It's good to remember in these situations that the perfect is the enemy of the good, and what Sanders is proposing has the advantage of maximum simplicity. If you listen to the advice of perfectionists like David Leonhardt, you're going to neither eat nor have your cake.
That is why you hear about free college, like Germany, and not one peep about what Germany's income tax brackets look like: http://www.worldwide-tax.com/germany/germany_tax.asp
Tax % Tax Base (EUR)
0 Up to 9,000
14% 9,001-54,949
42% 54,950-260,532
45% 260,533 and over
You see, in Germany, the guy making $80,000 is treated as a benefactor. He pays the 42% marginal income tax, 19% VAT, 7.5% social insurance contribution, etc. He doesn't get a $2.2 trillion windfall.My point about taxes is the flip side of the same criticism. "Progressive liberals" view the upper middle class as a marginalized class that should receive government benefits, not a privileged class that should pay for them. That's why Sanders' proposed tax brackets are the same as Trump's until above $250,000.
> Income bracket Tax
Lower limit Upper limit Rate
$0 – $18,450 10%
$18,451 – $74,900 15% <--- German 42% rate starts here
$74,901 – $151,200 25%
$151,201 – $230,450 28%
$230,451 – $250,000 33%
$250,001 – $500,000 37%
$500,001 – $2,000,000 43%
$2,000,001 – $10,000,000 48%
$10,000,001 – 52%
Put differently, upper middle class "progressive liberals" only believe in a progressive system to the extent they are on the receiving end of the welfare system. So that someone who paid $100,000 for college and has a $100,000 job in New York is treated as the proper recipient of government welfare, at the expense of those above them. But taxing that guy like the privileged class, to support the people at the bottom who truly need it, is off the table.People in the top 25% but outside the top 1% earn half of all income, $5 trillion, 2.5x as much as the top 1%. You need high taxes on that group to support an expansive welfare state. In Germany, Mr. NYC would be taking home $57,000, and he'd pay 19% VAT on cocktails in Munich.
Anyway, this hypothetical guy isn't helping my case, because we can either add or subtract virtues to make him more or less sympathetic. As someone who matched this description personally, I can tell you I did not feel "upper middle class" by any stretch of the imagination, which is what I was responding to.
Not only is this welfare to the upper middle and upper classes it is the big wealth transfer to colleges. Colleges who have no reason to keep costs down. Plus they also have the benefit not having to steer people to viable careers and can instead sell them on many cost increasing courses which are more padding for the college bottom line.
If the politicians were serious about education they would lock colleges into rates set by government for any education guaranteed part or in full by government. People fall all over themselves demanding that the medical costs be regulated, where are the screams for colleges to do the same when it comes to costs.
Simply put. A degree cost X dollars. Each course credit is Y. The college that wants their students to receive loans or partial to full payment must offer degrees and courses conforming to the cost the government assigns to that degree. The college must make a good faith effort to see the student graduates with the degree or pay a penalty.
They would fall over themselves to comply
It's not about a competition of loss; you're correct. But it's simply an expensive and unfair plan to forgive the debt of those who have it, without regarding why they have it. Either we take a more refined plan about how we forgive student debt, or we simplify even further and just give stimulus checks to everyone without any conditions.
Because the money comes out of everyone's pocket. How about free healthcare for more people, free child care so people can go to work etc etc? The govt can't just issue new dollars indefinitely, so there's a cost. I understand that colleges are very expensive and loans have made it even more expensive--just sign here and see you in 4 years. But since the money is coming out of the pooled money we have to think twice and consider everyone's problems.
Maybe more lower class people would go into this if they could afford it?
One of the selling points of the universal policy is that it’s the only way to get the votes of the well off but resentful, even if it’s staggeringly inefficient.
I agree
10% cap is nice and all, but not if you’re going to be paying it through middle age. Blunt loan forgiveness is not the answer, but reform is needed.
Sanders is the last person to do any reform ( real reform would come most likely from somebody like Andrew Yang ).
Education is first and foremost extremely political, almost everywhere and every country.
Milton Friedman knew it 40 years ago.
Letting a free market in education to exist would put a lot of service jobs at risk.
Education is how people who support a candidate get a job after elections are over.
Many prominent lieutenant and donors in the Democratic party end up in the educational sector, same applies in every other party in so many other countries it's unreal.
In Islamic countries, trying to reform education is much much harder than other areas. Everybody wants a say in what goes in the heads of other people's kids.
It is fine to have certain amount of transfer from the rich and middle class to the poor to pay for basic things, but pay for college should not be part of it. College is not crucial for living a good life.
I would agree with proposal to support pay for vocational / professional training. But college? No.
On that basis I would expect this to benefit the lower middle class, they accrued the debt without accruing the earning potential.
Fairly clear one of those 2 is getting a much better deal.
All that said I'm not from the US, so didn't expect fees to vary so much. (do they?)
The interest rate environment right now means that many of my high earner friends are not in a hurry to pay more than the minimum on their loans. Debt forgiveness for them will be a straight cash infusion against their net worth.
No idea what the percentage of each is.
That said one of the arguments for universal forgiveness is that it’s the only way to get major reform in the space. That seems like a crazy expensive premium to pay to me but maybe I’m naive about the appetite for improving others lives.
If we want to help people, we need to raise taxes on the middle and upper middle class and spend it on safety net services, like everyone else in the developed world: https://taxfoundation.org/how-scandinavian-countries-pay-the... https://www.oecd.org/tax/revenue-statistics-sweden.pdf (Sweden - 61 % of revenue from from middle class taxes: payroll, social insurance, and goods and services); https://www.oecd.org/tax/revenue-statistics-united-states.pd... (USA - 41% of revenue from same sources).
> “Education debt,” as Sandy Baum and Victoria Lee of the Urban Institute have written, “is disproportionately concentrated among the well-off.” The highest-earning quarter of the population holds more than a third of all student debt, while the lowest-earning quarter holds only 12 percent, according to Baum and Lee.
Less than 40% of those 18-29 have student loan debt: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/08/24/5-facts-abo.... Almost by definition, these are disproportionately the folks who were privileged enough to go to college to begin with. Moreover, the total debt is skewed towards the people with the highest income potential. The median debt for someone who doesn't attain a college degree is $10,000. Versus $45,000 for someone who attains a post-graduate degree.
The existing system we have is fine. Obama's PAY-E caps student loan payments at 10% of income. That means the people who end up with good jobs end up subsidizing everyone else. (The government kicks some money in too, but PAYE will only cost $180 billion over 10 years, instead of more than then times that in one shot.) If we need to fix the loopholes in that, let's do it. But under the current system, I as a private practice lawyer pay thousands of dollars a month to the government. Under Bernie's plan, I'd get a small mortgage worth of a windfall.
If we're going to raise taxes $2.2 trillion, it's criminal to not spend it on the people who need that money the most.