News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by jasonhansel on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:02AM (#20317973)
To be honest: I think SO is in a difficult position here. They're absolutely essential to the software dev community, but their service is incredibly hard to monetize without alienating users.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by danShumway on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:50AM (#20318179)
This is complicated, because it's not really SO that's the essential part. The knowledge on SO is essential.

That's not to say that SO isn't playing an extremely valuable role in helping to collect that knowledge and organize the community. Community management is hard. I do want SO to make money, I want the devs to be successful, I think they should be compensated for their work.

But products that are built on (what I would call) the commons are in a weird place. I'm cognizant of the fact that most of SO's value comes from the fact that ordinary people contribute to it without any compensation, and that part of the reason ordinary people contributed to it in the first place was because the developers were able to capitalize on a kind of social spirit.

That's not to say that SO is wrong here. TBH, I don't think advertising your own products on a home page is crossing any reasonable line, particularly when most people are getting to SO from search engines anyway. But I do want to push back a little bit against the idea that SO created something magical out of the ether. (Not that I think you're saying that, or trying to say that).

SO is essential only because the devs were able to get ordinary people to give up large swaths of information, for free. And part of the reason they were able to do that was because they projected a kind of business style that resonated with those people. Would SO be as successful today if it had run ads with trackers in them from the beginning? I don't know where the line is, but there has to be some degree of give-and-take, or there's no point in complaining when that same community decides, "nah, we don't think we want to give you free information any more."

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by quantummkv on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:18AM (#20318305)
I don't think so. Wikipedia has a model that works. And unlike Wikipedia, a whole lot of professionals working in some of the most high paying jobs across the globe frequent and love stackoverflow.

All stackoverflow has to do is to bite the bullet and officially turn into what most of its users consider it as anyway - The wikipedia of programming.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by hacym on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:26AM (#20318346)
And become a nonprofit? So they can do fundraising drives where people will complain about them asking for money? I don’t think that will/should ever happen.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by ForHackernews on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:11AM (#20318009)
Just charge big companies $500,000/year or whatever for an "Enterprise Stack Overflow subscription" or something. Have their lawyer sign a licensing agreement that SO will promise to never sue BigCorp if BigCorp's engineers incorporate a SO answer into their precious proprietary software.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by jasonhansel on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:14AM (#20318025)
But I think that incorporating SO answers into proprietary software is already legal, right? And if it is illegal, then the copyright is owned by the person who posted the answer, not by SO itself.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by ForHackernews on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:17AM (#20318043)
Sure it's already legal. That doesn't mean that corporate lawyers wouldn't be thrilled to make extra-certain they have a signed contract that explains it's legal.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by paulryanrogers on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:20AM (#20318050)
IIRC all answers on SO are under a Ceative Commons attribution license. Changing that might be near impossible for all the existing questions, unless the TOS granted then a right to relicense.

(Since answer authors retain the copyright to their answers and edits.)

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by snazz on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:17AM (#20318038)
The answers have always been CC-BY-SA 2.5 licensed.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by shagie on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:58AM (#20318535)
That is a... complicated statement.

If you look at https://stackoverflow.com/help/licensing - the license that it points to is http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/

A 2010 wayback http://web.archive.org/web/20100701152609/http://stackoverfl... links to 2.5

While a 2011 wayback links to 3.0 http://web.archive.org/web/20110703111023/http://stackoverfl...

A blog post from 2011 on attribution required : http://web.archive.org/web/20110717145827/http://blog.stacko... - that links to 2.5

The current blog post - https://stackoverflow.blog/2009/06/25/attribution-required/ links to 3.0

The 2.5 license : http://web.archive.org/web/20100630092909/http://creativecom...

> A new version of this license is available. You should use it for new works, and you may want to relicense existing works under it. No works are automatically put under the new license, however.

IANAL reading of this suggests that posts from 2010 should be under 2.5 and post from whenever the 2.5 to 3.0 change was made would be under 3.0. Unfortunately, this isn't made clear on the posts themselves (or the site).

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by GordonS on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:00AM (#20318223)
I thought Jobs was meant to fix this, providing a route to profits while also being something devs want.

I wonder how much revenue it generates?

EDIT: Answering my own question:

Their cheapest package (which allows max 1 job ad at any time) is around $7,500/year. They have 5572 jobs advertised right now, so I guess it's pulling in 30-41M a year.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by Grue3 on Monday July 01, 2019 @03:50AM (#20323295)
Their service is incredibly easy to monetize. Just add bounties to questions. The asker can put a bounty on the question and the bounty is given to the correct answer. SO gets a cut.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by verisimilitudes on Sunday June 30, 2019 @02:16PM (#20319584)
>They're absolutely essential to the software dev community

I disagree. I'm of the opinion that it's useful only if you're doing something you've no clue about and also don't want to gain a clue about. It's no surprise, then, that WWW garbage is typical, since it's poorly documented and a ''living standard'' and other nonsense.

