Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by koolba on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:09PM
(#20190917)
> It happened when Bouraoui went to a busy restaurant one evening with a group of family and friends. As they waited outside for a table, a white waiter approached Bouraoui and asked for her name along with the number of people in her party.
> "Yasmina, party of six," she said.
> "I need something easier to pronounce," he said.
> She repeated her name but he didn't want to try to pronounce it. And then she was no longer there.
> "He looks at a 12-year-old in our party and he says, 'What's your name?' '' says Bouraoui, a manager with the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. "Now he's just ignoring me."
That’s some terrible customer service. I’ve heard many people give aliases or single syllable westernized names by choice to simplify things, but having the employee you’re dealing with insist on it is particularly insulting.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by jjeaff on Saturday June 15, 2019 @04:10PM
(#20191845)
Doesn't sound realistic? And is this coming from a position of experience? Where you have had to deal with prejudice and everything else that comes with being singled out as a minority?
Or is this coming from a upper middle class white male that has always lived amongst people who look and sound like they do?
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by jjeaff on Saturday June 15, 2019 @09:24PM
(#20193251)
There were no assumptions. Only questions. But I will make the assumption now that you probably are of the majority class and have little experience how "realistic" an act of prejudice is.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by jumasheff on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:07PM
(#20190903)
`but by law in the US she is considered white -- and she looks white as well` -- as a non-American I have a hard time understanding why the law in the US should distinguish your race?
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by krapp on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:26PM
(#20191025)
>as a non-american I have a hard understanding why law in US should distinquish your race?
>May be I am missing something?
You're missing the fact that the US was founded on the principle of racial hierarchy which led to centuries of oppression and stratification of class along racial lines. Numerous laws were passed in the US which explicitly granted or denied rights by race, the most obvious being slavery, through which people of African descent were legally classified as property in slaveholding states, and "separate but equal" laws post Reconstruction.
As a result of this history of racial discrimination, American culture and law are inextricably linked to racial segregation and classification, as must be any attempts to correct the injustices of the past.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by defertoreptar on Saturday June 15, 2019 @04:09PM
(#20191840)
And I think you're missing the fact that you're not actually breaking any laws by telling people you're one race or another. Saying, "by law in the US she is considered white" implies there is some legal repercussion, which was likely cause for jumasheff's confusion. I could only imagine that happening if there was some sort of fraud involved.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by orkon on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:14PM
(#20190951)
I also found the following sentence strange:
> That belief is partly why many Irish, Italian and Polish immigrants who came to America in the early 20th century whitened their children's names to avoid persecution and increase their chances of social mobility.
> Tim Machuga is a software engineer who also knows what it's like to be black for a minute. He is a white man with an African name.
A typical Eastern European last name to me.
I wonder what does my first name (Oleksii) sound like to folks in the US?
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by jofer on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:46PM
(#20191127)
As far as immigrants "whitening" their names in the early 20th century, it's pretty common, for whatever it's worth... My wife's last name is Gage, but her grandfather changed it from Gadzeki after he lost a local city council race for what he felt was his "damned Polish last name" (his words). This was in Detroit, and he worked for Ford, which at the time, had a fairly strong culture of "Americanizing" recent immigrants. There was a massive wave of anti immigrant sentiment in the 20's and 30's targeted at Irish, Italian, and Eastern European immigrants, and it lingered for many decades afterwards.
Also, the first name bias is quite real. I dated a lady for most of my late teens - mid 20's named Ticia (pronounced Teecha, rather than Tisha). She's Ojibwe Chippewa, but this was rural TN and SC, so race is treated as a very binary black/white checkbox, and she falls into the "white" category. However, Ticia is a "black" name, for the most part. I lost count of the number of times I saw blatantly rude reactions when she introduced herself.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by bluedino on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:21PM
(#20190994)
People turned a lot of Z's into S's and things like that.
That's a big reason why there are so many similar spelled surnames. They'd write it down 'wrong' at Ellis Island, and that's what you were stuck with. Oleksii, Oleksy, etc.
I agree with you that Machuga doesn't sound black at all. Maybe Hispanic if you're pronouncing it 'Mah-choo-gah'
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by somebehemoth on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:22PM
(#20191004)
As an American with an Italian last name I've experienced some of this personally. It is ridiculous. Oleksii is a cool name and I imagine how it is perceived here depends a lot on how you pronounce it when introducing yourself. My family has always pronounced our last name with an emphasis on phonics to make the name sounds "less weird" or easier to pronounce for Americans.
Interesting that this submission got flagged. I wonder why?
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by CommieBobDole on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:31PM
(#20191053)
That one struck me as strange as well - "Machuga" doesn't sound like a stereotypically African name at all. And an image search for it brings up a sea of pasty white faces. Maybe Tim met somebody from an area of Africa where it's a common name and he mentioned it or something.
I feel like the reporter asked around the office for people who'd had these experiences, and Tim mentioned his, so he put him in the article.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by vinay427 on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:17PM
(#20190969)
Census, university admissions (which is controversial and repeatedly in a legal grey area), and maybe a few other things I'm missing. It's always optional to choose one, obviously.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by MrMorden on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:17PM
(#20190973)
It would be difficult to measure racial discrimination without the law defining race. And since the US federal and state governments stacked the deck against non-whites for more than a century, we can't just declare that we're color-blind and assume racial discrimination is now over.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by badrabbit on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:42PM
(#20191107)
Then let me ask you this,if a person has ancestors that were never victims of the "stacked deck" such as immigrants and they happen to be of a race as defined by the government which had been victimized,should they benefit from these reparations?
