News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by jchw on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:24AM (#20203874)
Anyone who wants to defend themselves, consider using U2F where you can and Google Advanced Protection. I just recently picked up a bluetooth security key because one is needed to log an iPhone into an account using advanced protection; there is no SMS backup loophole. The Titan key bundle comes with a bluetooth and USB key, which is enough to get started, though frankly you probably want a couple additional backup keys too.

https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/

(The usual disclosure: I work for Google, but not on anything related to this, only speaking as a user.)

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by lstamour on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:38AM (#20204030)
U2F keys are great but I look forward to the day when they’re more widely available outside the US. And I’m still waiting for my replacement from Feitian for the recent vulnerability. Not to say you shouldn’t use them, but... they have their limits. Particularly Advanced Protection which forces you to use Google’s browser in many situations and disables API access so I can’t use the API to get my own data, only Google’s official apps and a small exception for Apple’s.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by jchw on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:48AM (#20204162)
Yeah, Chromium is needed to add keys, which effectively means you can’t enable Advanced Protection without Chromium. I personally ran into this wall. I acknowledge that this sucks, as a person that intentionally only uses Firefox, but to be clear logging in and most other operations work absolutely fine with Advanced Protection.

Does it really disable all API access? I thought it only blocked certain OAuth scopes, but to be honest I haven’t really tried.

I was able to login to a NVIDIA Shield, but only by resetting and bootstrapping off a spare Android device (!!!) because U2F keys are broken on Shield. Interestingly, my Samsung TV remains signed into Youtube, which is kind of odd now that I think about it.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by archi42 on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:22PM (#20204532)
Seems like Firefox U2F is just disabled by default: https://www.yubico.com/2017/11/how-to-navigate-fido-u2f-in-f... (tl;dr: Open about:config, search for u2f, enable)

With that done, GitHub prompts me for my key. My Linux office workstation is missing the necessary udev rule, so I couldn't test more. (Funnily, pressing Cancel caused them to send me a SMS, so their 2FA is practically worthless).

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by OrwellianChild on Monday June 17, 2019 @03:51PM (#20206652)
I've run into strange interactions where adding a key is disabled in Firefox (even with the security.webauth.u2f flag set to true), but once one key is added, you can add subsequent keys no problem.

This is how Github worked for me - I think it's just a mis-match in the code checking for U2F functionality...

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by archi42 on Friday June 21, 2019 @10:18AM (#20242686)
I think adding the key use a different mechanism - there are two JS interfaces for U2F, and FF only supports one of them. TBH I've added my key to GitHub with chromium, but have since moved to FF; so that might be what you're seeing with GitHub.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by jchw on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:45PM (#20204794)
Oh yeah, I’ve set all that stuff up already and I am able to login; NixOS makes it mostly pretty easy.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by mrkstu on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:10PM (#20204424)
Youtube/YoutubeTV seem to be walled off on 2nd factor auth. I've been able to log into both on browsers w/o 2nd factor and then get prompted when logging into web gmail.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by mikelward on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:03PM (#20204345)
Or use your Android phone as your second factor.

https://security.googleblog.com/2019/06/use-your-android-pho...

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by jchw on Monday June 17, 2019 @05:33PM (#20207599)
That’s a great idea and would’ve saved me some time. Sadly, I had ordered and received my Titan kit before even realizing I still had an Android device, less that I could use it to bootstrap my iOS device...

I hope Apple some day supports NFC or maybe even USB U2F, both things Android has supported on phones for a bit.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by flarex on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:37AM (#20204013)
Why doesn't Google get rid of SMS recovery completely? It's a huge security flaw that can be easily exploited.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by ghaff on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:43AM (#20204090)
Probably because the more barriers you put in the way of scams, social engineering, etc. the harder you make it for people to legitimately get back into their accounts and the more likely it is that you'll instead read stories about how someone "forgot their credentials and lost access to everything in their account and Google won't do anything about it."

