News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by kazen44 on Sunday June 30, 2019 @03:00PM (#20319813)
Also, how much of this effect is basically the rest of the world playing catch up in terms of economic production?

China and the rest of Asia are magnitudes more competitive compared to 50 years ago. And prior to that US industry was unmatched thanks to the massive effects world war 2 had on the other, western industrialized nations.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by maxxxxx on Sunday June 30, 2019 @03:21PM (#20319933)
That doesn't explain why inequality within the US keeps growing. As a whole the country is doing well but somehow the benefits go a small number of people while everybody else is stagnating.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by AndrewKemendo on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:56PM (#20320469)
It's explained somewhat in the article:

We’ve also had a combination of tax and regulatory policy that has encouraged capital formation and increasing returns to capital, so labor’s share of returns has decreased.

To add to that, capital is exponentially more portable than labor. With globalization, capital in the form of investments can move wherever it needs to to grow, it's borderless. Labor however, in order to grow wealth has to physically move. Remote jobs for basic labor doesn't exist - that's almost exclusively knowledge work.

So if you're a coal miner, your ability to create wealth is extremely limited to certain physical places. If you're a remote Java dev, you can code from anywhere and grow wealth much easier, but there is a serious time cost to switching work. If you're an investor and just need to drop money into an account, not only can you do it from anywhere, you can move things around more or less immediately with little (relative) cost.

It's about portability of the thing that is growing the wealth. Labor = slow, Capital = fast.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by zebrafish on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:26PM (#20320299)
Sure it does. US consumer demand rises after WWII because of GI bill & repurposing of capital -> competition drives prices down -> Securities & Exchanges Act essentially mandates firms optimize for returns to capital as a fiduciary duty to shareholders -> producers look to countries where standards of living demand lower wages to maintain market positions -> US jobs decline but shareholder value grows -> wealth concentrates in the hands of those who have the opportunity to be a shareholders
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by moorhosj on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:55PM (#20320459)
You kind of hand-waved 70 years of economic history/decisions. How does “US jobs decline” match with an historically low unemployment rate?
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by deogeo on Sunday June 30, 2019 @03:09PM (#20319867)
> Also, how much of this effect is basically the rest of the world playing catch up in terms of economic production?

If the rest of the world becoming more productive results in US workers being worse off, then something is severely wrong with US trade policy. For one, it contradicts the dogma that more trade is strictly beneficial.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by cycrutchfield on Sunday June 30, 2019 @03:50PM (#20320114)
>For one, it contradicts the dogma that more trade is strictly beneficial.

It is strictly beneficial, in aggregate. But in any situation, there are winners and there are losers. There are no decisions you can make where everybody wins. If you live in a first world country and your skill set is worse than somebody in the developing world, you’re going to have a bad time.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by deogeo on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:06PM (#20320196)
> But in any situation, there are winners and there are losers.

The usually trotted-out theory of comparative advantage claims there are only winners.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by ACow_Adonis on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:51PM (#20320426)
again, only in the aggregate/ entity of measurement level.

I would argue anyone who says otherwise is either being disingenuous or doesn't actually understand economics.

That is not to say that is not trotted out frequently.

Also, to be fair, during my economics education they had this whole focus on modeling policies and finding optimizations where no one is worse off.

Of course, in the real world, that practically never happens... and there is an argument that the focus on efficient/competitive markets/ equilibria/rational agents is also a bit "wouldn't it be nice if the world was actually like this...", whereas in the real world only the most trivial goods/markets can vaguely be described as such...

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by cycrutchfield on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:38PM (#20320356)
I don’t think you fully understand comparative advantage then.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by FooHentai on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:10PM (#20320878)
>If you live in a first world country and your skill set is worse than somebody in the developing world, you’re going to have a bad time.

Even if your skill set is greater, your cost of living is higher. So you'd have to be more than marginally better.

Also, the logical conclusion of where this seems to be headed is that if you're a low-skill person living in a first-world county, voting for protectionist, isolationist policies/politicians is a rational choice.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by digitaltrees on Sunday June 30, 2019 @11:46PM (#20322320)
Except protectionism makes everyone poorer in the medium term and actually causes international conflict. Who do you think gets drafted to fight war when trade wars turn to real wars?

