News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by bradknowles on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:14PM (#20299394)
So, on the power side of the equation, I have come to understand why they chose to go the direction they did.

With the previous generation of MagSafe/MagSafe II power supplies, if the cable gets frayed, you have to replace the entire power supply. If the MagSafe connector gets hosed, you have to replace the entire power supply. Basically, if anything goes wrong beyond the AC input side, you have to replace the whole power supply. I ended up buying a whole bunch of these things over the years, so I am particularly sensitive to the amount of money I've spent.

With the USB-C power supplies, if something goes wrong with the cable, you just get a new cable. If something goes wrong with the connector on the cable, you just get a new cable. The only time you need to replace the entire power supply itself is if something goes wrong internally, or if something goes wrong with the USB-C connector on the power supply. And since cables are engineered to break before cable connectors, that is much less likely.

Don't get me wrong, the MagSafe connector has saved my machine on several occasions. But I understand why they want to be able to cheaply and easily replace just the cable part, because that's the part that is most likely to have hardware failures.

I do wish they had figured out some way to have a standardized cable interface on the power supply itself, and a MagSafe-like connector on the other end. That would have been the best of both worlds. But failing that, I think I will grudgingly take the second-best solution, which is to have a standard USB-C connector on both ends.

Now, this whole concept of mixing USB-C, USB-C Power Delivery, and Thunderbolt 3, that's a whole 'nother Gordian Knot that I really wish they had not created.

Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by thinkling on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:20PM (#20299444)
> if the cable gets frayed, you have to replace the entire power supply

This is true for the existing design but it would have been easy to redesign the power supply to avoid it.

Just look at the other end: the wall-plug end has long been replaceable; it slides out so you can put on a different plug or a longer cable. This could be true on the MagSafe side as well -- then any Mac power supply could be used with any generation Mac, just by switching out the MagSafe/USB-C end.

Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by mstade on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:34PM (#20299554)
But the MagSafe cable would serve exactly one purpose, whereas the usb-c cable does not. And now I can charge from Either side of the box too – great stuff! When my cable broke it wasn’t a big deal, I had an extra (shorter) cable I could use, and then go get a new one later. I’d be hard pressed to buy extra MagSafe cables to carry around just in case one broke, but the extra usb-c cables are actually useful or other things too.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by killjoywashere on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:59PM (#20299757)
What would be awesome is USB-C in a magsafe connector. Would the magnet interfere with the signal transmission at all?
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by jonesetc on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:53PM (#20300127)
I don't think so, you can buy usb-c magnetic adapters right now and I haven't heard any issues with them.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by killjoywashere on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:36PM (#20301280)
But you're not transmitting high speed data.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by zoom6628 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:27PM (#20299967)
Common sense and good design will not rule over sales generation thru designed in obsolescence. I had to buy new adapter with mag-safe for my 2013 Air. Got a new MBP at work a few days later and the replaceable cable makes so much sense. Now just needs a cable maker to produce a USB-C to MagSafe cable.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by carbocation on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:19PM (#20299428)
It seems like something like this could be best of both worlds: a magsafe power cable + USB-C connection:

https://www.amazon.com/Magnetic-Adapter-Connector-Quick-Char...

Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by dsego on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:10PM (#20299838)
Funny how other laptops (and I've owned PC laptops and macbooks) have cables that don't fray. Only Apple's old magsafe cable has that fine rubbery material that disintegrates with time, and no strain relief on the connector.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by xenospn on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:18PM (#20299896)
You know, I've never had that happen to me, and I've owned multiple MacBooks and iphones over many years.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by dsego on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:41PM (#20300046)
On my cables the material starts to crumble and crack. Something about that particular type of rubber. But maybe it depends on the market or where it is manufactured. I seem to remember some lasting longer than others, I think it didin't happen on the 2014 model, but did on my original 2011 charger and on the replacement I had to buy (within the first year). But the 2016 usb-c cable doesn't really have this issue I think. Maybe it's the climate, warmer summers?
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by Operyl on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:13AM (#20301665)
I found that this happened if you are around cigarettes. Once I moved away from that family member, I’ve not had another one die in that fashion since.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by dsego on Friday June 28, 2019 @05:50AM (#20302820)
Oh interesting, I did not think of that.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by xenospn on Friday June 28, 2019 @12:21PM (#20305934)
"Designed by Apple in California, where cigarettes do not exist"
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by Operyl on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:50PM (#20306975)
To be fair cigarettes do a ton of damage to a ton of materials.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by mstade on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:32PM (#20299998)
Happens all the time with any cables really. I've had many cables succumb to the good ol' lemme just adjust may chair right over your cable there type situations. Particularly when you have to run the cable to an awkwardly placed outlet.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by dsego on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:45PM (#20300072)
You can certainly damage a cable, but I'm sure those old thick black PC charging cables with a barrel connector are way sturdier than the flimsy but aesthetically pleasing macbook ones.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by varjag on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:34AM (#20301755)
I had those old barrel connectors tear too. Lenovo, Dell, you name it. It's not a new (or a particularly rare) problem.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by darkpuma on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:06PM (#20301152)
> "Happens all the time with any cables really."