No opinion on SMS specifically but there are tradeoffs.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by flarex on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:54AM (#20204227)
It would be more just if people losing access to their accounts were those that lost their credentials rather than anyone that has a SMS number tied to their account. Other approaches to account recovery could be explored but none of them should involve SMS.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by pergadad on Monday June 17, 2019 @02:41PM (#20206075)
Google is a pain as there's no way to talk to a human. I have lost access to an old Gmail account as my phone broke. Without authenticator I can't get in. I can't set up authenticator anew because I don't have the password anymore. I still have same phone and plenty of emails - just no way to get in.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by WillPostForFood on Monday June 17, 2019 @04:40PM (#20207126)
When you set up 2fa with Google they give you a set of backup codes you can use to get back in case you lose access to your phone/authenticator. It's important to store those somewhere safe.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by jchw on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:42AM (#20204080)
I have no idea what the pros and cons are and certainly can’t speak for why. However, I think the existence of the Advanced Protection Program is definitely acknowledgment that the SMS backup is not secure enough for everyone.

The thing is, not long ago I had no issue recovering my account if it got compromised. I think attackers today have gotten better at finding ways to beat the system. One thing I’ve seen, albeit I don’t know if it works on Google accounts, is enabling high security after stealing an account, effectively making recovery very hard.

Though, I can’t really speculate on if that’s what’s going on here.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by throw0101a on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:24PM (#20205246)
Because, depending on your risk profile, it can be very helpful:

> We found that an SMS code sent to a recovery phone number helped block 100% of automated bots, 96% of bulk phishing attacks, and 76% of targeted attacks.

* https://security.googleblog.com/2019/05/new-research-how-eff...

Not everyone has to worry about being targeted by nation states.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by zxcvbn4038 on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:22PM (#20205230)
When you first enable 2FA with Google you have to do SMS (at least that was the requirement last time I did it). However, once you've defined an alternative 2FA method (Google auth, u2f key, etc) then you can remove the SMS method completely.

Believe it or not banks are really bad at security. They are so bad at it that they don't even realize how bad at it they are. But the banks all copy from each other so "what the other guy is doing" is more or less their justification for what they do. Most of them have little to no idea why they do what they do for IT security, they just do what the Computer Security for Dummies book says to do (walk through the IT security department at any big bank and I bet you there is a dog eared copy of that tome on every desk)

Synchrony is one of the worst offenders, they won't even let you change your password without doing SMS verification, and their source of phone numbers is a Transunion skip trace database (which you can't change or remove any information from), so getting past Synchrony can be as easy as filling out a contest form at a mall, waiting for the phone number to appear with Transunion, then choosing that phone number to do SMS verification. It might take a couple months but payoff can be huge.

My hero at the moment is Capital One, they allow you to do e-mail authentication instead of SMS, and their iOS app also doubles as an additional factor (one requiring you to enter your password or use touch ID to use).

I was also extremely happy to find that the brokerage Robinhood offers Google Auth as a second factor. E*Trade also offers 2FA but a proprietary token w/ lcd display (which they happily charge you for).

My trick has been to give banks a false phone number that rings busy forever. That does effectively keep me from using banks that require SMS authentication, but there are more then enough that either offer other methods or drop their SMS requirement if you list your mobile number as your home number (indicating that its a wired phone and can't receive SMS). That doesn't keep my Synchrony accounts secure but there are enough protections around credit cards that my liability would be $50 at worst, with Synchrony having to eat the remainder of the loss.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by yellowapple on Monday June 17, 2019 @02:52PM (#20206175)
> When you first enable 2FA with Google you have to do SMS (at least that was the requirement last time I did it)

I don't remember that ever being the case, either when Google first launched Google Authenticator and 2FA (when I pretty soon after set it up) or when I later went through the setup process for my work account at my current job (a couple years ago).

