News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by Spooky23 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:18PM (#20234359)
You have supply and demand, both drive prices.

Airbnb changes the demand curve by letting residential zoned property be commercial short term rentals. It also doubles down by undermining actual hotels.

So you can react by saying just more houses. And I can react by saying “don’t do Airbnb, which is often illegal anyway.” We’re both right.

Capital shouldn’t have higher preference over citizens.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by dkhenry on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:34PM (#20234543)
There are a lot of people out there who argue that building more houses won't help solve the high cost of housing. I have also found a lot of those people complain Airbnb is driving up pricing. To not acknowledge the supply problem ( and the supply solution ), but to say the minimal change in demand caused by Airbnb is the problem to me is just dishonest.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:54PM (#20234786)
Name one mega city with lots of housing where the prices have actually gone down. It isn't rocket science: add more supply in a hot area, it attracts more demand. Kind of like how building wider highways doesn't really do anything for traffic jams.

Most cities would like to keep their growth in check somehow so they have the appropriate infrastructure ready for it. Things that distort that (AirBNB, Chinese speculators, etc...) throw all of that off.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by cpitman on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:37PM (#20235224)
Induced Demand (ie "bigger highways leads to more traffic") depends on having an alternative. IE, traffic can take a different route, people can take public transit, people can stay home, etc.

It sounds like you are claiming that it is impossible to out build housing demand. This cannot be true. There is a finite population of people that want to live in any one place.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by Spooky23 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @04:31PM (#20237037)
You are correct and the argument you are responding to is evidence of the boom period we are in.

The NY Metro area is the definitive example of what you are talking about. Every lane of highway or bridge built increased traffic because it enabled someone to get the house they wanted cheaper somewhere else.

Now, construction costs are too high and land is in tight supply. The result? Infill of formerly blighted areas (aka gentrification).

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by aesthesia on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:31PM (#20235155)
Induced demand is not an infinitely scalable effect. There is some point at which adding more lanes will in fact reduce traffic congestion (ignoring logistical issues with extremely wide roads, which isn't the point of the induced demand argument).

With housing, the induced demand is mediated by housing prices. More housing lowers prices, which attracts more demand, which raises prices. But it's not going to raise prices above where they would have been had no new housing been built. (If prices were higher in the more housing scenario, what's stopping the person who moved to the city at those higher prices from moving in the less housing scenario?)

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by dkhenry on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:43PM (#20235279)
So what you just claimed here is that adding more supply attracts more demand. With that logic by removing supply we reduce demand. So Airbnb would be reducing demand, especially on infrastructure since part time residents don't use the most expensive infrastructure ( schools ).

Also there are cities where housing prices have stayed in check, and generally they have done it by building more supply. Here is a ink to a graph that show the difference between Dallas and Atlanta and San Francisco ( https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=oe8E ). For reference Atlata had over twice as many new units constructed per year as San Francisco with half the population. This is why I say denying the supply side fix is dishonest. There is no reasonable measure where what you claim about supply attracting demand is true.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:56PM (#20235418)
Eventually it would right? If rents shoot up and people can’t make a living at it in that city, they will simply go elsewhere. AirBNB also doesn’t need public schools or the other businesses and services that are dedicated to residents, so those would go away also (and do in Airbnb heavy areas).

Dallas and Atlanta are nit great examples, as they basically have unlimited land to expand on.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by fjsolwmv on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:13PM (#20234963)
Chinese speculators reduce growth by keeping property vacant. Airbnb doesn't affect growth.

House prices are not growth, and they generate the tax revenue that you say helps get the infrastructure ready.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:28PM (#20235114)
Building more supply to keep up with demand, no matter how real, would be growth.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by carapace on Thursday June 20, 2019 @02:17PM (#20235638)
> building more houses won't help solve the high cost of housing

It won't:

> Building enough housing to roll back prices to the "good old days" is probably not realistic, because the necessary construction rates were never achieved even when planning and zoning were considerably less restrictive than they are now. Building enough to compensate for the growing economy is a somewhat more realistic goal and would keep things from getting worse.

https://experimental-geography.blogspot.com/2016/05/employme...

