News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by petschge on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:31PM (#20321514)
Why do you say gravity is important for organelles? At those length scales other forces are MUCH more important than gravity.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by saagarjha on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:51PM (#20321605)
Gravity is important for heavy elements to cluster in one place in sufficient concentrations to form organelles.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by krastanov on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:54PM (#20321623)
Excuse my language, but I want to stress how preposterous this statement is: this is complete and utter nonsense. Gravity is way more than 10^10 times weaker than electromagnetism at this scale.

Unless you mean "gravity is important to make planets, and planets are where we have observed life", in which case you are stretching the meaning of this expression to a meaningless level.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by saagarjha on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:53PM (#20322116)
> Unless you mean "gravity is important to make planets, and planets are where we have observed life"

I did.

[dead]
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by jcranmer on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:03PM (#20321911)
The cell is not a natural homogeneous mixture obeying the laws of free energy. It is actually a densely packed collection of mechanisms designed to subvert free energy and selective cause otherwise improbable reactions to occur. It ought not to be a surprise that some of those mechanisms do not work so well outside the standard uniform gravitational field we experience.

But that is not to say that there isn't another set of mechanisms that could work without the influence of gravity. You can see this in parallel with human construction: stairs don't work so well without gravity, but ladders work perfectly fine.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:30PM (#20322027)
> It ought not to be a surprise that some of those mechanisms do not work so well outside the standard uniform gravitational field we experience

This is called a dependency. So you agree with my initial proposition.

> But that is not to say that there isn't another set of mechanisms that could work without the influence of gravity

As I addressed in another post, this is orthogonal to the discussion because we are talking about the universe the way it is, not the way it could be; If we remove gravity from the equation, we don't even get past the big bang and forming systems from uneven matter distribution.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by jcranmer on Sunday June 30, 2019 @11:13PM (#20322194)
Your original proposition is "[gravity is] required for [...] chemical reactions in our organelles."

I am explicitly disagreeing that gravity is required for such reactions. Your own source doesn't back up that statement--it suggests that the microstructure (in addition to the more obvious structure of the intercellular matrix) of cells is influenced by gravity, which is itself a rather different statement. Influence is a very different thing from requirement.

Furthermore, I should point out that our experience that life can survive quite well outside of the normal gravitational field is itself sufficient disproof of your proposition. After all, our mitochondria don't go "Wait! There's no gravity! How am I supposed to Krebs cycle now?"

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Monday July 01, 2019 @02:56AM (#20323042)
I said indirectly, so if you're going to quote me don't only quote the parts that feed your take on things.

> I am explicitly disagreeing that gravity is required for such reactions

A dependency is very different from a requirement. You can have one without the other. But a system's growth being influenced by an outside system explicitly means that the system's current structure is dependent on that outside system; in the sense that if the outside system were never present, the internal system would be structured differently if it existed at all. And that is only talking about direct influence.

> Furthermore, I should point out that our experience that life can survive quite well outside of the normal gravitational field is itself sufficient disproof of your proposition

You are straying sooooo far from my original post, can we reel it in a little bit?

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by eesmith on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:50PM (#20321857)
Okay, I read it. It's an editorial. It says nothing about how gravity is required "for heavy elements to cluster in one place in sufficient concentrations to form organelles".

For the matter, it says nothing about heavy elements.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by pharrington on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:05PM (#20321922)
https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/cciss_fe...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemodynamics

etc.

Yes, gravity is, by far, the weakest force. None-the-less, it is a force, and definitely effects all sorts of things at all scales.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by eesmith on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:18PM (#20321981)
These two links still have no bearing on the topic.

You wrote "Gravity is important for heavy elements to cluster in one place in sufficient concentrations to form organelles."

Your link #1 concerns blood flow, which is much larger than organelles and has nothing to do with heavy elements. (In any relevant sense - while red blood cells have iron, they don't affect the fluid dynamics.)

Your link #2 barely touches on gravity, and doesn't mention organelles or heavy elements.

I agree with krastanov - the statement of yours, which I quoted, is preposterous according to a widely held understanding of how things work. As such, it would require strong evidence to overturn those views.

What is the basis by which you decided it was correct and important enough to bring up?

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by pharrington on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:45PM (#20322089)
Sure, organelle formation probably has little to do with gravity. You seem very devoted to this semantic battle. Would you like to take this conversation elsewhere?
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Monday July 01, 2019 @02:48AM (#20323003)
Grice's razor: "As a principle of parsimony, conversational implications are to be preferred over semantic context for linguistic explanations."

People fall into semantic battles when they don't feel qualified to discuss the real substance of the conversation. A pity, I was hoping for some stimulating discourse and not a bunch of egotistical hogwash missing the entire point of my proposition.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:27PM (#20322014)
While OP's words are his own and I'm not necessarily in agreement with them, it's worth pointing out that the circulatory system and organs and organelles which comprise them all have circular dependencies; it's not simply hierarchical based on relative size. A change in any part of the system can propagate both upward and downward.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by eesmith on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:49PM (#20322097)
The "OP" I'm quoting is you, at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20321707 . How are you not in agreement with what you wrote?

