News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A plan to phase out fossil fuel production in the US by sxates on Monday June 24, 2019 @06:07PM (#20269017)
Separate thought related to this--

I've personally made the following investments to reduce the amount of carbon dioxide I'm directly emitting -- and these are the sorts of things we'll need millions of people to do in the coming years:

* 6kw of solar panels (no A/C): $22,000 * Powerwall batteries to power house when not sunny: $18,000 * Whole house insulation as part of remodel: $15,000 * Conversion of all kitchen appliances from gas to electric: $5000 * Replace gas water heater with electric heat pump: $3-4000 * Electric car: $30k+ (mine was $50+)

The remaining gas-powered appliance in the house in our furnace, which I'll get to replacing in the next few years (est $15k) - at which point we'll probably also have a second electric car, and need to increase our solar production as well to keep up.

How many people can afford the above list for their homes? In 10 years if the above items cost half what they do now, how many can afford it then? How many landlords are going to make these investments for rental properties?

The transition we face is potentially economically stimulating (there's a lot of stuff to replace!), but also has really high up-front costs (and sunk costs) that will have to be managed. This goes both for national infrastructure all the way down to people's homes.

Re:A plan to phase out fossil fuel production in the US by wmf on Monday June 24, 2019 @06:37PM (#20269257)
Pretty much nobody can afford to do that. At best you could stop selling new gas appliances and gas cars at some point and then wait 20 years for the old ones to naturally fall out of use. But a corollary is that you have to slowly ramp up carbon prices over 20 years.
Re:A plan to phase out fossil fuel production in the US by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @08:22AM (#20273466)
I wonder how much carbon was emitted from all your investments.
Re:A plan to phase out fossil fuel production in the US by sxates on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @06:07PM (#20279535)
More than 0, hopefully less than will be offset.

But I think part of why you were accused of short term thinking here is that if we don't spend the carbon to build things like solar panels now, we'll never move off a carbon economy. We have to accept that manufacturing of anything isn't entirely green right now, but the solar panels we make now will enable the next solar panels to be built with less carbon, which will enable the next batch to be built with less carbon, etc.

Carbon will power the innovations that get us off carbon - no way around that. But we still have to do it so we can get to that end state where entire supply chains are electrified with renewable energy.

Re:A plan to phase out fossil fuel production in the US by truckerbill on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @10:46AM (#20274722)
Short term thinking
Re:A plan to phase out fossil fuel production in the US by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @01:59PM (#20276965)
As someone who doesn’t own a car or fly anywhere because of climate change I don’t think you can accuse me of short term thinking.
Re:A plan to phase out fossil fuel production in the US by truckerbill on Wednesday June 26, 2019 @06:02AM (#20283440)
That's really good to hear. It wasn't a personal attack, just calling out that one specific point you made. For reasons the sibling post pointed out.