IMO, it's a small step towards a better direction. The "validator" consensus (oligarchy) is a much more transparent/inclusive solution compared to the closed financial ecosystems of Wechat/Alipay/Paytm/Grab. If Libra is an oligarchy, closed financial systems are dictatorships
Given the global financial system is not controlled by one individual, it isn't a Dictatorship (power of one) but is more like a form of Oligarchy (power of the few). As for which form of Oligarchy each are, I'd argue that the existing financial system is more of a Technocracy (i.e. you need to know what you are doing to be one of the few) whereas Libra is a Plutocracy (you need to be wealthy to be one of the few) or even possibly a Kleptocracy depending on how they actually run it and what their true motives are.
Agreed. The same way governments require a large amount of capital to be a bank to ensure depositors of liquidity. You need to have capital to back the Libra tokens, otherwise it can get pretty scary, just like USD Tether shenanigans.
> or even possibly a Kleptocracy depending on how they actually run it and what their true motives are.
Banks, Central Banks, Governments, etc. whatever. Their motives are exactly "secret" when it comes to managing currencies. They all gear towards enriching their currency and making it more valuable. So yeah for this "oligarchy", I'd bet it's the same, Kleptocracy it is.
The main central banks usually have a monetary policy clearly defined by their governments. Typically this will include things like "target of keeping inflation at 2%"[0]. This is not exactly secret. It can however be very difficult for people without the necessary backgrounds to fully understand. But I guess we are living in an era of short attention spans and distrust of experts, which provides a fertile breeding ground for cryptocurrency conspiracy theorists to exploit for personal profit.
I agree about classical closed financial services like visa and mastercard being financial dictatorships. That is why their involvement doesn't really build trust.
Sixteen Tons is applicable.
You are on the right path, don't stop there :-)
Then W3C and the USB-IF are also "oligarchies" and dystopian?
A bunch of institutions working together is presumably a lot more trustworthy and less prone to abuse by anyone individually than a single institution, which maybe you would call a "monarchy"?
Really not sure what's dystopian about this at all. Do you think MasterCard and Visa networks are dystopian too, or that national currencies themselves are dystopian?
There is a major difference between settlement being operated by a democratic government, which will therefore handle the payments market with the public’s interest in mind…
…and it being operated by a for-profit.
Monetary policy (eg. target inflation rates) can be driven by investors, at the expense of social stability.
You won't even need to vote, they will already know how you feel about the candidates.
I'm just wondering at what point does the whole 'only the federal reserve is legally permitted to mint currency' thing kick in. With Bitcoin you can make an argument that it's too different... but with this, they're literally setting up a reserve banking system but putting gigacorps in the place of Congress in terms of deciding fiscal policy.
How long until someone uses this against the “oligarch“ validators?
E.g.: an AdBlock browser extension is on unless they send some microfunds to your account / transfer Libra funds to you.
If you’re not familiar with display ads it’s a literal bidding war per space per user by the advertiser. Platforms don’t care they just get a cut.
Now, I could see this: turn it around and have this “central authority” by having them bidding for you to turn on your ads based on their data’s understanding of likeliness to click.
You can already kind of do that with other crypto currencies. For e.g. > 70% of bitcoin mining happens inside China, and the currency is susceptible to a 51% attack (in theory anyway). This site calculates the cost of executing such an attack.
Nor is susceptibility to a 51% attack relevant to that point.
I think the implication is that since China does not have meaningful rule of law, that 70% of mining could in practice controlled by one entity: the Chinese state.
What's actually far more dystopian is the power that Visa, Mastercard and Paypal already have. It's not getting worse with this new thing, it's getting better.
Nobody has to use Libra, but getting by without access to Visa/Mastercard/Paypal is a real problem for businesses.
Ripple can freeze accounts, and has done this before to prevent an early founder from selling their XRP, which I think exemplifies the level of control the team has over the network. [https://insidebitcoins.com/news/not-so-decentralized-ripple-...]
Ripple I think would be more appropriately called a "centrally-managed cryptocurrency" rather than "decentralized". This is not to say it's doomed, but rather just that many XRP proponents misunderstand the technology and claim it shares technical properties with Bitcoin which it actually lacks. A known team controlling any cryptocurrency to this extent puts the entire currency at risk of rubber-hose and insider attacks.
This is a laughably meaningless statement in the context of a cryptocurrency. For which currency could someone possibly say that the supply does not outpace demand? What would that even mean? The precise amounts of supply or demand are irrelevant since the market will naturally find an equilibrium at wherever the current market price is.
I hope this educated your mind. The education system in many parts of this country has huge problems and I'm glad that uneducated people from deficient areas that lack basic math programs for people with special needs come to Hacker news too learn more. I applaud you for taking the initiative to learn!
Other than that, what I really didn't like about your response is your insulting tone. The parent poster did nothing to deserve such a response. "laughably meaningless statement" is a vile and disgusting statement in itself. There are other ways to critique someone's statement. The way you did it is highly immature.
Bitcoin: $0.30 per transaction
XRP: $0.43 per 100,000 transactions
True believers forget that normal people have zero interest in spending energy thinking about their financial system. Just give me a card backed by a company whose name I've heard of and who I can sue if I have to and then let me focus on my life.
Many mining pools have models extremely similar to Uber's business model. Others (including one of the major players) are completely private.
Corporate censorship, on the other hand, is abundant and is widely accepted. Lots of left-leaning people even proudly support it these days (for obvious reasons).
So no, pools are not like corporations, and generally crypto currencies have attracted more libertarian crowds.
Bitcoin is decentralized in theory alone. Fundamentally Bitcoin has structural flaws due to its design that create a self-reinforcing cycle of centralization. The corporation with the deepest pockets can survive the sparse rewards. They can reinvest in hardware, reducing the value of everyone's hardware. This runs people out of business (or forces them to join the largest company). Once they have enough market share they can set transaction prices as they like.
Transaction prices have grown 20x in the last 3 years. Even more than that considering you need to pay for accelerated transactions to have a good chance of the payment going through within an hour (a requirement for most real currency use-cases).
I'd be happy if you could explain how this is wrong, but in years of asking this to crypto enthusiasts, I still haven't found a convincing argument of how cryptocurrencies can truly be decentralized while serving real-world use-cases.
^Corporations don't generally censor by banning - that would be stupid because they'd lose the lawsuit. They prioritize some things and allow unprioritized things to be buried (ask Yelp).
To be fair, the Fed is kind of that.
It's a cabal of bankers who decided that the USA would be better of if they did the central banking.
In practice, it's not too-too far off how other central banks works, but technically it is a private entity, owned by the banks.
FB's new coin doesn't really have any real use other than basically dropping all of the ugly limitations of the regular financial system.
Though there are a lot of regulations there 'for our safety' - in reality, the flow of consumer money is just a huge pile of tangled cobwebs of stupidity.
This is will be a really great opportunity to do '21st century currency'. If it works, there's going to be a whole new way of doing money. The banks, in a way, should be afraid.
That said, there are huge privacy concerns as well which might very well kill the ostensible improvements to be had just by doing things in a new, clean, way.
That sounds amazingly dystopian. I mean, that’s literally a money built on an oligarchy. By design.
I understand people trust these services ( to the extent they keep using them), but the playing field should be flatter in crypto. Unlike the article’s suggestions that Ripple is toast, I can imagine it’s putting such coins in a position to be very competitive, more open, and not run by the companies above.