So if you say something horrible about a public figure, knowing that it is false, and presenting it as true, if it’s outrageous enough to be obvious parody then it’s permitted. But if it’s stated as truth and emphatically presented as truthful and not as parody, then the public figure exception is lost?
Very hard not to wade into the quagmire of horrible statements people make about a certain politician which a large portion of the country accept as truly factual in this context...
I forgot to mention perhaps the greatest political porn title: "Who's Nailin Palin?" ... the perfect recent embodiment of the Falwell holding.
So it could be argued. But color me skeptical as to whether such an argument would convince any judge. For one, sex tapes of so called clean cut stars have emerged before. For another, most reasonable people would agree that there is a significant difference in how we perceive the realness of text and photorealistic images. People understand that text is inherently a medium in which reality is filtered through the interpretation of the writer. In other words, we’re comfortable with the idea that text is an unreliable medium. Photorealistic images are different in that regard. If people can’t tell that a video is fake by looking, it’s reasonable to expect that they will assume it’s real.
Who's Nailin Palin?
That’s ridiculous. Nobody who knew Sarah Pailin would mistake an actress for her.
"During a segment on whether Palin will run for the 2012 Republican presidential nomination, [Fox News] aired a photo of Fey posing as the former Alaska governor."
https://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/fox-news-mistakenl...
So ya, people who did know her image very well did in fact mistake an image of the actor Tina Fey for the real Sarah Palin. It happened several times during the campaign.
https://frontpageconfidential.com/larry-flynt-supreme-court-...
As I showed you a moment ago, even the syllabus of Rehnquist's opinion acknowledges that no reasonable person could have believed the Hustler ad to be true.
I'm becoming convinced that you're arguing for the sake of arguing.
One could make the argument that due to the ubiquity of photoshop and "shooped memes," the fact that both livestreamers and TV networks regularly employ digital makeup filters, and the continued press that deepfake technology recieves -- there is no reason for any reasonable person to assume any piece digial media hasn't been substantially altered...
(especially now that the term "fake news" has become a tumour on our lexicon)
According to whom?
Falwell involved an absolutely perfect fake
If that were true, written accounts would be as video when used as evidence in a court of law. You may be surprised to learn that this is not in fact the case.
Held: In order to protect the free flow of ideas and opinions on matters of public interest and concern, the First and Fourteenth Amendments prohibit public figures and public officials from recovering damages for the tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress by reason of the publication of a caricature such as the ad parody at issue without showing in addition that the publication contains a false statement of fact which was made with "actual malice," i.e., with knowledge that the statement was false or with reckless disregard as to whether or not it was true. The State's interest in protecting public figures from emotional distress is not sufficient to deny First Amendment protection to speech that is patently offensive and is intended to inflict emotional injury when that speech could not reasonably have been interpreted as stating actual facts about the public figure involved. Here, respondent is clearly a "public figure" for First Amendment purposes, [[[ and the lower courts' finding that the ad parody was not reasonably believable must be accepted. ]]] "Outrageousness" in the area of political and social discourse has an inherent subjectiveness about it which would allow a jury to impose liability on the basis of the jurors' tastes or views, or perhaps on the basis of their dislike of a particular expression, and cannot, consistently with the First Amendment, form a basis for the award of damages for conduct such as that involved here.
Em. mine.