News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by noir_lord on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:03AM (#20190312)
I read quickly and have the same retention rate (or better) than most people I've interacted with.

I don't do any of the tricky stuff that 'speed readers' do.

The only thing I'm aware is different is I don't hear the words in my head when I read as I'm often 'reading' a chunk of 3-4 words at once.

I thought this was completely normal til I spoke to an ex about it when she commented I demolished books.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by saberience on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:33AM (#20190439)
I often hear people boasting about their "speed reading" skills and then I ask them what sort of books they read, turns out speed reading and having "good retention rate" is easy if you're reading crap. I could also speed read Clive Cussler, Stephen King, and JK Rowling.

I love Philosophy and classic literature and I've yet to meet anyone that's managed to speed read Proust's "In Search of Lost Time", and then tell give me a detailed description of the plot, themes, artistic merit, and so on. Similarly with books like Ulysses. There's no possible way to speed read that book because it's so rich with allusions, references to religion, art, mythology, and philosophy. If you tried to "speed read" it, you would be missing half the point of reading it in the first place.

Reading great books isn't about numbers, you don't get rewarded for how many classics you read in a year. Reading great books is about slowly absorbing all the riches inside, something that just cannot happen if you're rushing. I've read The Brothers Karamazov and The Magic Mountain 4 or 5 times and each time I learn something new and gain a deeper understanding of psychology and life. I find it more rewarding to read and re-read the classics slowly, writing notes, using a critical guide (or book of companion essays), than smashing through as many crappy novels or modern popular non-fiction books (The Power of Now of any of Malcom Gladwells books are typical fodder for todays readers).

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by qwsxyh on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:05PM (#20190600)
This is legitimately the most pretentious HN comment I've ever read, and that's a very high bar.

I too dismiss things that people enjoy as "crap" because I have such a gigantic brain from reading philosophy and looking down everyone else, and belittle them for believing that they read and understand fast in the wrong type of book.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by saberience on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:15PM (#20190637)
I actually read and enjoy Stephen King and JK Rowling, but I don't tell myself it's fine art and I'm super "smart" for speed reading it. I don't try and speed read anything because I don't think it's useful or meaningful.

I'm trying to rally against the crowd you always find in any thread on speed-reading who love to talk about how great they are for reading 10 books a day and gaining nothing from it.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by techer on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:30PM (#20190723)
One can legitimately spend 20 minutes reading a single page...sometimes it depends on the thought, craft and skill of the author but relies on the reader to actually give a damn - enjoying reading for the sake of reading...

One authors view - https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/jul/07/howard-jacobso...

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by coldtea on Saturday June 15, 2019 @02:36PM (#20191390)
>This is legitimately the most pretentious HN comment I've ever read, and that's a very high bar.

Or just one that tells it like it is.

Not everything is of the same level (e.g. Bach and Nicky Minaj or Coltrane and Vanilla Ice), and not everything is equally "subjective". The same that goes for music, goes for literature, cinema, and so on.

Sure, USA was founded on a populist ideology, where no individual's tastes and cultural development is lesser than another's. Well, not all cultures agree with that.

>I too dismiss things that people enjoy as "crap" because I have such a gigantic brain from reading philosophy and looking down everyone else, and belittle them for believing that they read and understand fast in the wrong type of book.

Well, at some point someone has to belittle if not the people, surely the wrong type of book -- in other words, put it in perspective, not everything is a diamond -- else there's no art and no culture, just an indistinguishable blob of different works.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by nilkn on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:05PM (#20190893)
The post could have been written with a different tone, but I think it makes a good point that can't be purely dismissed as simple snobbery or belittling.

I think the reason some folks get defensive on this topic is that it's somewhat common for someone to claim to be an incredibly fast reader, but on closer inspection it is (almost always) revealed that they are reading very straightforward and simple fiction that is about as close to being designed for speed reading as possible. This makes the claim of speed reading feel disingenuous. There can be truly dramatic differences between novels in terms of the complexity of the language used and the nuance of characters and events. I don't think one should expect a particularly celebratory response if one is making other folks feel like slow readers when they actually have been reading far more complicated material.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by watwut on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:04PM (#20190887)
I like King and can confirm that I can read it much faster then books he mentions.

Some books are quick to read, others slow. Ulysses was intentionally written to be difficult and Stephen King put great effort in making his books easy to read.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by buttcoinslol on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:38PM (#20190765)
It's not really up for debate that it takes more concentration and time to read Ulysses or Hegel than it does to read the Dark Tower or Harry Potter series.

