News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by olliej on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:33AM (#20233930)
I’m generally pro-right to repair bills but I’m not clear how far they can reasonably go - should companies that make phones or whatever with custom cpus (Apple, Samsung, etc with completely custom chips or custom configurations - arm licensees etc) be required to sell those chips freely?

I’m not trying to be unreasonable: being able to replace a broken screen without replacing the entire device is reasonable, but there must Shirley* be a line across which repair is unreasonable.

* :D

Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by ben509 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:57AM (#20234157)
You don't need to require OEMs sell their parts. They just need to be unencumbered by IP and other restrictions, i.e. customs. Then the parts will become available on the secondary market as companies disassemble dead devices and resell them.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by olliej on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:10PM (#20234279)
So Apple should be required to license their cpu design to other companies?
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by th3l3mons on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:33PM (#20234526)
Apple has used US Customs to seize parts intended for repairs, including parts from donor boards. Apple sued (and last I knew was trying to appeal) a Norway repair shop for repairing iPhones using "counterfeit" components. iirc, some parts, including the display, must match appropriately or the OS won't boot as a form of parts validation, effectively preventing display swaps when repairing.

I don't think the previous comment was licensing the design. Apple has been very aggressive with donor parts and data recovery.

Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by olliej on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:42PM (#20234633)
I’d be interested in knowing where those parts came from - do they come from Apple facilities (because apple does refurbish devices) or do they come entirely from third party recyclers?

I’ve seen plenty of articles about parts coming directly from factories, rather than from torn down devices.

What is the actual ratio of stolen vs recovered by non-Apple facilities ?

I’m sure Apple would claim 100% stolen and rtr orgs would say 100% recovered. Note that Apple pays (in the form of a discount) for returned devices so if a refurbisher is selling parts they’ve claimed aren’t recoverable they are selling stolen goods (reason for destroying irrecoverable devices is to reduce/remove incentive for this type of theft)

Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by kcbanner on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:18PM (#20234354)
How does third parties disassembling and reselling parts equate to licensing a cpu design?
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by olliej on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:22PM (#20234395)
A most of the time the third parties are sourcing from recovered parts, they’re dealing in parts stolen from factories.

But you are right - if they did gets the parts from a different device they should be allowed to reuse them freely.

Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:32PM (#20234512)
> A most of the time the third parties are sourcing from recovered parts, they’re dealing in parts stolen from factories.

Wonder if there's any data on that. Given the extent to which China recycles electronics (some of which I've seen myself), it wouldn't surprise me if China-sourced replacement components were actually recovered from discarded devices.

Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by olliej on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:44PM (#20234654)
Apple also has refurbishment programs that tear down and rebuild devices, I suspect some of those refurb parts are reported to Apple as being destroyed but then sold.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by Drakim on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:54AM (#20234124)
Indeed, however, there are certain "no brain" borders we can cross right away. For instance, it should not be illegal to repair your device. But ouch, we have already made ourselves an enemy of huge parts of several big industries.

The world is a bit crazy sometimes.

Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by pjc50 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:47AM (#20234064)
I think the barrier should be drawn at not trying to prevent the boards being re-sold; fabricating an entirely new one from scratch may be infeasible, but they will turn up on the secondary market.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by Buttons840 on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:38AM (#20233988)
In many scenarios, simply having the company not sue you if you did get your hands on a CPU replacent is an improvemt.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by olliej on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:55AM (#20234140)
Except if the company doesn’t sell those cpus separately, in which case you know you’re buying stolen goods.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by hombre_fatal on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:21PM (#20234391)
Well, they could be scavenged from existing devices that were already sitting around destined for trash.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by JaimeThompson on Thursday June 20, 2019 @02:45PM (#20235946)
So if I take a CPU and remove it from the motherboard than resell it separately it would be stolen if the CPU was only sold bundled with a board by the manufacturer?
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by zaksoup on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:36AM (#20233966)
Honestly every time I hear somebody throw out a hypothetical example of “is this [RTR Requirement] too far” my reaction is immediately “wow that sounds like a fantastic idea”
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by legohead on Thursday June 20, 2019 @11:44AM (#20234035)
If they are still creating those chips, yes, why not?
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by olliej on Thursday June 20, 2019 @12:05PM (#20234237)
Because the companies make enough chips for the devices they are building, they aren’t making extra.
Re:Support for right-to-repair laws slowly grows by amelius on Thursday June 20, 2019 @05:58PM (#20237802)
Someone has to define what a "part" is. If a transistor in your CPU is broken, then is the "part" the transistor, the CPU, the board+CPU, or the entire phone?