Unless we do something dramatic and Bucky Fuller-istic like...

https://www.berkeleyside.com/2018/08/02/prefab-housing-compl...

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by dkhenry on Thursday June 20, 2019 @04:45PM (#20237165)
It will and your links even say that

> If the (first) model is correct, it would take a 53% increase in the housing supply (200,000 new units) ... to cut prices by two thirds

There is no reason you couldn't build that many new units over a ten year period. In fact if San Francisco increased its construction to match D.C. it would have that many new units in less then a decade

edit: Just to clarify, the only limitation is political. People don't want to allow the construction required and would rather pass protectionist laws that effectively lead to the Housing and Homeless crisis you see in SF and LA. In so much that you can convince Rich San Franciscans that those poor people they keep saying they care about should be able to have a reasonable path to getting housing you could fix it in less then a decade

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by carapace on Thursday June 20, 2019 @07:20PM (#20238427)
Assuming the model has that predictive power is there really the physical capacity to build that much without adopting radical methods like the instant dorm? And if there is, is that really the best option?

One the one hand, I grew up in SF and it's been hard coming to terms with the idea that I'll never be able to own my own home here. At this point I'm just glad that there's still (relatively) cheap land in the eastern part of the state.

One the other hand, I don't want the city I love to be changed for the worse by rampant growth with the admixture of profit-driven decision-making to make the situation even more complicated. I've already got the futureshock[0], I don't think more-of-the-same accelerated 10x would result in a great place to live.

One the gripping hand, I'd love to renovate the mega-structure of the Bay Area, clear off and revitalize the old creeks and replace the lost housing with arcologies[1].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Future_Shock

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arcology

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by dkhenry on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:40PM (#20238863)
If you don't assume the model has predictive power, then why bother listing it as a source? The real issue is what you say in the second part of your comment, people don't want the city to change. So in an attempt to live in a world that doesn't exist any more they try to hold back change and hope Prop 13 will allow them to wait out all the interlopers.

The city has changed and its a hellscape. No one can live there unless they bought their house in the early 90's or before. Teachers, Police, Firefighters, and every other kind of public servant is paid below the poverty line for the city they are supposed to serve. Low income people are forced further and further out, and entire economic sectors are starting to experience people insolvency. The city is being slowly turned into a monoculture of tech workers, and office buildings. The only thing the people of the city can bring themselves to do is try to legislate ever more controls on change and try to keep the city in some sort of 80's time warp. However they just banned selling e-cigarettes, and passed a law making sure the government doesn't use facial recognition software so I guess they don't feel the crisis of homelessness or high rents is something that should be given their attention.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by carapace on Friday June 21, 2019 @01:33AM (#20240112)
> If you don't assume the model has predictive power

I am assuming that for the sake of discussion. Part of the reason I link to that article is because the author seems to me to be data-driven and careful about how much you can accurately predict from the data he collected and analyzed.

> people don't want the city to change.

I can't speak for everyone, but for me it's not about preserving the city in amber, I don't want it to become like Manhattan or Tokyo. Like I said above, I want to make cool high-tech arcologies and revitalize the ecology of the Bay.

> The city has changed and its a hellscape. No one can live there unless they bought their house in the early 90's or before. Teachers, Police, Firefighters, and every other kind of public servant is paid below the poverty line for the city they are supposed to serve. Low income people are forced further and further out, and entire economic sectors are starting to experience people insolvency. The city is being slowly turned into a monoculture of tech workers, and office buildings.

You're preaching to the choir here brother. You left out the traffic and insane drivers.

> The only thing the people of the city can bring themselves to do is try to legislate ever more controls on change and try to keep the city in some sort of 80's time warp. However they just banned selling e-cigarettes, and passed a law making sure the government doesn't use facial recognition software so I guess they don't feel the crisis of homelessness or high rents is something that should be given their attention.