Edit: And I like all of the above books/authors

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by bdavis__ on Saturday June 15, 2019 @10:01PM (#20193386)
Ever read a Tom Clancy book? Absolute crap. In about 3 dimensions. But, entertaining. Have read them all. Quickly.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by pessimizer on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:48PM (#20190801)
Being difficult to read definitely isn't a mark of quality, but all books aren't written at the same difficulty (vocabulary, ideas, information density) level, even if the idea that some things are harder than others strikes you as elitist.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by nickthemagicman on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:44AM (#20190501)
I completely agree. I can read incredibly fast however I've attenuated my reading speed over time to appreciate richness of text and think deeply about the ideas that are being communicated. At some point the actual technical part of reading becomes trivial and the ideas become what's important.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by cecilpl2 on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:07PM (#20190607)
Speed reading seems have become a point of pride for many people. I think they see it as a proxy for intelligence rather than a learned ability that is very useful in some (not all) contexts.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by Buldak on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:29PM (#20190721)
I have a similar attitude toward audio books. When someone claims that listening to an audio book is largely the same as reading it, it strikes me that this could only be true of books which aren't especially demanding in terms of comprehension. The idea of listening to audio book of Hegel or using an audio book in lieu of textbooks to study for school seems crazy to me.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by imjustsaying on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:30AM (#20190429)
I read words aloud in my head. However, I remember reading words as fast as possible almost like an auctioneer when we would break up into reading groups in elementary school. My classmates thought it was hilarious but when the teacher came by, she would tell me not to read so fast.

So I switched the extra processing power to making context-appropriate inflections, dramatizations, and intonations instead of the monotone my classmates were doing, which the teachers seemed to tolerate.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by cecilpl2 on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:57AM (#20190567)
> context-appropriate inflections, dramatizations, and intonations

I do this too, and other people often comment on how well I read out loud.

I often find myself buffering words into vocalization while I read ahead a line or so and prepare the next sentence. I can insert pauses (or intone a clause as an aside) to make it easier for the listener to parse.

What tricks do you have?

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by jacobolus on Sunday June 16, 2019 @09:42AM (#20195393)
I have been reading kids books aloud for maybe 2 hours per day for the past 2 years (to an almost-3 year old), and at this point I can do a pretty decent read-aloud including voices etc. while also considering some unrelated technical problem in my head.

The catch is that if I am thinking about something else simultaneously then what I am reading aloud doesn’t make it into memory; I can read for 20 minutes and then suddenly realize that I have no idea what happened in the story. The reading is on autopilot.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by gowld on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:16PM (#20190642)
You comment seems a bit defensive about your teacher inspiring you to improve your reading performance skills.

Your teacher probably tolerated monotone because your classmates were working hard just to get the words out, and they weren't ready to add inflection.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjtPMiumixA Don't Read Like a Robot - Blazer Fresh | GoNoodle

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by imjustsaying on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:22PM (#20190683)
>You comment seems a bit defensive about your teacher inspiring you to improve your reading performance skills.

It was stated that the only thing she inspired me to do was slow down my expression of reading speed. Reading faster than my peers and entertaining them is not something people get embarrassed about.

Her telling me to slow down was not a magical way to get me to add inflection out of the void. Being scolded for deviating from normal speed only reinforced the standard school mentality that any deviation = bad. It would have only discouraged me from adding inflections without first being instructed to do so.

>(other classmates) weren't ready to add inflection.

I don't recall my classmates even adding inflection by high school or beyond, let alone by the end of the trimester. At least where I'm from, elementary teachers do not try to add inflection in their students. I'd imagine being able to read itself is more than sufficient to send them on to the next class.

Teachers focusing attention on illiterate students probably took precedence over tinkering with subjective inflections in kids who were not only going to pass their K-5 standardized tests but were already reading at a high school level.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by briandear on Saturday June 15, 2019 @01:22PM (#20190999)
> being able to read itself is more than sufficient to send them on to the next class

This is why my kids go to private school and I support school choice: when students are treated like widgets that only have to meet some minimum quality standard, that necessarily results in teachers doing exactly as you describe: tolerating mediocrity because mediocrity is the standard. It’s not the teachers’ fault, it’s the way public schools are designed: to output students at a minimum level of competency. Until parents start demanding something beyond the minimum and voting accordingly, just “passing,” is all that we can expect.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by falcolas on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:27AM (#20190413)
Yeah, based on a very informal survey I’ve seen on some reading-related subreddits, the biggest difference between fast and slow readers was whether they subvocalized or not.

I fall in the “not” category (the average-sized book is a 3-4 hour length for me), but I will occasionally intentionally subvocalize, just to slow myself down a bit.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by dorfsmay on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:35AM (#20190453)
I'm an extremely slow reader. I read probably most books about this subject, but am unable to absorb material if I don't subvocalize.i see words, chunk of words, but they don't connect to each other and I get no meaning.

I've wondered if this is one of those thing that if you have not learned how to do it before a certain age, your brain can no longer learn it, like seeing in stereo etc...

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by noir_lord on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:59AM (#20190576)
It could be, I was really slow to learn to read (and I mean slow, I nearly ended up in remedial classes) until I got exceptionally lucky in having a teacher who realised my issue wasn't capability it was boredom and who was willing to give up her lunch time to introduce me to books that were engaging (I still remember the first 'proper' book I read, 'Goodnight Mister Tom' by Michelle Magorian - The critical point was when I wanted to know what happened next and began (laboriously) reading it at home so I could find out) - at 7 I had the reading ability of a slow 5 year old by 8 I was reading books typically read in school by 16 year olds.

