News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A serious drug problem by tptacek on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @03:18PM (#2032308)
If there's one person on HN who doesn't think drug prohibition is an ongoing tragedy, I'd be surprised to see them say it. If everyone is just going to find different (and prickly) ways to agree with the thesis of an article, and it's not directly germane to HN, I don't think it belongs here.

"Illustrating the true dimensions of a tragedy" is not a back door for political/public-policy issues.

Here is, I think, a valid acid test:

* Does the story generate genuine debate in the comments about the core idea in the story? (Not really.)

* Do the story itself mention Obama? (No.)

* Do the comments mention Obama? (Yes.)

... then something's wrong with the story for HN. Not every good story has a home here.

Re:A serious drug problem by blahedo on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @04:48PM (#2032583)
> Does the story generate genuine debate in the comments about the core idea in the story?

Well, I would have liked to see some debate about the nature of police states and what sorts of police actions make a population as a whole more rather than less likely to go to the police with their problems...

...but everyone was too busy arguing over whether the story belongs on HN to get that far. Um, my bad, I guess.

Re:A serious drug problem by tptacek on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @05:17PM (#2032682)
What debate? Seriously: you want a debate about something that virtually everyone on HN agrees about. There are right-leaning and left-leaning people alike on HN, but even Daniel Markham opposes the police state. Are we debating just to hear ourselves talk?

The question of whether stories like this belong on HN or not is more interesting than the other questions being discussed here, because at least this question has opposing interests and can lead to a conclusion of some sort.