News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

collidge

"You framed it as people who don't deserve a break".

I'm quite sure you can't find a quote where I did this.

But anyway, you're focusing on this from a different point of view from the people you're arguing against. It's important to take note that there are (at least) 3 groups of people with interest in this conversation: people who've paid off their debt, people who have not paid off their debt because they've been unable to, and people who've not paid off their debt because they did not want to.

Those who've paid their debt are pointing out that it's unfair to retroactively support those who did not make the same frugal choices. (This is sort of what you're arguing against)

Those who are in debt because they are hard up for reasons beyond their control are arguing for paying off debt for anyone who has it.

I understand your interest at stake in saying we should forgive the debt. But you're being disingenuous if you ignore the point of the first group of people.

Instead of hashing out what's fair, let's give tax progressively and give a stimulus to everyone. This has the same benefit to those in debt, but avoids both the unfairness we're talking about and requires less government expense in paying accountants to determine who should get the benefit (because everyone gets it automatically).

"Moreover the insinuation that the only people in student loan debt are irresponsible is nonsense."

This isn't what I said. If you want to twist other people's words, I can do that too: "There are unfair things in life therefore we should not put any effort into trying to make our own policies fair".

No one once in this topic has said "exclusively due to immoral choices".
If the government sent everyone a check for $20k, this would be more fair regarding your concerns and the concerns of those of us who are against forgiving student debt for the reasons in this thread.

It's not about a competition of loss; you're correct. But it's simply an expensive and unfair plan to forgive the debt of those who have it, without regarding why they have it. Either we take a more refined plan about how we forgive student debt, or we simplify even further and just give stimulus checks to everyone without any conditions.

I get helping those who are legitimately low income. But this is much broader than that.

Please explain how this is not rewarding those who chose to spend their money on luxuries instead of paying their debt. What about those of us who paid off our debt by living frugally?

As someone in favor of universal health care, subsidizing college, etc, I'm still against this particular policy decision. It's badly-thought-out populist candy.