Once I found books and authors I liked I became a voracious reader, from eight to adulthood it wasn't unusual for me to have 3-4 books on the go at once and to read 3-4 books in a week all the classic works of sci-fi, books on science, computers, geography, history, politics, biology I was a sponge, I'd read almost anything - I used to read while walking to and from school, I walked into surprisingly few lamp posts.

The more I read the less I vocalised the words in my head, I started with pointing at each word (as most kids do) and then I stopped doing that, then I started looking at the word shape rather than the word and not vocalising it at all, it wasn't anything conscious just a natural progression.

In a very profound sense that teacher and my mum altered the scope of my life for the next 30 years, the teacher by realising I just needed the time and the right material and my mum for scouring charity shops/2nd hand book shops to keep me fed with books as money was tight (bless her, she used to keep a list in her purse of all the authors I liked, what books they had written and which I'd read).

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by gowld on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:17PM (#20190652)
It's also possible that people who don't subvocalize aren't absorbing as much.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by cnasc on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:34AM (#20190447)
> I fall in the “not” category (the average-sized book is a 3-4 hour length for me), but I will occasionally intentionally subvocalize, just to slow myself down a bit.

This is what I do, though sometimes it's a second pass over a passage that I want to savor or really focus deeply on.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by noir_lord on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:04PM (#20190593)
Similar to re-reading a passage I go back and re-read books I really like 3-4 times (and a few many more than that).

I've read all of the Discworld novels at least 3 times and a few like Hogfather more than a dozen (I re-read it ever Christmas).

Reading is one of lives truly great pleasures and it's one of lifes most democratic.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by dbmueller on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:32AM (#20190436)
Is this categorization (subvocalizers vs others) backed up by research?

Can on learn not to subvocalize?

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by someguy345 on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:07PM (#20190604)
I would consider whether you really want to. I'm someone who seems to have naturally not sub-vocalized for most of my life or at least if I did it was like a robotic voice fast talking in my head, I guess I would actually sound the words in my head but much faster than a person talking and in a way that did not help me develop a feel for inflection, etc. I have always been able to read faster than an average person but the last couple years has opened my eyes to a lot of communication issues I have had, basically my default has been that when I talked to people it would always seem very low energy and without much emotion or inflection and it has had a very negative impact on my social life, among other things. In the last couple years I've started learning a second language, in which I find it much easier to read if I do sub-vocalize at a normal human pace and I've also started pushing myself to record myself talking about various topics in English and to work on my communication skills overall. I've now started sub-vocalizing when I read in English as well and I'm noticing overall improvements in my life like being able to have more expressive and natural conversations with people. I'm sure reading without it has its places when you really need to speed read but I'm not sure a goal of never sub vocalizing is ideal.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by CydeWeys on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:38AM (#20190463)
I suspect so, as almost everyone starts off as an out-loud vocalizer when they're first learning to read.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by gowld on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:18PM (#20190655)
This is a _fantastic_ example of sampling bias. You simply have no idea when small children are reading silently. You assume they aren't reading until they vocalize, and then when they stop vocalizing you change your assumption to assume they are still reading even though you can't hear it.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by pessimizer on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:50PM (#20190816)
I never knew that anyone subvocalized until I ran into theories that subvocalization was required for reading.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by wodenokoto on Saturday June 15, 2019 @05:16PM (#20192200)
> I don't do any of the tricky stuff that 'speed readers' do. The only thing I'm aware is different is I don't hear the words in my head when I read as I'm often 'reading' a chunk of 3-4 words at once.

That IS the tricky stuff speed readers do.

Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by 7952 on Saturday June 15, 2019 @11:15AM (#20190371)
A family member is deaf and does exactly the same thing. He never learned to read aloud so never got into the habit. He reads ridiculously fast.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by paulpauper on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:13PM (#20190627)
I think it's highly correlated with IQ. It happens that people with higher IQs read faster and and have better comprehension as demonstrated, for example, = by verbal score on the SAT.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by le3dh4x0r on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:30PM (#20190722)
IQ is a highly outdated concept and making wild assumptions about correlation unscientific. Reading becomes more effortless with practice.
Re:The average person’s reading speed is slower than commonl... by noir_lord on Saturday June 15, 2019 @12:42PM (#20190780)
In my experience (which isn't data) the correlation is weak at best, I know people I consider much smarter than me who read slower (my boss for example, he has advanced degrees in industrial chemistry and is ridiculously smart)

That and people over-estimate my intelligence because I know about lots of random things, they think I'm smart because of that but they could have done exactly the same thing if they'd chosen to which feeds nicely into nature vs nurture I guess.

I got hooked on books and my mum fed that addiction, that they didn't is the only difference.

It helps that the perception of computer programmers is that we are geeky but do something that is incredibly difficult (when I know the reality is except for certain domains, you really don't need much math beyond arithmetic and the rest is conscientious attention to detail and explaining the problem simply to a really high speed idiot).