News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A serious drug problem by tptacek on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:15PM (#2031755)
Is there one person on Hacker News that will write a heartfelt comment in support of drug prohibition? I don't think there is but am prepared to be surprised.

Otherwise, what is this post doing here? What are we learning from it? Is this just an opportunity for us to bicker about Obama vs. Bush vs. Ron Paul?

Re:A serious drug problem by Alex3917 on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:28PM (#2031816)
There's a difference between being vaguely against drug prohibition and having the facts and stories necessary to convince others. In the past 18 months I've read 6 or 7 books about drugs, gone to three conferences on the science of drugs, and listened to another 50+ hours of podcasts. From all this I've learned an enormous amount of stuff that I would have never learned just by reading Reddit or whatever.

There is a world of difference between knowing that many people smoke weed, versus having not only memorized the numbers from the most reputable surveys but also having read through their methodology, as well as all of the scientific research that methodology is based on. (If your curious about the validity of self-reported drug use, check out this: http://archives.drugabuse.gov/pdf/monographs/Monograph167/Mo...)

I'm not trying to defend this story specifically, although I thought it was good, but there are definitely reasons for learning more about drugs even if you're already against prohibition.

(Also, for what it's worth, if you go through my submissions page there is an enormous amount of really intellectually interesting stuff related to drugs, drug use, the war on drugs, etc., and virtually all of it would be completely new to those reading it.)

Re:A serious drug problem by tptacek on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:35PM (#2031838)
I agree, but that's not this post, is it? You think it's a good story, so, how about saying why? It'll likely be the only productive debate on the thread.
Re:A serious drug problem by Alex3917 on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:57PM (#2031906)
What I thought was interesting:

* The information about Anklyosing Spondylitis. I know someone who has it.

* The low-income workers flushing their medications that they legitimately need because they are afraid of getting arrested, being forced to pay thousands to retain a lawyer, etc.

* The fact that if the DA says they have "reason to believe" you are going to sell your legally prescribed medication, you aren't even allowed to say that your doctor prescribed it or why you need it for medical reasons in your defense. So you essentially aren't allowed to defend yourself at all, which means you are all but guaranteed to go to prison based on the flimsiest of accusations.

Re:A serious drug problem by blahedo on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @03:14PM (#2032297)
I can't tell you for sure why 50 people upvoted it, but I can say why I posted it (and why I originally expanded on the given title): because unlike a lot of other articles about drug prohibition (pro or con) or other side non-computer topics (TSA, etc) of some interest to some HN readers, this one specifically explores its effect on average people. Not on crime or prison or nonviolent offenders or "real drug" users (we've heard a lot about all that), but on people who take what the French would call médicaments rather than drogues---which is a lot of people---and on the deeper implications of the "drug war" on their lives, their relationships with the law, and their interactions with police. Also the AS stuff, which is interesting, but it's background and setup for the main argument of the essay.

Also, the original title is not very descriptive and not only doesn't tell you its thesis, it doesn't even tell you which drug-related topic it's about.

Re:A serious drug problem by tptacek on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @03:18PM (#2032308)
If there's one person on HN who doesn't think drug prohibition is an ongoing tragedy, I'd be surprised to see them say it. If everyone is just going to find different (and prickly) ways to agree with the thesis of an article, and it's not directly germane to HN, I don't think it belongs here.

"Illustrating the true dimensions of a tragedy" is not a back door for political/public-policy issues.

Here is, I think, a valid acid test:

* Does the story generate genuine debate in the comments about the core idea in the story? (Not really.)

* Do the story itself mention Obama? (No.)

* Do the comments mention Obama? (Yes.)

... then something's wrong with the story for HN. Not every good story has a home here.

Re:A serious drug problem by blahedo on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @04:48PM (#2032583)
> Does the story generate genuine debate in the comments about the core idea in the story?

Well, I would have liked to see some debate about the nature of police states and what sorts of police actions make a population as a whole more rather than less likely to go to the police with their problems...

...but everyone was too busy arguing over whether the story belongs on HN to get that far. Um, my bad, I guess.

Re:A serious drug problem by tptacek on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @05:17PM (#2032682)
What debate? Seriously: you want a debate about something that virtually everyone on HN agrees about. There are right-leaning and left-leaning people alike on HN, but even Daniel Markham opposes the police state. Are we debating just to hear ourselves talk?

The question of whether stories like this belong on HN or not is more interesting than the other questions being discussed here, because at least this question has opposing interests and can lead to a conclusion of some sort.

Re:A serious drug problem by protomyth on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @01:43PM (#2032053)
I find the wording kind of problematic. If someone asked me if I was for "ending drug prohibition", I would have to say no. If someone asked me about specific ones, then I would probably say yes to some of them. I would have serious problems with the legalization of meth or crack. I would also say I don't want to give a huge loophole to pharmaceutical companies to put their wares on the streets without formal testing.