. Any time I’m distressed about the cost of living, I just look at the Bay Area. As far as I can tell, housing is at least 3-4x more expensive. Even on a senior engineer’s pay, your choices come down to something tiny or something that requires a very painful commute.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by d1zzy on Thursday July 11, 2019 @07:11PM (#20416738)
I wouldn't go that far... or maybe it depends on what you define as "tiny".

For a place to rent you can find 2500 sqft higher end apartments relatively close to work for 3000-3500 a month. The total income of a senior engineer when you factor in the stock compensation (and not just the base salary) should more than cover for that. On top of it, many other things cost the same across the country (ex. gadgets) while your salary is much higher than other places.

Now if by "cost of living" you mean that you must _own_ a single family home, then things definitely start looking a lot more grim. But I think it's unfair to make that as some sort of basic requirement for moving somewhere, it's a very American attitude to begin with.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by mikeash on Thursday July 11, 2019 @07:20PM (#20416787)
It’s a basic requirement for me to move somewhere. I don’t much care if that’s fair or not.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by gkuan on Thursday July 11, 2019 @10:49PM (#20417694)
Where can one find 2500 sqft apartments for 3000-3500? Very curious.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by redis_mlc on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:12PM (#20426097)
You can't in SF. Anything new would be under 1000'.

I know of some in the 1500' range, which is huge, on the peninsula, but I'm not telling anybody.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by walshemj on Thursday July 11, 2019 @04:21PM (#20415407)
I suspect the availability of better public transport allowing a commute from 50/60 miles on the train which in turn allows you to buy a nicer bigger property.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by betterunix2 on Thursday July 11, 2019 @05:28PM (#20416029)
I suspect that most of the young tech and finance workers in NYC live in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens (LIC in particular), Jersey City, and Hoboken -- all of which are expensive and right in the center of the metropolitan region. I am sure some recent college graduates are commuting from the suburbs but for the most part suburban life attracts people who are more established in their careers (and who are not planning to stay out late enough that the late night LIRR/MNR/NJT schedules are a consideration).
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by walshemj on Thursday July 11, 2019 @06:31PM (#20416493)
I was thinking couples in there late 20's who might want to start a family - I suspect that FANG employees median age is creeping up
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by president on Thursday July 11, 2019 @05:03PM (#20415823)
They are not running out of talent but they are running out of starry-eyed tech dreamers and people that can be exploited of their passion. The SF Bay area tech scene is fizzling out and the excitement is long gone. Also, this is a chance for top tech execs and their friends to capitalize on the real estate speculation game as they reinforce the new talent pipeline to NYC.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by bobthepanda on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:03AM (#20418619)
The time to buy and speculate in NYC was 20-30 years ago. You can speculate now, but the metro area is so large that even a large company building a regional office there would be a drop in the labor market.
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by ryacko on Thursday July 11, 2019 @11:01PM (#20417742)
Disney owns a city in Florida (Reedy Creek Improvement District), Scientology owns a city in Florida (Clearwater)...

I would assume that the best real estate speculation would be to buy land with higher margins.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by fred_is_fred on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:03PM (#20414440)
I guess they looked at a map and picked the most expensive US city they could find then?
Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by nradov on Thursday July 11, 2019 @03:09PM (#20414520)
Talent is a myth.

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2002/07/22/the-talent-myt...

Labor costs are high and growing in the SF Bay Area but there are many other areas that would work just fine for a tech company HQ.

Re:Big technology companies are doubling down on New York City by coolio2657 on Thursday July 11, 2019 @05:35PM (#20416089)
While the article you reference is quite good, if I do say so, as it points out many aspects of how people 'exude' superiority more than they actually are 'superior', or 'more talented' than others, straight up saying that "Talent is a myth" is none-sense. Your view should be more nuanced.