Yeah, SF city politics is a shit-show. Everyone is so busy being Progressive that they can barely make any progress. (You like that line? You can use it. ;-) But you're being unfair IMO. I watch SFGOVTV and I can tell you that people are very much concerned about and working on homelessness and out-of-control rents (along with a lot of other weird stuff. Like "Legacy Businesses", what's up with that? I'm kind of a lefty and even I feel that that's "commie-pinko" level economic meddling. But then again, I like most of the businesses that get on the registry and receive money. I can't really hate something too much that if it helps them stay viable through the rough seas. But then again again, it's such a blatant political machination: you have to get a Supervisor to sponsor your business to be considered. Or what about this new system they're rolling out to make homeless people use a special card and account with the city to receive any help. Orwellian surveillance is fine if we are using it to help them, eh? Or the police whose job it is to board buses and trains and "check your papers" to make sure you're not evading fare. That's not progressive, it's imperial. What would be progressive is making the buses free to ride. Or doing like in Seattle: it's not the drivers' job to collect fares. You can ride the bus in Seattle without paying. You're supposed to, but if you're broke you can just mumble an apology to the driver and ride anyway.)

Er, um, rant over. Sorry about that. SF city politics is a hellofa drug...

Anyhow, we need to come together and think clearly about things to solve any of this. We have to balance growth (population and economic) with quality of life, advances in technology, ecological harmony, international politics and financial stuff, etc...

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by Spooky23 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @08:33PM (#20238819)
No way. Who is going to fund billions of dollars of construction that will crash the market? Nobody.

Commercial real estate is about cashing in quickly and selling shares of accelerated depreciation. Not gonna happen.

Woke rich people will continue to feel good about not chasing off the homeless people sleeping behind the garbage can and cash in. When the market tanks, they’ll walk away.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by ng12 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:35PM (#20234552)
> Airbnb changes the demand curve by letting residential zoned property be commercial short term rentals

Sure, but how big is that change? The article references 31,000 homes in a country of 37 million people. If you assume the average of 3 people per home that's only "displacing" ~0.2% of the population.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by parthdesai on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:39PM (#20234601)
That's not even correct way to look at it. Airbnb's tend to be concentrated in more nicer residential areas, where if you can afford, you want to rent.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by ng12 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:42PM (#20234634)
I'm not sure what your point is.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by parthdesai on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:53PM (#20234759)
You are taking into account the entire population of the country while calculating the displacement of the population, while Airbnb units this article is referencing tend to be concentrated in certain neighbourhoods of certain cities. Your calculation is off by a mile.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by ng12 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:55PM (#20234797)
Why are you assuming the distribution of AirBnBs is significantly different than the distribution of Canada's population?
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by parthdesai on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:15PM (#20234983)
Do you actually believe that you have equal amount of Airbnb's in Jane and Finch compared to Entertainment district even though population in the respective areas might be comparable?
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by ng12 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:23PM (#20235067)
Again really not sure what your point is. If you can't afford Entertainment district move to another one -- unless you're arguing that AirBnB is the reason why the Entertainment district is expensive.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by parthdesai on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:50PM (#20235349)
Airbnb is a part of the reason. There are studies out there that show that the rents in nicer neighbourhoods have gone up more than the average increase in the city. It is easier for the landlords to Airbnb the unit and make more money compared to renting it out long term. This decreases the supply of available long term units, which in turn increases the rent. Now is Airbnb the only cause for increase in rental prices? Hell no, but it definitely is a catalyst. I do think that Airbnb is beneficial if it was used the way it was meant to be, but it just has become another investment avenue for the rich now while fucking over people who actually work and live in the city but can't afford to buy a place.
Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by Retric on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:40PM (#20235248)
It’s clearly increasing the price over what it would be. Just because X is affordable does not make X + a little bit more affordable.

So, now you not only displace people from that location you want the displacement to casecade across the rental market forcing large numbers of people to have a worse commute and or pay more in rent. Perhaps some people could possibly have a major problem with that idea.

PS: You can actually just search locations on Airbnb it’s rather concentrated magnifying this impact.

Re:Airbnb likely removed 31,000 homes from Canada’s rental m... by Spooky23 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @01:25PM (#20235082)
Airbnb’s tend to be near central business districts or other attractions.

If by offering short term rentals you take 30% of the rentals off the market (which may only be 100 apartments), that has a huge impact. Rental prices are all about marginal demand.

There are other factors as well — there is a de facto price floor due to section 8 prevailing rent. Because of factors like the “just build” doesn’t work, as profitable new construction is high-end, and the older stock tends to turn into defacto hotels.