Perhaps if society used the increased wealth to benefit everyone the value of global interconnected trade could be felt by everyone. This is an easy fix, return to the post World War Two tax policy that built the middle class. Return to a well respected government that drives large scale work like highways, scientific research, the space program. Think about how much technology is a direct result of military research (GPS, the Internet, rocketry, etc) imagine if we mobilized on the same scale for exploring space, basic research and innovation and entrepreneurial activity.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by cycrutchfield on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:42PM (#20321030)
Sure, as we saw quite vividly in 2016. This is also known as Crab Mentality.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by deogeo on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:24PM (#20321237)
It's really not - crab mentality refers to pulling others down for no reason other than envy. But in this case, the reason is the lower classes don't want to be pushed even lower. Are they supposed to selflessly sacrifice themselves so that the rich can get even richer?
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by cycrutchfield on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:59PM (#20321384)
They want the economy to suffer to preserve their legacy careers doing pointless things like mining coal or forging steel, things that somebody in a developing nation can do just as well for 1/10 the cost. Why are blue collar jobs so sacrosanct? When the careers of secretaries and travel agents essentially vanished, there was no weeping and moaning, no irrational protectionism, no economic suicide. People moved on to do something more productive with their time, and so should the coal miners.

So, yes, they are crabs at the bottom of the pot seeing other crabs moving up, and they cannot abide by that.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by deogeo on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:15PM (#20321457)
Ah yes, mustn't let "the economy" suffer - who cares about the actual workers within that economy.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by cycrutchfield on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:35PM (#20321525)
I mean, you’ve shown that you don’t even understand the concept of comparative advantage at the individual vs. aggregate level. How am I supposed to explain to you that protectionist policies benefit a small minority of workers at the expense of almost everybody else?

Instead, I’ll just suggest that you find a good Freshman-level Economics textbook and read carefully. You may find it illuminating to understand the concepts behind complex policy decisions.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by deogeo on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:54PM (#20321621)
> How am I supposed to explain to you that protectionist policies benefit a small minority of workers at the expense of almost everybody else?

Given that none of the most successful economies developed without protectionism [1,2], you'll have a difficult time explaining that indeed. That pesky reality, always getting in the way of "good Freshman-level Economics textbooks".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage#Criticis...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20320483

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by cycrutchfield on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:04PM (#20321667)
I forget, are we talking about workers in first world countries or workers in developing countries? I’m not quite sure why you are gloating like you just made a strong counterargument, but it’s not a good look.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by bilbo0s on Sunday June 30, 2019 @03:12PM (#20319888)
I think that dogma though was meant to address the situation in a global context. ie - More trade is strictly beneficial for the global population in aggregate.

But yeah, it's still trade, so there will be lows and highs, and ebbs and flows.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by asark on Sunday June 30, 2019 @03:44PM (#20320073)
> For one, it contradicts the dogma that more trade is strictly beneficial.

Ricardo's original idea was applicable with a narrow set of assumptions/conditions and didn't have much to say about who'd end up with the greater net wealth. I'm not sure how/why it was turned into a magical improve-any-economy law of nature.

Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by astazangasta on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:33PM (#20320328)
Ricardo's mistake is not thinking about development; comparative advantage is optimal now, but a society that just makes coffee beans is going to lose in the end to the one that makes microchips because of the difference in how the economy and society develop over time.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by 0815test on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:45PM (#20320390)
This may have been a mistake by Ricardo, but not one that points towards less trade as optimal. Indeed, export-led development (implying more trade openness) is the one reliable way we know about of going from the "coffee beans" to the "microchips" stage of development.
Re:Rising US Inequality: How We Got Here, Where We're Going by astazangasta on Sunday June 30, 2019 @04:59PM (#20320483)
False, I recommend Ha-Joon Chang's writing on this subject. The US did not develop in a climate of trade openness, it used tariffs to protect its development. In fact no developed economy developed this way, all of them protected their industry until it was mature and ready to compete, had their governments invest in research and infrastructure and so on. If you have an example of a country that successfully developed through export led development and trade openness I would love to hear it.