News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by sandworm101 on Monday July 01, 2019 @03:41PM (#20328975)
The real joke is that "deepfake porn" has been common in Hollywood for generations. It was just consensual. Google around to see how many shots in sex and/or nude scenes were actually body doubles. Only lately has that evolved into digitally putting the star's face on the body double's body.

There are some serious first amendment issues here. Hustler Magazine v. Falwell, an iconic case that set the tone for modern supreme court arguments, turned on a verbal 'deepfake', the depiction of a celebrity in a supposed real sexual situation without their consent. That involved a fake interview with Falwell published in Hustler. I don't see how that is legally distinct from putting his face on a body double. Both are claiming an untruth, the creation of a fake sexual history, as a form of legitimate parody and comment on their public persona.

Also, half of all porn films. Does using a Charlie Sheen lookalike in the XXX version of Two and a Half Men constitute deepfake? ("Two and a Half Men", "The Big Bang Theory" ... Chuck Lorre was just begging for porn parodies.)

Download/watch "The People v. Larry Flint". I used to use clips as intros to first amendment and copyright law. It is a great movie.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by adamlett on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:12PM (#20329254)
That involved a fake interview with Falwell published in Hustler. I don't see how that is legally distinct from putting his face on a body double

What I understood from recently rewatching The People vs Larry Flynt was that LF and Hustler magazine were acquitted because nobody would reasonably believe that Jerry Falwell had actually had sex with his mother. It seems evident that the material difference between that case and today’s deepfake is how likely anyone would be to mistake it for the truth.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:15PM (#20329290)
Yes; this is basic enough to be in the syllabus for the case:

Held: In order to protect the free flow of ideas and opinions on matters of public interest and concern, the First and Fourteenth Amendments prohibit public figures and public officials from recovering damages for the tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress by reason of the publication of a caricature such as the ad parody at issue without showing in addition that the publication contains a false statement of fact which was made with "actual malice," i.e., with knowledge that the statement was false or with reckless disregard as to whether or not it was true. The State's interest in protecting public figures from emotional distress is not sufficient to deny First Amendment protection to speech that is patently offensive and is intended to inflict emotional injury when that speech could not reasonably have been interpreted as stating actual facts about the public figure involved. Here, respondent is clearly a "public figure" for First Amendment purposes, [[[ and the lower courts' finding that the ad parody was not reasonably believable must be accepted. ]]] "Outrageousness" in the area of political and social discourse has an inherent subjectiveness about it which would allow a jury to impose liability on the basis of the jurors' tastes or views, or perhaps on the basis of their dislike of a particular expression, and cannot, consistently with the First Amendment, form a basis for the award of damages for conduct such as that involved here.

Em. mine.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by zaroth on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:46PM (#20329562)
Thank you for posting that. I’m not sure I ever fully grok’d the “outrageousness” standard.

So if you say something horrible about a public figure, knowing that it is false, and presenting it as true, if it’s outrageous enough to be obvious parody then it’s permitted. But if it’s stated as truth and emphatically presented as truthful and not as parody, then the public figure exception is lost?

Very hard not to wade into the quagmire of horrible statements people make about a certain politician which a large portion of the country accept as truly factual in this context...

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by sandworm101 on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:31PM (#20329433)
Exactly. So a deepfake of a clean-cut star, say Taylor Swift, in an over-the-top hardcore porn clip would not reasonably be considered real and so could be a legitimate parody.

I forgot to mention perhaps the greatest political porn title: "Who's Nailin Palin?" ... the perfect recent embodiment of the Falwell holding.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by adamlett on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:05PM (#20329755)
So a deepfake of a clean-cut star, say Taylor Swift, in an over-the-top hardcore porn clip would not reasonably be considered real and so could be a legitimate parody.

So it could be argued. But color me skeptical as to whether such an argument would convince any judge. For one, sex tapes of so called clean cut stars have emerged before. For another, most reasonable people would agree that there is a significant difference in how we perceive the realness of text and photorealistic images. People understand that text is inherently a medium in which reality is filtered through the interpretation of the writer. In other words, we’re comfortable with the idea that text is an unreliable medium. Photorealistic images are different in that regard. If people can’t tell that a video is fake by looking, it’s reasonable to expect that they will assume it’s real.

Who's Nailin Palin?

That’s ridiculous. Nobody who knew Sarah Pailin would mistake an actress for her.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by sandworm101 on Monday July 01, 2019 @06:27PM (#20330349)
>> Nobody who knew Sarah Pailin would mistake an actress for her.

"During a segment on whether Palin will run for the 2012 Republican presidential nomination, [Fox News] aired a photo of Fey posing as the former Alaska governor."

https://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/fox-news-mistakenl...

So ya, people who did know her image very well did in fact mistake an image of the actor Tina Fey for the real Sarah Palin. It happened several times during the campaign.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by pvg on Monday July 01, 2019 @06:40PM (#20330439)
No, they were just sloppy. Wrong graphics were common enough that Fox management had to write grumpy memos about it. You're basing your argument on a hook sentence from a tabloid. Nobody thought they made the mistake because they couldn't tell them apart.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by LyndsySimon on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @11:57AM (#20336366)
What about the "I can see Russia from my house" line? A ton of people believed (and some likely still believe) that Palin said that. She didn't. Tina Fey said that.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by pvg on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @12:41PM (#20336831)
What about it? I'm also happy to stipulate former college football all-star Gerald Ford wasn't actually a klutz.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:56PM (#20329659)
That's not at all the case, no. If you use extraordinary new computing facilities to create a convincing facsimile of a public person having sex with someone else on camera, you're very unlikely to skate on the "reasonable person" standard. I remain interested in how familiar you are with deepfake technology, because it is nothing at all like the Falwell parody in Hustler or the porn parody film you just cited.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by sandworm101 on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:03PM (#20329733)
I am well aware of what can be done having once worked in film/TV production. But the quality of the fake is irrelevant. Falwell involved an absolutely perfect fake. It was a text interview. There was nothing in the interview, beyond the nature of the content, that suggested it wasn't real. They even used his real face in the portrait. Surely more than a few people fell for the gag. The parallels to a modern deepfake porn parody are clear.

https://frontpageconfidential.com/larry-flynt-supreme-court-...

