News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of stud... by jqgatsby on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:12PM (#20265057)
Is it the case that you are coming at this from a point of view that is opposed to progressive liberalism in general? That would have been helpful to mention up front, because the article you cite is actually arguing from the view of Sanders' proposal being insufficiently progressive. It seems disingenuous to me to cite it without clarifying that your own reasons for opposing the proposal are completely different.
Re:Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of stud... by rayiner on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:03PM (#20265725)
The article criticizes Sanders' proposal for allocating a large government benefit disproportionately to the middle class. I'm criticizing the proposal for the same reason.

My point about taxes is the flip side of the same criticism. "Progressive liberals" view the upper middle class as a marginalized class that should receive government benefits, not a privileged class that should pay for them. That's why Sanders' proposed tax brackets are the same as Trump's until above $250,000.

> Income bracket Tax

  Lower limit Upper limit Rate 
    $0 – $18,450              10% 
    $18,451 – $74,900         15%   <--- German 42% rate starts here
    $74,901 – $151,200        25% 
    $151,201 – $230,450       28%  
    $230,451 – $250,000       33% 
    $250,001 – $500,000       37% 
    $500,001 – $2,000,000     43%
    $2,000,001 – $10,000,000  48%
    $10,000,001 –             52%

Put differently, upper middle class "progressive liberals" only believe in a progressive system to the extent they are on the receiving end of the welfare system. So that someone who paid $100,000 for college and has a $100,000 job in New York is treated as the proper recipient of government welfare, at the expense of those above them. But taxing that guy like the privileged class, to support the people at the bottom who truly need it, is off the table.
Re:Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of stud... by jqgatsby on Monday June 24, 2019 @05:12PM (#20268535)
Your example of the guy who has $100K in student loans and is making a $100K salary in New York is a good example, but I think we very much disagree on how he should be treated. If he's living in NYC, his take-home is about $68k after taxes and he's laying out $3500/month in rent for a one bedroom and paying $1k/month for the loans. That leaves him $1100/month for utilities, medical, and, you know, food if he wants to eat. I know there are plenty of people who are worse off, but this guy is working a non-trivial job just to tread water. Why do you have so little sympathy for him?
Re:Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of stud... by rayiner on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @12:40AM (#20271242)
Because (1) he's objectively well off, having a one bedroom apartment to himself in New York itself being a sign of prosperity and privilege; and (2) because he's around the 90th percentile income level, and if we don't tax him heavily we cannot afford an expansive welfare state.

People in the top 25% but outside the top 1% earn half of all income, $5 trillion, 2.5x as much as the top 1%. You need high taxes on that group to support an expansive welfare state. In Germany, Mr. NYC would be taking home $57,000, and he'd pay 19% VAT on cocktails in Munich.

Re:Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of stud... by acheron on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @09:04AM (#20273754)
Living in a high cost of living area is voluntary consumption just as much as leasing a new BMW or going on European vacations twice a year. If he wants to stop "just treading water", then he can move somewhere else, such as a place that's not in the top 3 most expensive areas in the country; just like the guy with the BMW can buy a used Honda instead.
Re:Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of stud... by jqgatsby on Tuesday June 25, 2019 @10:13AM (#20274372)
That's a common fallacy. Places that have high paying jobs usually have high cost of living. You can't typically command high salaries in cheaper areas, but people seem to think that just by virtue of living in a certain area you are defacto well-off.

Anyway, this hypothetical guy isn't helping my case, because we can either add or subtract virtues to make him more or less sympathetic. As someone who matched this description personally, I can tell you I did not feel "upper middle class" by any stretch of the imagination, which is what I was responding to.