News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by gfunk911 on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @07:11PM (#2029956)
Great article.

Choosing a place where people appreciate honest criticism works for friendships as well. My biggest criteria for friends is that the person is cool with honesty, including telling them when they're wrong.

Interesting point about how if you never fail, you're too conservative. The same idea applies to poker. Microsoft fails constantly and people accept it, yet every Google failure means they've lost their mojo. No Wave and no Buzz means no GMail.

Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by sriramk on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @08:05PM (#2030119)
Microsoft fails constantly and people accept it? :) I would argue the exact opposite - Microsoft succeeds consistently in a lot of very measurable ways but isn't given enough credit for it (that a Google/Apple would get for doing the very same thing).
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by gfunk911 on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @10:59PM (#2030521)
I didn't mean that people ignore instances when Microsoft fails. I meant that failing is an accepted part of Microsoft's DNA. People didn't like Vista, but putting out an (arguably) busted OS didn't seem out of character for Microsoft.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by napierzaza on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @09:36AM (#2031398)
That's just lowered expectations. They just don't put out quality innovation products and we're all used to that.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by endtime on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @04:42PM (#2032563)
Yeah, WP7 and Kinect are the same old tired crap, and they're definitely not doing anything interesting with Bing...?
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by mkramlich on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @05:52AM (#2031029)
The general pattern I've seen with Microsoft is they mostly just copy other people's successes. Sometimes their copies do okay, or well enough. Sometimes they fail. But due to their huge install base and lock-in effects and user inertia and huge cash pile they have the ability to muddle onward. In some ways, Microsoft treats Apple as a sort of external UI R&D department, one with the wonderful quality that Microsoft doesn't have to pay the Apple folks anything, just copy whatever people seem to like. I do think they succeed enough, at the right things, that it keeps them shambling forward. But the same is true of a zombie.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by khafra on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:38PM (#2031853)
Parsing note: "Microsoft doesn't have" should be repeated immediately after it appears.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by fjarlq on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @09:16PM (#2030307)
Care to list some examples? (Not that I disagree)
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by random42 on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @10:44PM (#2030491)
1. Project Natal/Kinect

2. Surface Table

Both are good innovations, on which media would go over gaga, had they come from Apple/Google.

Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by brk on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @09:12AM (#2031337)
Yes, but both of those are (I believe) technologies developed outside of Microsoft that were then purchased.

While Google and Apple do also purchase technologies, they seem to produce more interesting in-house products than Microsoft. At least in my perception.

I can't recall the last time that Microsoft actually developed internally and rolled out a significant "game changer" device or software.

Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by krschultz on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @10:46AM (#2031545)
Your perception of Microsoft may be correct, but it alsao applied to the others. Apple didn't invent multi-touch either. Google didn't do Android inhouse it was an acquisition (at least at first).
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by brk on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:59PM (#2031919)
No, but I would credit Apple with "inventing" the iPhone, iPad, MacBook Air. Even though all of those products likely have core pieces that were from acquisitions, it seems like Apple executed the grand vision of bringing it together.

Same thing with Google, though they appear to buy several things that they don't fully roll out (Dodgeball, etc.). Android may have originally been an acquisition, again it feels like Google made it into a finished product far beyond what they acquired.

Microsoft appears to have bought the Kinect technology/product and done little more than change the logo on the device. The surface table also hasn't been productized into anything revolutionary or different.

Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by sriramk on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @01:06AM (#2030713)
Kinect was on the top of my list. When I used Kinect, it seemed quite magical (and I'm jaded enough that few pieces of tech makes me go that way). I really suspect a Kinect from Apple would have been handled differently.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by mccutchen on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @01:15AM (#2030731)
You're probably right. But you've got to admit that Apple itself makes its products seem much more magical than Microsoft does. They do such a good job that it's really easy for the media to pick it up and run with it.

Nearly all of Microsoft's own promotional stuff is extraordinarily bad, especially in comparison to Apple.

Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by rahoulb on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @05:45AM (#2031024)
A big problem Microsoft has is their pre-announcements.

They will announce stuff before it's ready so when it does arrive there's no buzz about it. BUT it's a necessary culture for them because of the way their business interdepends upon their partners.

Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by intdev on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @02:02PM (#2032102)
I think the bigger problem that Microsoft faces is their tarnished past image. Whatever they make, no matter how innovative or well made it is, people's perception towards the product changes immediately when the word Microsoft is attached to it. This I think is the major PR and marketing challenge faced by Microsoft today. People need to move on and have a broader outlook. People will still bring up IE6 to support their anti-MS arguments.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by cdr on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:15AM (#2030644)
The media did go "gaga" over those, even despite the fact that 99.99% of people will never see a Surface.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by sz on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:45AM (#2030680)
How was Surface a success where Wave wasn't?
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by gregschlom on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @05:21AM (#2031001)
We can't really talk about the sucess or failure of Surface, actually. Microsoft sold a few of them at $12,000 each to hotels, luxury stores, etc... but never intended to make it a mass-consumer product.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by lancewiggs on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @07:06PM (#2033026)
which was a failure - a failure to commercialize a technology that we all wanted. Apple later delivered the iPad, and the rest is history.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by fuzzythinker on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @04:10AM (#2030919)
Kinect is a game changer, but most of its credit should be given to the company MS obtained the technology from.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by zaidf on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @04:26AM (#2030942)
From an academic point of view, perhaps. Bit from a business point of view, the credit goes to Microsoft for recognizing a hot piece of technology, acquiring it and launching it as a cool product. Each one of those things are more difficult than you seem to give them credit for.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by babeKnuth on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @12:20PM (#2031781)
xbox, bing
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by j_baker on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @09:00PM (#2030256)
People accept that Microsoft fails? Does the name "Windows Vista" mean anything to you? Of all the reactions people had to that version, "acceptance" isn't on the list.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by philwelch on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @09:08PM (#2030278)
To be fair, I can't imagine Google fucking up web search or AdWords without receiving the same kind of criticism. We can shrug it off when Google fucks up Wave, or when Microsoft fucks up Kin, as long as products like AdWords and Windows keep making money.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome by bad_user on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @07:24AM (#2031136)
Vista was 5 years late, overhyped, full of bugs and incompatibilities, slow and IMHO ugly.

For me it was the biggest failure I've seen since Netscape Navigator.

And while Windows 7 is not that bad, IMHO that's the next worst thing customers can say about your product.