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by zxcvbn4038 on Monday June 17, 2019 @05:36PM (#20207620)
That is awesome then! It was a lot of hassle for me to find a phone that accepts incoming calls (and wouldn't come back to me) so I could get past the first step - though to Google's credit the number I used never showed up anywhere so they didn't try to sell me out.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by friedegg on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:48AM (#20204164)
It depends on your threat level. If you're just trying to avoid phishing, it's great, something like 99.9% effective. However, if you're worried you'll be targeted, where someone will go through the effort to do this to you specifically, then it's not a good choice.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by flarex on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:59AM (#20204291)
2FA does not fully protect you against phishing. The attacker can just passthrough all credentials including your 2FA code. It limits the attack to a time window and any further security sensitive changes that require 2FA may be protected unless the user naively re-enters their code.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by tialaramex on Monday June 17, 2019 @03:21PM (#20206413)
U2F/ WebAuthn credentials can't be passed through.

Or in more detail, the credentials aren't human readable and are per-FQDN, so when you visit badguy.example thinking it's goodguy.example, your Security Key will cheerfully hand over valid credentials for badguy.example, but there is no way to give them credentials for goodguy.example because that's not where you are.

Hence that 100% score on Google's page.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by flarex on Monday June 17, 2019 @05:18PM (#20207488)
Meant to say TOTP or SMS 2FA.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by wooptoo on Monday June 17, 2019 @06:33PM (#20208005)
I've just checked and Google now allows the removal of SMS based 2FA if you have an alternative 2FA method configured.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by daphneokeefe on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:05PM (#20205032)
What is your contingency plan for when that physical key is lost, stolen or damaged?
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by vel0city on Monday June 17, 2019 @02:27PM (#20205960)
Multiple physical keys in multiple formats stored in multiple places. I've got a few security keys: one on a keyring, one in a locked file cabinet, one locked in a safe. Backup codes are printed on good quality acid-free paper with good toner and then are put in acid-free envelopes or laminated, stored in a safe at home and a trusted family member's house.

I'm far more concerned with an attacker from the internet or destruction from a fire or natural disaster than someone using my computer at my home who happens to have my username/password combination as well.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by bradstewart on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:41PM (#20205427)
I have two. One stays with me, the other in a safe.

Which is legitimately a pain in the ass to register, manage, keep in sync, etc but I only use it for a few very important accounts--Google being one of them.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by ijpoijpoihpiuoh on Monday June 17, 2019 @02:15PM (#20205850)
You should have emergency backup keys as well printed on real paper. I have a set stored with our important files, and another in my nightstand. Having my phone stolen would be a damnable inconvenience, since that is my second factor -- although not via SIM, but via Google's in-app authentication. But it wouldn't be fatal.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by yellowapple on Monday June 17, 2019 @02:47PM (#20206126)
I use andOTP, which is compatible with Google Authenticator and actually allows backing up the private keys (one of the key missing features of Google Authenticator, though maybe they've fixed that).
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by retromario on Monday June 17, 2019 @04:53PM (#20207256)
A good equivalent to andOTP on iOS is OTP Auth (backups, optional cloud syncs, it just works): https://apps.apple.com/us/app/otp-auth/id659877384
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by sneak on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:48PM (#20205537)
I have about six, one in each computer I regularly use.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by throw0101a on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:37PM (#20205391)
Have multiple keys/tokens?
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by Tepix on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:40AM (#20204051)
Why not "defend" yourself by not relying on gmail? It's not exactly the first time this has happened.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by nixgeek on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:41AM (#20204071)
What’s better? Serious question. Very few companies spend as much on security as Google. You have to do your part and configure something like Advanced Protection, but if someone’s going to go to all the effort listed in the article, which provider would be a better bet?
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by Tepix on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @02:56AM (#20210318)
It's not like email providers get hacked all the time. Individual email accounts do get hacked.

Find an email provider that provides decent support, i.e. you can call and talk to a real person. Make sure they support 2FA (ideally the non SIM variant). Also recovery tokens that you can write down and stuff like that.

Personally I run my own mail server but I understand that's not everybody's cup of tea.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by andybak on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:07PM (#20204387)
Is there anything specific to Google about this? Could it be the same story about another email provider?

And if not then why not? Is it because Google is a bigger and more obvious target or something specific they are doing badly?

