News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by apo on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:58PM (#20329685)
> The new law amends existing law in the Commonwealth that defines distribution of nudes or sexual imagery without the subject's consent —often called revenge porn —as a Class 1 misdemeanor. The new bill updated the law by adding a category of "falsely created videographic or still image" to the text.

This is a strange law:

> Any person who, with the intent to coerce, harass, or intimidate, maliciously disseminates or sells any videographic or still image created by any means whatsoever that depicts another person who is totally nude, or in a state of undress so as to expose the genitals, pubic area, buttocks, or female breast, where such person knows or has reason to know that he is not licensed or authorized to disseminate or sell such videographic or still image is guilty of a Class 1 misdemeanor. For purposes of this subsection, "another person" includes a person whose image was used in creating, adapting, or modifying a videographic or still image with the intent to depict an actual person and who is recognizable as an actual person by the person's face, likeness, or other distinguishing characteristic.

https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/18.2-386.2

A kid makes a pencil drawing of the school principal in a compromising situation and posts it to Instagram.

Legal?

A very talented artist creates a realistic watercolor of the President in a compromising situation with Kim Jong-un and posts to Instagram.

Legal?

A kid uses software he downloaded to generate a realistic depiction of the school principal in a compromising situation and posts it to Instagram.

Legal?

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by sandworm101 on Monday July 01, 2019 @06:17PM (#20330277)
Fine print.

>> where such person knows or has reason to know that he is not licensed or authorized to disseminate or sell such videographic or still image is guilty of a Class 1 misdemeanor.

First amendment gives authorization. Had they meant the more colloquial "without permission of the subject" they would have said so. They are allowing authorization from a variety of sources, the constitution included. So #2 is fine as basically anything to do with the president, in his role as president, is fair game.

And they said you have to know or reasonably know that you do not have permission. So the inner thoughts of the artist is an issue and it is very hard to prove knowledge of a negative fact. If you think you have permission somehow, then maybe you do. So if the kid thinks the constitution protects his work, maybe that's enough to avoid the law even where the constitution does not.

It's a badly written law. I suspect written by people who know it is doomed to fail.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by nitrogen on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @01:10AM (#20332309)
> ...with the intent to coerce, harass, or intimidate, maliciously disseminates...

This part matters

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by DanBC on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @03:06PM (#20338342)
1: legal

2: legal

3: legal, unless there's intent to coerce, harass, or intimidate which would tip it into being illegal.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by asveikau on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:09PM (#20329778)
> A kid

I think we can probably agree kids would be wise to avoid doing the specific things you mentioned.

But importantly, when a kid breaks a law there is typically a separate system for juveniles...

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by stickydink on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:19PM (#20329877)
There's a separate system for how it's responded to, but the same laws apply, and the same act remains illegal
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by pfisch on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:04PM (#20329746)
> A very talented artist creates a realistic watercolor of the President in a compromising situation with Kim Jong-un and posts to Instagram.

Probably legal. It is satire meant to be political commentary. Not distributed with the intent to "coerce, harass, or intimidate"

As for the other ones idk, probably illegal. The last one almost certainly is, and honestly it probably should be.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by solotronics on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:08PM (#20329770)
Why? I thought we had freedom of speech in the US. If I want to draw a picture of you doing something nasty and post it to my own website why should the state stop me?
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by curryst on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:21PM (#20329881)
IANAL, but at least for images that are designed to appear to be, or likely to be perceived as, a real photograph, it strikes me as comparable to libel or slander. To me, the distinction is whether a viewer is likely to interpret the image as satire or general humor, or if they are likely to believe that it is genuine photographic evidence of a compromising event. Satire and humor are protected

You drawing a picture is unlikely to pass that muster. Deepfakes, on the other hand, are generally designed to be falsified images.

I think the interpretation of this will lean heavily on being able to prove intent.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by zzo38computer on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:30PM (#20329943)
As long as it includes a disclaimer that it is a fake (even though it appears to be a real photograph), I do not complain about it, because I like freedom of speech.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by jakobegger on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @02:03AM (#20332535)
Disclaimers are useless because people strip them when they repost the image
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by AstralStorm on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @03:10AM (#20332868)
Make stripping disclaimers illegal? Like stripping copyright claims. Removing the disclaimers is in most cases breaking copyright anyway. It does not count as a remix. It does not count as a quotation and definitely not as archival.

That bit is easy to detect most of the time...

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by pfisch on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @09:22PM (#20340831)
Yeah, and all we have to do to stop piracy is make it illegal. Right?
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by dahart on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @12:45AM (#20332195)
> I thought we had freedom of speech in the US.

Freedom of speech is not absolute in the U.S., and never has been. There’s a fairly long list of boundary lines that are not protected and can get you in trouble if you cross them. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech

> If I want to draw a picture of you doing something nasty and post it to my own website why should the state stop me?

Maybe the same reason the state stops you from hitting or shooting people? Turn that around - why shouldn’t someone stop you from doing something mean, degrading or damaging to someone else publicly?

We could discuss reasons why or why not, but that would also be beside the point. The current law defines illegal speech to include a whole bunch of things your nasty picture might constitute: the harm principle, the offense principle, libel, slander, obscenity, pornography, incitement, fighting words, right to privacy, and public security, just to name a few.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by DuskStar on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:12PM (#20329810)
> I thought we had freedom of speech in the US.

Because thanks to some puritanical supreme court rulings over the past century or so, freedom of speech doesn't cover things considered 'obscene'. This has been variously interpreted to include pornography, information on birth control and abortion, and a variety of other things.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by EliRivers on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:48PM (#20330089)
From an outsider's perspective, simply riffing out loud, you're free to say (and draw) whatever you like. That's not inherently forbidden, but one is NOT free to deliberately cause distress or harm; you don't get a free ride just because your weapon of choice is words (or pictures).

I'm free to hold a hammer in my hand; I have freedom-of-hammer-holding. I'm not free to threaten someone with it; my freedom-of-hammer-holding does not give me a free ride if that hammer becomes my weapon of choice.

The problem isn't with the hammer, or me holding it; it's with me deliberately causing distress and harm. The problem isn't me saying something; the problem is with me deliberately causing distress and harm.

Why should someone get a waiver when deliberately hurting people for their own pleasure, simply because the weapon of choice is words or pictures?

A hand-drawn picture posted on your website would probably be more akin to self-harm in this particular example; I'm just riffing out loud on the idea that it's okay to hurt people for your own pleasure so long as the weapon is words (or pictures).

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by stale2002 on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:16PM (#20331268)
Harrassment is a crime in most places.

It doesnt really fall under free speech.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by whenchamenia on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:26PM (#20331319)
But your post makes me feel genearlly harassed, how can I know when I am just uncomfortable or annoyed?
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by dang on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:29PM (#20331625)
Could you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by stale2002 on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @05:33PM (#20339606)
Well, US law is how you know.

Harassment is not a new thing. It is covered in multiple different situations.

Courts and juries and judges handle this stuff all the time.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by chrshawkes on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:55PM (#20330136)
Um... harassment maybe? Why not also go to his place of employment, talk to all his coworkers and distribute the information manually to anybody you see, should that be legal?