How about european immigrants that just arrived in the US within the last decade,should native minorities have better opportunities than them?
And what exactly is race? Ancestry? National origin? Consider this list: north african arab,turk,spanish, white skinned mexican,brown skinned egyptian,light skinned indian,albanian and south african with european ancestry. Lets say these people and their families immigrated to the US in the late 80's and had children immediately,their children will be treated very differently from each other. Which race are they? The south african is white but the mexican is not so white?
The law has no business defining race or using this social construct for systemic inequalities. This breeds so much strife,resentment and division and is not sustainable.
When you benefit one group, if you in the process benefit and harm other groups unfairly you're only shuffling around inequality. I believe the end result is even more unfairness and injustice to even more groups of people.
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by procrastitron on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:22PM
(#20191001)
It’s just a terrible article.
It’s incoherent at times (that was the most egregious example) and seems to reflect the author’s bizarre misconceptions about the world (e.g. claiming “Jace” is a non traditional name).
Re:What it's like to be a white woman named LaKiesha
by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:22PM
(#20191000)
This is a very interesting article that offers a unique insight into the experiences of people with non-traditional names, that the majority of users on HN will not be familiar with.
It absolutely aligns with HN's goal of promoting intellectual curiosity. Furthermore the comments so far have been civil and uncontroversial.
With this in mind, could the person(s) who flagged it please unflag it?
> "Yasmina, party of six," she said.
> "I need something easier to pronounce," he said.
> She repeated her name but he didn't want to try to pronounce it. And then she was no longer there.
> "He looks at a 12-year-old in our party and he says, 'What's your name?' '' says Bouraoui, a manager with the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. "Now he's just ignoring me."
That’s some terrible customer service. I’ve heard many people give aliases or single syllable westernized names by choice to simplify things, but having the employee you’re dealing with insist on it is particularly insulting.
If true, yes.
Or is this coming from a upper middle class white male that has always lived amongst people who look and sound like they do?
If anything, it's less likely for whites - most Western countries have above-average diversity.
So most people should probably not cast dispersions about the validity of the claims made by the marginalized.
Maybe I am missing something?
>White – A person having origins in any of the original peoples of Europe, the Middle East, or North Africa.
You're missing the fact that the US was founded on the principle of racial hierarchy which led to centuries of oppression and stratification of class along racial lines. Numerous laws were passed in the US which explicitly granted or denied rights by race, the most obvious being slavery, through which people of African descent were legally classified as property in slaveholding states, and "separate but equal" laws post Reconstruction.
As a result of this history of racial discrimination, American culture and law are inextricably linked to racial segregation and classification, as must be any attempts to correct the injustices of the past.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_aspects_of_race_in_th...
[1]https://www.census.gov/acs/www/about/why-we-ask-each-questio...
[2]https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/why-census-is-right-to-as...
> That belief is partly why many Irish, Italian and Polish immigrants who came to America in the early 20th century whitened their children's names to avoid persecution and increase their chances of social mobility.
> Tim Machuga is a software engineer who also knows what it's like to be black for a minute. He is a white man with an African name.
A typical Eastern European last name to me.
I wonder what does my first name (Oleksii) sound like to folks in the US?
Also, the first name bias is quite real. I dated a lady for most of my late teens - mid 20's named Ticia (pronounced Teecha, rather than Tisha). She's Ojibwe Chippewa, but this was rural TN and SC, so race is treated as a very binary black/white checkbox, and she falls into the "white" category. However, Ticia is a "black" name, for the most part. I lost count of the number of times I saw blatantly rude reactions when she introduced herself.
That's a big reason why there are so many similar spelled surnames. They'd write it down 'wrong' at Ellis Island, and that's what you were stuck with. Oleksii, Oleksy, etc.
I agree with you that Machuga doesn't sound black at all. Maybe Hispanic if you're pronouncing it 'Mah-choo-gah'
Interesting that this submission got flagged. I wonder why?
I feel like the reporter asked around the office for people who'd had these experiences, and Tim mentioned his, so he put him in the article.
How about european immigrants that just arrived in the US within the last decade,should native minorities have better opportunities than them?
And what exactly is race? Ancestry? National origin? Consider this list: north african arab,turk,spanish, white skinned mexican,brown skinned egyptian,light skinned indian,albanian and south african with european ancestry. Lets say these people and their families immigrated to the US in the late 80's and had children immediately,their children will be treated very differently from each other. Which race are they? The south african is white but the mexican is not so white?
The law has no business defining race or using this social construct for systemic inequalities. This breeds so much strife,resentment and division and is not sustainable.
When you benefit one group, if you in the process benefit and harm other groups unfairly you're only shuffling around inequality. I believe the end result is even more unfairness and injustice to even more groups of people.
It’s incoherent at times (that was the most egregious example) and seems to reflect the author’s bizarre misconceptions about the world (e.g. claiming “Jace” is a non traditional name).
Nobody wants to make a call and change anything that is wrong...let alone questions of what happens to progress reports of someone was X and now Y....
It absolutely aligns with HN's goal of promoting intellectual curiosity. Furthermore the comments so far have been civil and uncontroversial.
With this in mind, could the person(s) who flagged it please unflag it?
He's not once mentioned any discrimination he has experienced because of his name.
I'm not saying there's no prejudice here but I think it is less extreme.
It's about a German guy whos hippie parents named Ranjid and now he has some of the problems usually only immigrants have.