That's such nonsense. I've never had a thinkpad cable wear out on me. I've got a whole box sitting around somewhere full of them because they never break. But thinkpad cables aren't unusually robust; Dell cables last just as long. Most cables last effectively forever unless you slam a door on them or something unreasonable like that.

The only cables I've seen reliably fall apart after no more than a few years are Christmas tree light strings from the dollar store, and Apple charging cables.

Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by aj7 on Friday June 28, 2019 @04:25AM (#20302451)
Exactly. I have a DRAWER full of nasty ones.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by notahacker on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:44PM (#20299627)
Every other consumer electronics manufacturer just figured out how to make cables that didn't fray, and it's nothing to do with the magnet...

The boon from the USB-C is that you can charge with a borrowed commodity cable when you've left your adapter at home and aren't in an office full of Macbooks. But it's been left to third parties to implement the concept of combining USB-C and a magnetic joint in the same cable. (I'd have been tempted to get into the manufacturing business if they hadn't...)

Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by nutjob2 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:59PM (#20299753)
I always hated the MagSafe connectors because I almost always used my laptop with the power connected but not on a table or other hard surface (eg a bed), and it would invariably fall off constantly.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by ridgeguy on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:52PM (#20300124)
I had this problem too on my 2015 MPB, when Apple went from Magsafe 1 to Magsafe 2, which was (vertically) thinner. The Magsafe 2 easily disconnected when there was even a little vertical torque.

I bought a Snuglet, a thin metal shell that inserts into the Magsafe recess on the MBP. It reduces vertical and horizontal clearance between the Magsafe connector halves. In my case, this has completely eliminated unwanted disconnects.

Disclaimer: no connection with Snuglet or NewerTech, just have found the product useful as advertised.

Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by dsego on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:14PM (#20299863)
USB-C is not making it better, my t480s cable is too heavy and you can see it tugging on the connector and it's not sitting straight but tilted. I already managed to break one USB-C socket on my 2016 macbook pro, I can see it breaking soon on the thinkpad if I don't caress it, which means not letting the cable hang and making sure not to bump it with my knee.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by aj7 on Friday June 28, 2019 @04:27AM (#20302459)
Or at least once a day.
Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by mbell on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:21PM (#20299922)
I was annoyed by the MagSafe removal but I've had 5 of these [0] since the change and I have zero complaints. My Neato has eaten them multiple times and they are still kicking and if they ever die, it's just a cheap cable rather than a new power supply. I went through multiple of the old magsafe power supplies despite ample application of Sugru [1]. Overall I think moving the magnetic disconnect to the cable is a good move.

[0] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B079NJM3VS/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b...

[1] https://sugru.com/

Re:Jony Ive to form independent design company with Apple as... by darpa_escapee on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:09PM (#20299832)
> With the previous generation of MagSafe/MagSafe II power supplies, if the cable gets frayed, you have to replace the entire power supply. If the MagSafe connector gets hosed, you have to replace the entire power supply. Basically, if anything goes wrong beyond the AC input side, you have to replace the whole power supply. I ended up buying a whole bunch of these things over the years, so I am particularly sensitive to the amount of money I've spent.

This is a design issue that doesn’t require a USB-C cable to fix.