If you're like me and use real languages with real standards and good books available, you're probably not going to need something such as this. I've never asked a question there and I've never needed to look at a Common Lisp question and answer; I don't think there are many Common Lisp questions and answers in general, actually. Similarly, I don't see these for APL, either. I don't believe it's a coincidence that these languages are well-documented and encourage understanding to use.

Meanwhile, ''Why does JavaScript do this?'' or ''I can't get my CSS to do this in Safari.'', sure, I can see that.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by Nextgrid on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:45PM (#20321567)
Disagreed.

Even if you are lucky to use a language where the official documentation is very good, there’s still a chance that you run into some issue that isn’t covered by it or is out of scope. My personal example is an issue installing a third-party Python library on a certain macOS version. I wouldn’t expect this to be in the official docs considering it’s a bug in the OS (more specifically where the unofficial package manager puts C libraries), but it’s still an issue that’s preventing me from getting stuff done.

StackOverflow had an unanswered question about it, and similar questions (with answers) for other libraries. With those answers I was able to solve my problem and post an answer to that original library. It’s still earning upvotes 2 years later suggesting it’s being useful to quite a few people.

There’s also the issue where you have to work with languages where documentation isn’t ideal or the behaviour is implementation-dependent (JavaScript and CSS come to mind). In a perfect world we would have one authoritative source for docs and all implementations would follow it. We’re not in a perfect world, so the next best thing is a site where new people can ask questions and people experienced with the issue at hand can share their knowledge.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by verisimilitudes on Monday July 01, 2019 @03:44AM (#20323272)
In my opinion, Python doesn't belong in the same category as Common Lisp and APL.

>There’s also the issue where you have to work with languages where documentation isn’t ideal or the behaviour is implementation-dependent (JavaScript and CSS come to mind).

I already agreed that JavaScript and CSS are good languages for Stack Overflow.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by lispm on Monday July 01, 2019 @07:11AM (#20324199)
Questions:

4850 for CL

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/common-lisp

5798 for Lisp

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/lisp

6786 for Scheme

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/scheme

Other languages: 90K Scala, 1.5M Java, 1.8M Javascript, 1.5k Smalltalk, 10k Prolog, 1.6k Ada, 235k Swift, 1.2M Python, 1.3M C#

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by everyone on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:09AM (#20318003)
"They're absolutely essential to the software dev community"

Posting a question there has been pointless for years. I also dont think I've seen any answers there via duckduckgo useful to me in a long time. I dont think I'd even notice if it disappeared tomorrow. (I am not a web dev btw)

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by lordnacho on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:18AM (#20318046)
> Posting a question there has been pointless for years.

Isn't that mainly because it's already been answered? (Apart from new tags) I've got dozens of questions on my SO account, but it's been quite a while since I wrote one now.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by everyone on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:31AM (#20318101)
No, The trend I noticed starting years ago, which according to various articles Ive seen is now complete and institutionalized there, is that:

High ranked mod/troll types, who seem to spend all day there trying to get more karma for some reason, constantly cruise for new questions. They dont know much about programming in general, and have zero knowledge of my specialist field for example. If they see a question that superficialy resembles or shares certain keywords with another one they will close it as being answered already (pretty much acting like particularly dumb bots) even if it has nothing to do with the existing question, or if the existing question is massively out of date and irrelevant because of updates to the software in question.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by lordnacho on Sunday June 30, 2019 @10:18AM (#20318306)
You may have a point there. It happens quite often that I google for something, and the article containing the answer is marked closed or off-topic.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by patrick5415 on Sunday June 30, 2019 @01:30PM (#20319329)
Yes. Some of the best, most valuable questions and answers are closed for pedantic reasons.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by chessturk on Sunday June 30, 2019 @02:16PM (#20319585)
I upvoted you and the gp, but I also would like to point out that the useful answer often still arrives before the pendatic closure.

Some of my own questions followed that route, without being dupe questions and while being a code-based success or fail state. The closure of tickets is detrimental to the site, but somehow, it's still worth asking a question.

Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by jasonhansel on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:13AM (#20318019)
I think it's more useful for new devs than for experienced ones. I've also found it a useful source for snippets of code that I have trouble remembering on my own.
Re:“New home page seems like Stack Overflow doesn't allow fr... by Nextgrid on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:48PM (#20321587)
It could also be survivor bias. You don’t rely on it as much because you’re experienced. I do the same for the programming language I’ve now got 7 years worth or experience.

The picture was much different when I started out, and I feel like StackOverflow is still an invaluable resource for juniors/mid-levels or for those transitioning to an unfamiliar technology.