News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by tomxor on Sunday June 16, 2019 @10:05AM (#20195489)
Yes, I find it difficult to imagine developers that are enthusiastic about "metal", I mean who wants another platform specific API for graphics cards. If Apple really think we need something other than "vulkan" then they should push to make "metal" a competing open standard- But I doubt they think that, and It's quite easy to imagine ulterior motives, M$ had exactly the same motives.
Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by flohofwoe on Sunday June 16, 2019 @02:41PM (#20197148)
I'm quite enthusiastic about Metal, and I'm not even much of an Apple fan. Compared to Vulkan or even OpenGL, Metal's API design is much more elegant and developer-friendly. It can be used just fine without a "sanity layer", which can't be said about Vulkan.
Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by pjmlp on Sunday June 16, 2019 @10:41AM (#20195674)
All of us that rather use productive SDKs, with higher level languages, instead of a C API that only knows about drawing pixels.

The same devs that rather use DirectX, libGCM, libGNM, GX, GX2, NVN.

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by tomxor on Sunday June 16, 2019 @10:44AM (#20195692)
I am talking about principles of openness vs lockin, I am not personally interested in technical merits until I can depend on it existing beyond Apple's back garden.

My point was I am surprised others do not care about this aspect, you are obviously one example - So my question to you (as someone who values it technically) is: does this not bother you?

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by pjmlp on Sunday June 16, 2019 @10:52AM (#20195742)
APIs win on technical merits and market tooling, not on feels good kind of thing.

Not at all, as someone that learned to program graphics when demoscene was all the rage, it is all about taking advantage of the hardware.

Professional game studios are more than used to have a thin layer to abstract each 3D API, which is a very small codebase from any game engine/middleware.

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by tomxor on Sunday June 16, 2019 @11:05AM (#20195807)
> APIs win on technical merits and market tooling, not on feels good kind of thing.

Ok, but the technical merits for metal stop at Apple, you can abstract away differences in your translation layer if you care about your game existing outside, but you have to leave any merits of metal behind. Doesn't this dull your enthusiasm over improvements and features specific to metal?

I get that the original demoscene you were using unique hardware, and unportable demos that squeezed everything they could out of that specific piece of hardware felt natural, but Apple computers use the same GPUs everyone else is using... doesn't that make a proprietary low level graphics API seem more artificial.

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by pjmlp on Sunday June 16, 2019 @11:23AM (#20195903)
Not every developer feels like they have to support every computer in existence.

Many game studios are quite happy being Apple experts, just like many other game studios release exclusives or sell themselves as experts on a given platform, including selling consulting services.

For those, vendor tooling is very much appreciated.

The ones that care for portable code, they also care about having the easiest way to start coding on each platform.

If Khronos cares about adoption, they should improve LunarG SDK to be more than just a set of bare bones libraries.

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by tomxor on Sunday June 16, 2019 @12:07PM (#20196157)
So in short, to answer my own question: a developer can have enthusiasm for metal if metal covers all of their target platform (Apple).
Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by frou_dh on Sunday June 16, 2019 @11:21AM (#20195891)
Their most important platform uses in-house GPUs these days.
Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by frou_dh on Sunday June 16, 2019 @10:36AM (#20195647)
> If Apple really think we need something other than "vulkan" then they should push to make "metal" a competing open standard

Metal predates Vulkan by years. They were already using Metal in shipping products before Vulkan existed.

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by tomxor on Sunday June 16, 2019 @11:22AM (#20195894)
Why does that mean they shouldn't make it an open standard?
Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by derefr on Sunday June 16, 2019 @03:32PM (#20197418)
"Metal" is a vertically-integrated software stack that goes up into Objective-C runtime land. An open standard based upon it would require that there be an open-standard Objective-C runtime and toolchain to use in working with it.

Unlike Vulkan, the lowest-level, C-ABI, non-type-safe parts of Metal aren't exposed as public APIs, AFAIK. You could maybe standardize those, but Apple presumably wants to reserve the right to change them while just keeping the higher-level ObjC ABI stable.

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by astrange on Sunday June 16, 2019 @07:42PM (#20198645)
> Unlike Vulkan, the lowest-level, C-ABI, non-type-safe parts of Metal aren't exposed as public APIs, AFAIK.

They don't even really exist. Most Metal APIs are defined as protocols (id<MTL...>) for a reason; if you look at the objects you get back, they're directly implemented by the GPU driver.

Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by frou_dh on Sunday June 16, 2019 @11:32AM (#20195951)
cos randomers don't get to dictate the scope of the project after-the-fact
Re:Ray Tracing with Metal [video] by tomxor on Sunday June 16, 2019 @12:01PM (#20196122)
If "randomers" are developers who are repelled by the proprietary nature of their graphics API "randomers" may well dictate the scope of the project.