As to your 'circular dependencies', I'll again quote krastanov in the direct ancestor to this thread:

> Unless you mean "gravity is important to make planets, and planets are where we have observed life", in which case you are stretching the meaning of this expression to a meaningless level.

This 'circular dependencies' argument is as meaningless as saying that biological organelles are essential to the production of nuclear weapons - true, but not important enough that it's needed to understand the overall process.

And there are many things like that. We can model weather numerically without modeling each and every molecule because that low-level interaction doesn't really affect fluid dynamics. Mean field theory can be apply to many complex systems.

Yes, there can be chaotic behavior, even in Newtownian systems. But that's beside the point, which is they you have made statements which you seem to assert as fact which don't have any evidentiary support.

You might as well muse about the effects of feline ESP on the weather.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by saagarjha on Sunday June 30, 2019 @11:05PM (#20322162)
I think you’re confusing me with soulofmischief. In any case, I think I’ve clarified what I meant by my statement: organelles exist because gravity has caused heavy elements such as carbon and oxygen to be present in a dense enough concentration for life to occur.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Monday July 01, 2019 @02:45AM (#20322986)
I understand where you're coming from. You're talking about stellar dispersion of elements-- which is true. Somehow this isn't relevant to forming life? I guess that's why none of the people shitting all over my musings in this thread are actually working in Physics and not just recounting what they read in a Pop Sci article. Dunning-Kruger effect, I guess.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by krastanov on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @02:39AM (#20332708)
My disappointed comment at your musings (which I would characterize as misleading or at the very least nonsensically general truisms) started this regrettable thread. While I avoided commenting in it, this last comment of yours just continues the misleading pretentiousness: unlike what you assumed, some of the people that argue with you actually work in Physics, and we are annoyed because you conflate phenomena and then project and argue about meaningless semantics. As I said, I do share your excitement at the wonders of the universe, but I am trying and failing to see intellectual honesty or awareness in most of your follow-up comments.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Monday July 01, 2019 @02:43AM (#20322978)
You're confusing me with another poster, dawg. I said nothing about heavy elements.

> 'circular dependencies' argument is as meaningless as saying that biological organelles are essential to the production of nuclear weapons

Lol okay, or we could actually be mature about this and stay within the bounds of the discussion. Yes, it's meaningless when you stretch it that far; but I didn't. These systems are in direct contact with each other and depend on each others' designs to function. That has nothing to do with nuclear weaponry.

> We can model weather numerically without modeling each and every molecule because that low-level interaction doesn't really affect fluid dynamics

Yes, that's called classical mechanics. We wouldn't rely on QM to describe large-scale weather phenomenon which our current laws of classical thermodynamics encapsulate just fine. But these are all models, not reality itself; If we found out tomorrow a GUT which directly modeled quantum perturbations all the way to a storm in Kansas, with high accuracy, we would use that instead. So referencing our current applications of our current immature physical theories is pointless to this conversation.

> You might as well muse about the effects of feline ESP on the weather.

You just cannot have an open-minded scientific conversation can you? It just has to be a chance to show your intellectual superiority? Hardly a conducive attitude for progress and breaking the status quo. At one time Newton was considered nuts. At one time Einstein wasn't taken seriously. I'm not Newton or Einstein but neither of their bodies of work were developed having conversations with people like you.

More to the point, your derision is ill-formed; Comparing quantum gravitational fluctuations to ESP is just insane. One of them is very much real and proven. We just don't have a GUT to tie it all together.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by petschge on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:08PM (#20321932)
While technically present at all scales, gravity is so weak that you can ignore it until you get to pretty large scales. Meters or so. An ant barely feels gravity, a bacterium or a single cell don't even know it is there.
Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:18PM (#20321979)
What does it mean to "feel" gravity? I assure you the ant's biological systems would undergo many changes over generations in the absence of gravity in order to reach homeostasis. A bacterium can't feel anything but did I mention single-celled organisms? No, I mentioned organelles. You are arguing against a straw-man.

Furthermore you are completely ignoring the effect of gravitational perturbations on emergent structures. These things don't necessarily "iron out", and if they do, we have not yet ascertained at what level and via what mechanism.

You are confusing an object's ability to produce gravity with its propensity for interacting with gravity.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by ceejayoz on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:55PM (#20322122)
> A bacterium can't feel anything but did I mention single-celled organisms? No, I mentioned organelles.

Given that mitochondria are almost certainly descended from captured bacteria, that's an odd quibble.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by soulofmischief on Monday July 01, 2019 @02:52AM (#20323025)
You're right; I'm just trying to not stray so far from the intending meaning of my post. However, our organelles are indirectly influenced by gravity as a result of cascading interactions with other macro systems.

I'm just sure someone could make the argument that one bacteria out there was shown to function identically without gravity, thus dismantling an argument I was never trying to make. Organelles are different because they interact with a larger cell structure, which interacts with a larger tissue structure, the latter two both having experimentally proven dependencies on gravity for optimal performance in their current structure. Yes, a lot of our cells would work more or less the same in zero grav-- but would they have ever formed that way in the first place? Your guess is as good as mine.

Re:LIGO detects probable black hole merger event by pharrington on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:14PM (#20321956)
If you wanna go down that rabbit hole... one must be as precise as possible when estimating.