>>Also, if you bought a product, you've signaled that the current feature set was worth the price.
I question whether this is the consumer expectation for iOS apps. Updates for apps are fast and free, and oftentimes apps are sold with the explicit promise of future updates that will contain various anticipated features. This and the fact that many apps are platforms that consumers expect will be maintained over a reasonable amount of time verses those of competitors.
I think you're spot on. With the top apps, you're buying into a platform.
Evernote is web, desktop, ios, etc, etc
Remember the milk is everywhere... so is Simplenote
> Implementing syncing as an independent developer kind of sucks.
But they have syncing. You can sync between your iPhone and Desktop copies of Things just fine with a cable. Extending that to work over a network connection with a third pseudo-device in the cloud shouldn't be two years worth of work.Wifi/Cable syncing of a desktop and phone app is a completely different beast to doing so over the internet. The difference is that when you connect your iphone to your laptop and sync, the app determines which one has the last state and updates accordingly. Over the air syncing would imply the possibility of different mediums having different states and having to consolidate all the data into a definite final state, preferably by updating, deleting, or creating single objects instead of a complete store of the data. Trust me, it's not that easy and lot's of implementations done already on other apps are not quality implementations. Actually a lot of implementations are really a hack plugged in to deliver the functionality asap. That being said, it's not something that should take two years in the making. Nevertheless, Things is already a great application in it's current state and well worth the money.
> the app determines which one has the last state and updates accordingly
Have you used Things' desktop sync? I have. It didn't do that. I frequently updated items on my phone while I was out, then did some work and added/completed other items on the desktop before I sync'd. It handled everything well.I'm not saying Things isn't worth the money; I bought a copy and frequently recommend it.
I did a presentation once on the topic: http://iphone2009.crowdvine.com/talk/presentation_file/5104/...
Also, if you bought a product, you've signaled that the current feature set was worth the price. If the developers want to add new features for free, that's a nice bonus.