If you think people should switch then these are the kind of questions you should answer.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by roywiggins on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:44PM (#20204782)
A smaller, paid provider may make it easier to get someone on the phone to resolve problems when things go wrong. Having better support than Google would not take much.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by creato on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:56PM (#20204937)
"Getting someone on the phone" is a big reason these kinds of problems happen in the first place. The reason Google doesn't do that is because they would be too big of a social engineering target, and couldn't possibly be secure in the face of that at a reasonable cost.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by roywiggins on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:58PM (#20204946)
Fair enough. Is there any email provider that has similar procedures to NFSN?

https://faq.nearlyfreespeech.net/q/LostEverything

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by mikelward on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:08PM (#20204400)
The article doesn't say if the user had two-factor authentication set up. I guess it's implied they used SMS as the second factor.

This would happen with any email provider.

So the fix isn't changing email provider, it's using a more secure second factor, e.g. U2F.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by yellowapple on Monday June 17, 2019 @02:55PM (#20206200)
Right, but at least with a different email provider it's infinitely more likely to get actual support if this happens.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by UncleMeat on Monday June 17, 2019 @03:46PM (#20206616)
"I don't remember my password and I have a new phone, can you help me" is precisely how attackers do sim swaps in the first place.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by jchw on Monday June 17, 2019 @11:54AM (#20204228)
Absolutely, if you want. I am not advocating to use or not use Gmail or other services. But also be sure to use U2F on whatever you can, be it Fastmail or Proton Mail or what have you. I think Proton Mail is still working on their U2F support today, though.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by calvinmorrison on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:17PM (#20205170)
FastMail has humans respond to all support tickets. Imagine being able to recover your email without spending 5 days talking to a google form?

source: I work at fastmail. It's cool.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by jchw on Monday June 17, 2019 @05:46PM (#20207703)
At the end of the day, there’s a lot of differences between the many webmail offerings. The apps, the support, the feature-sets, etc. If you have gotten used to things like the nuances of Gmail filters, switching anywhere can be challenging, I think, and the same could be said about the reverse. I’ve been considering using both Gmail and FastMail simultaneously for a while, especially for custom domains. Also, JMAP is cool.

I am mostly just suggesting that folks who read stories like these and fear similar predicaments take the time, effort, expense, etc. to properly secure whatever accounts they have.

Thought experiment: if someone steals an account with no 2FA, enables U2F and other security mechanisms, how will support verify who truly owns the account? Or the reverse: user enables U2F and someone calls in and tries to claim the account was stolen?

Having humans make judgements is important because the real world is complicated and people are imperfect, but using U2F in the first place can save you a huge headache, no matter what services you use. If support can just flip a bit and disable U2F, it isn’t very useful for the same reasons accounts get hijacked to begin with.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by calvinmorrison on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @10:17AM (#20213226)
I mean, i think you answered the question yourself. History of account security details, things like login logs, IP addresses, when things were changed, payment information, etc can corroborate the story a user is trying to tell (ie, my account got stolen), or refute it.

And those things? It comes down to having strong process rules and having intelligent life forms make the decision.

Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by ufmace on Tuesday June 18, 2019 @08:51AM (#20212403)
This is the first thing I thought of when reading that. For sure, Google's lack of real support for fixing things when someone does steal enough 2FA creds, like phone number, is a drag. On the other hand, it appears that setting up Advanced Protection probably gives you a much harder to hack account than any other provider could do.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by danielpal on Monday June 17, 2019 @12:52PM (#20204887)
This unfortunately is useless. Account recovery will still allow the hacker to use the phone number that has just been swaped to logon to the email. The weakest link is what matters and in this case you are just putting a bigger door lock on the front door while leaving your back door open.
Re:SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Goog... by rst on Monday June 17, 2019 @01:08PM (#20205060)
Once you've configured a security key on a Google account, it's entirely possible to remove phone-number based account recovery -- and strongly recommended for at-risk users. See step 21 et seq. in the Tech Solidarity security guide for people working on political campaigns:

https://techsolidarity.org/resources/security_key_gmail.htm

For no particular reason, Google does require you to temporarily configure phone-number based recovery while configuring other 2FA options -- but once they're set up, you don't need the phone number anymore.