News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by gman83 on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:39AM (#20263948)
Or just don't buy a car.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by SEJeff on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:41AM (#20263965)
That isn't an option for 90% of the country (in the US at least).
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by bilbo0s on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:52AM (#20264092)
I suspect that HN User gman is trying to make exactly that point. (I could be wrong though.)

I wonder if 30 to 40 years from now, we'll be having the same convo about electric cars that we are having about recycling plastic? Something that seemed good on the surface, but masked all kinds of externalities.

I mean, at least electric should be a bit better than ICE in daily use. But will making these things at scale in the first place cost too much in the way of carbon production? Or other forms of pollution that we as consumers don't even know about yet? You may say, "well it was your job as a consumer to know the impact your purchases were having." But I'm just not that knowledgeable about that stuff. I don't know if a billion electric cars are bad or good? And it might not even be the cars, just the fact that we have to make the roads may be polluting somehow? Or whatever? It's just too much for a consumer to know. Should I be buying electric? Or supporting mass public transit? Which is better? Or is it just a question of which is worse? There's a lot to think about there.

Or maybe it's just me?

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by ljcn on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:22AM (#20264411)
It is an interesting question. The best option is almost certainly to not use a car (walk, cycle, or bus instead). The emissions are much lower[1] (absolute and per-distance) and you might get some health benefits.

If a car is needed it depends how you're planning to power it.

This answer[0] does a great job of looking at the energy inputs of building a car. I thought the up-front cost would be higher but the emissions from producing a car are comparable to the emissions of using the car for a few years.

So if the choice is between a used ICE car and a new EV and charging it with renewable energy, it's (surprisingly) probably worth buying the new EV.

If you're planning to charge it with power from a coal plant though you should probably get the used ICE car.

[0] https://www.quora.com/How-much-energy-is-required-to-build-a... [1] https://ecf.com/news-and-events/news/how-much-co2-does-cycli...

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by sandworm101 on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:42AM (#20264664)
>> and you might get some health benefits.

That depends. There are streets in the UK so polluted that jogging on them, breathing in lots more bad air, is actually worse for you than not jogging. Similarly, the violent accident rate for bicycle commuters is scary. I don't know of any regular commuter who hasn't been to hospital at least once.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by WorldMaker on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:20PM (#20265944)
Both of those are more reasons to ban cars. ;) Most spot pollution is car exhaust, and most violent pedestrian/bike accidents are car-related.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by ljcn on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:46PM (#20266263)
In addition non-negligible sources of particulates are tyres and brakes wearing down.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by sandworm101 on Monday June 24, 2019 @03:10PM (#20267266)
I said violent accent, not cars. People commuting on bikes collide with other things than cars. Regular bike commuters can hit 50+kph. At those energy levels, hitting a curb or tree branch can put you in hospital.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by tonyedgecombe on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:57PM (#20265659)
The statistics show that even allowing for the risks cycling is better than not.

Having said that I have had a hospital visit.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by ljcn on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:47PM (#20266280)
Yes the last time I checked this was the case. Most western cities are clean enough that cycling is still a net-win.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by lorenzobr on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:17AM (#20264360)
I bet you don't believe in climate change either, do you?
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by bilbo0s on Monday June 24, 2019 @03:17PM (#20267349)
Just for full disclosure, I believe in climate change. But I'm not sure I believe that having electric cars is better than having electric trains or buses? I honestly don't think it's stupid for me to ask whether or not having electric cars is the best strategy for dealing with climate change.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by andyhmltn on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:46AM (#20264724)
That's a hell of an assumption to make
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by gman83 on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:50AM (#20264072)
Don't something like 80% of Americans live in urban or sub-urban areas? I live in a suburban area in Europe and have no problems getting around with public transportation. I get my groceries delivered by the shop.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by ckuhl on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:04AM (#20264227)
The definition of what a suburban area is in North America vs. Europe are so different they really need different words.

A typical suburb in the US will have no public transportation, and be so sprawled out that bicycling or walking between places would be impossible for a working adult.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by WorldMaker on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:24PM (#20265989)
"Exurb" isn't used enough to describe American suburbs, but is certainly appropriate. Suburban sprawl got so bad that the original suburbs of a lot of cities, that were built with public transit in mind, today Americans think of as "city core" or "inner city" and don't even recognize as suburbs anymore. Meanwhile most of what Americans imagine suburbs to be are more accurately exurbs, and exurban living is seen as more normal than the traditional relationships between cities and their suburbs for a number of unhealthy reasons.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by TulliusCicero on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:08PM (#20264994)
I'm an American in Munich, suburbs here are still walkable, bikeable, and often have a solid S-Bahn connection to the city center.

In America, most suburbs are bad for walking, actively hostile to biking, and have either no public transit or nearly unusable public transit.

The cities are usually not much better, either. Only a handful in the US have public transit that can even be called decent, let alone good.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by SEJeff on Monday June 24, 2019 @01:12PM (#20265860)
This so much ^
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by colanderman on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:58AM (#20264170)
Most American suburbs are not well served by public transportation.

Personally, I've lived in many cities, suburbs, and rural areas in the northeast US (population-dense, relatively friendly toward ecological initiatives) and tried to use public transit whenever possible. My experience is that public transport outside cities is practically nonexistent. In cities, there are only buses and they're annoying/slow/don't go where you need them.

Only now that I live in the immediate vicinity of Boston do I have useful public transit options, yet still, owning a car is a necessity to get to anything outside the city.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by sp332 on Monday June 24, 2019 @12:07PM (#20264984)
Yeah it's only 90% of the county by land area. If you count by people it's probably a lot lower. But keep in mind that public transportation is terrible even in dense places where it could make a huge difference in the US.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by AgloeDreams on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:00AM (#20264193)
Sub-urban America is not 'no car' America, lacking public transport, the downright scale of American cities, and a car-focused traffic/zoning design makes bikes, walking, and bussing simply just not practical.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by stephencanon on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:54AM (#20264129)
Meh. We live in a town of 12,000 people (big town for the area, but in a very rural part of the US). My wife and I share one car, and walk/bike/take transit more often than we drive--the car is mostly for getting our daughter to daycare in the winter and for when my wife is on call at the hospital. There are plenty of folks in the area who don't drive at all.

There are certainly parts of the US where a car is necessary, but 90% is pushing it. It may well be that 90% of people think that they need a car, though.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by pyromine on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:09AM (#20264286)
You may find that due to your socioeconomic status it may be more feasible to be a one car-transit using family, but for many americans who may work two jobs with a hour break between them (or situation similiar) they seriously may only manage to be able to make their schedule work with a car. (Just an example situation)

Being car-less in America is hard, I lived in a the suburb of a main city and if I was to use transit options to get to work I would have spent 3 hours a day on commute alone. That's simply not feasible. Similarly I used to work a job from midnight to noon (and a year later noon to midnight) and there simply was no feasible transit option for such a schedule, and with the sprawling nature of the suburb carpooling wasn't much of an option either.

Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by neuronic on Monday June 24, 2019 @11:19AM (#20264370)
This is the real problem that needs to be addressed instead of churning out different cars.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by lorenzobr on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:49AM (#20264069)
The real option is autonomous cars which you can call with a Uber-like app when you need it. That way we would have less cars but we would maximize the utilization rate of the ones we'd keep on the roads.
Re:BMW is accelerating electrification plans by rplnt on Monday June 24, 2019 @10:51AM (#20264083)
> (in the US at least)

In the US only.