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:57PM (#20330149)
This doesn't even cohere as an argument. The "absolutely perfect fake" you're referring to was a parody (print) Campari ad with nothing but a headshot of Falwell and an "interview" that opened with "My first time was in an outhouse outside Lynchburg, Virginia"; "Wasn't it a little cramped?"; "Not after I kicked the goat out". A deepfake uses GANs to synthesize a convincing video of its subject, something that wasn't even technologically possible a few years ago.

As I showed you a moment ago, even the syllabus of Rehnquist's opinion acknowledges that no reasonable person could have believed the Hustler ad to be true.

I'm becoming convinced that you're arguing for the sake of arguing.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by justforyou on Monday July 01, 2019 @08:27PM (#20331041)
I think the point that sandworm101 is trying to make is that for the medium, it was a perfect fake.

One could make the argument that due to the ubiquity of photoshop and "shooped memes," the fact that both livestreamers and TV networks regularly employ digital makeup filters, and the continued press that deepfake technology recieves -- there is no reason for any reasonable person to assume any piece digial media hasn't been substantially altered...

(especially now that the term "fake news" has become a tumour on our lexicon)

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:40PM (#20331408)
One could make all sorts of arguments, but in fact a spoof print ad for Campari and a deep fake video are not the same thing. In particular, the law does not operate based on the kinds of logic that prevails on message boards, as the previous commenter, a lawyer, must know.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by pvg on Monday July 01, 2019 @11:06PM (#20331808)
In fairness, "a fake so perfect, you can't tell it's fake (other than by its content)" is the work of a trained professional. Few among us message board amateurs so effortlessly reach for the sublime.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by adamlett on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:11PM (#20329796)
But the quality of the fake is irrelevant.

According to whom?

Falwell involved an absolutely perfect fake

If that were true, written accounts would be as video when used as evidence in a court of law. You may be surprised to learn that this is not in fact the case.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by 0815test on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:24PM (#20329370)
One could definitely use "deepfake" tech to make transparently-untrue and highly fanciful depictions/parodies though. It's not so much about the technology itself as how it gets used.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by adamlett on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:15PM (#20329847)
It’s both. If there was a way to state the law in such a way that it was always clear when and how to apply it, there would be no need for courts and judges.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by TomMckenny on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:11PM (#20329249)
Not to defend the Virginia statute but as devils advocate, couldn't they argue that their law does not apply to parody and only protects non-public figures?

So couldn't they argue the statute would not apply to the Hustler-Falwell parody for those two reasons?

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by heyitsguay on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:12PM (#20329257)
Why wouldn't you defend this statute?
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by TomMckenny on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:15PM (#20329285)
I haven't read enough about it to have an opinion yet.

Does the wording in fact contradict Hustler Magazine v. Falwell? Would it outlaw satyrical images of politicians? Thus my question above.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by moate on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:07PM (#20329211)
>>Hustler Magazine v. Falwell

That's not a "deepfake". One is a satirical printed ad aimed at a celebrity (satire has been pretty frequently protected speech) and the other is malicious creation of an artifact to attack random people (typically women). You know that there are plenty of unprotected forms of speech (harassment and assault at the top of the list) and it seems like that's what the legislature here is trying to do, add this to that list.

>>Does using a Charlie Sheen lookalike in the XXX version of Two and a Half Men constitute deepfake?

No. That actor isn't credited as "Charlie Sheen", he's credited as <actor's name>. This is not the same thing. He is not representing himself as actually being Charlie Sheen, but possibly the character of "Charlie Sheen".

You're a man of the law: how would you protect these women from revenge porn if this law offends you so? Or are you more of a "sticks and stones and sending my mother an image of what appears to be me getting penetrated in my asshole will never hurt me" type of guy?

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:11PM (#20329248)
Moreover, the entire point of Hustler v Falwell was that no reasonable person could have believed the Hustler piece was anything but satire, while the whole point of a "deep fake" is that the opposite is meant to be true.

It's very strange to argue that deepfake revenge porn is in any way comparable to Hustler v Falwell; it seems like you'd have to be almost totally unfamiliar with that case – or with deepfakes, or with revenge porn – to draw a connection.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by zaroth on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:49PM (#20329591)
Maybe in the venn diagram of deep fakes and revenge porn, these are not two perfectly overlapping sets, and since first amendment issues have to pass strict scrutiny, the law could still be in Constitutional jeopardy?

I Am Definitely Not A Constitutional Lawyer.

Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by moate on Monday July 01, 2019 @04:15PM (#20329286)
Or arguing in bad faith because you just think people should always be able to "say" whatever they want whenever they want because slippery slope >> thought police >> being an asshole sends you to jail.
Re:Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia by whenchamenia on Monday July 01, 2019 @09:29PM (#20331340)
Freedom of speech, should apply reguardless of good faith. Who would you have draw the line?