News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by Theodores on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @06:03AM (#20093530)
Something is not working with this carbon credit market, the article says demand for electric cars is not there so the auto makers can't generate their own credits. Yet people who are into EV cars view the big three as well as the German marques as not even trying.

I bet that selling the credits was never in the Tesla business plan. But it is now!

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by davedx on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:32AM (#20093934)
"Demand is not there"

"25,913% Growth In Tesla Sales In 6 Years"

I don't know how people reconcile these kinds of statements. Unless they're arguing that Q1 2019 is an inflection point and sales will taper off for the foreseeable future?

https://cleantechnica.com/2018/10/04/25913-growth-in-tesla-s...

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by adolph on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:13AM (#20094199)
The two assertions may not be in conflict. There may not be demand for EVs that are rehashes of ICE designs (and not just in “looks” but also in engineering compromises made to retrofit EV to a body originally intended for an ICE). Also, there may truly not be sufficient demand for EV in the bread and butter market segments traditional “mature” automakers address (and corporate/union socio-political factors might stifle an internally created Tesla, similar to what happened to Saturn in GM).
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by gamblor956 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:47AM (#20095532)
To put things into perspective: Despite 26000% growth... Tesla still has less than 1% of the global auto market.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by imtringued on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:38AM (#20093960)
Isn't that basically what happened? [0]

[0] https://insideevs.com/news/343787/tesla-sales-down-for-q1-20...

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by jsight on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:34AM (#20095387)
If it was, it isn't at all clear from the data. Model S and Model X slowed dramatically, and that part might be indicative of a real problem with those two models. Model 3, OTOH, appears to be growing steadily right now.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by rfeather on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:03AM (#20094539)
No. You cite an article that falsely compares sales and delivery numbers. It's deliveries on already sold cars that slowed.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by zaroth on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:51AM (#20094451)
Regulatory assistance was always a huge part of Tesla’s business plan. Whether it is on the consumer side (rebates) or corporate side (credits).

As for demand, you are missing the big picture of the technology adoption curve. There is a massive learning curve which needs to be climbed in terms of producing EVs and particularly batteries at the scale required. Never mind the charging infrastructure or changing consumer habits. The market is growing as fast as possible and is totally supply constrained and will be likely for the next decade plus.

It’s not that the big 3 aren’t even trying. It’s that they can’t try. If you are buying 3rd-party assembled batteries and motors to put into your EVs you are likely able to produce a meaningless number of units at a near zero or negative margin. They were never going to invest the $20 billion in R&D to canabalize themselves. It always had to be an outsider who would have to make the push.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by gamblor956 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:51AM (#20095570)
Toyota has spent billions on alternative fuels and green tech cars. The Prius is single handedly the reason that a market for Teslas and other EVs exist.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by zaroth on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @05:06PM (#20099225)
> The Prius is single handedly the reason that a market for Teslas and other EVs exist.

Can you elaborate on this please? I would never own or drive a Prius, or really a hybrid of any kind. I do own a Model 3. I see it as polar opposite to a hybrid.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by gamblor956 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:55PM (#20100887)
The Prius showed that there was a large market for green cars. The largest group of Tesla Model 3 buyers is former Prius owners.

Without the Prius to pave the way, Tesla would never exist, because nobody would have invested in an EV company without the Prius proof.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by lazyjones on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:00AM (#20093774)
> Something is not working with this carbon credit market, the article says demand for electric cars is not there so the auto makers can't generate their own credits.

Just low quality articles - most other car makers have long delivery times for EV due to demand, 6 to 18 months in some cases. Their real problem is that they can't or don't want (negative margin?) to produce in quantities.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by sokoloff on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:52AM (#20094455)
Let's see. Long delivery times due to demand that exceeds supply. Margin pressure on the product. I wonder what Microeconomics 101 suggests the path forward for a supplier caught in that trap? It's been a while since I took Econ, but I think the answer is maybe raising prices? Tends to align demand with supply and improve unit economics.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by lazyjones on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:24AM (#20094727)
This would be the correct choice in a simplified scenario without considering the competition, but car makers know how it'd work out: Tesla would sell even more cars and they'd sell none. Why are they doing what they're doing? Possibly because they want to slow down Tesla's growth and virtue-signal a little without losing too much money. I'm not sure it's working very well for Jaguar and Audi at the moment.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by tyfon on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @06:14AM (#20093568)
It sounds like the cost of the credits is not high enough to make a real dent.

Another effective way of doing this is adding the cost of pollution into the price of the car as tax making ICE expensive and electric cheap. That is done here and the demand is very high. ICEs generally have > 100% tax.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by Theodores on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @06:32AM (#20093639)
Where is 'here'? Let me guess, Norway?
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by tyfon on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:11AM (#20102638)
Correct :)
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by Shivetya on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:14AM (#20093839)
warning, I ramble quickly

Because the market isn't there. I know we like to believe otherwise but the majority do not care. They will reply to a survey with what the expect the person asking wants but at the end of the day they have no reason to change their buying habits.

I really enjoy my Tesla 3 but I am a fan of sedans and coupes. The Y will make it more useful to some but even then it won't solve the immediate issue. That for all their supposed warts petrol powered cars don't require you to change anything you are currently doing. The habits we have established over generations are so ingrained that the time spent fueling and maintenance is not an issue. Now of course they could just plug in at home but people see the costs for charging station installs and say screw it. Infrastructure won't fix this. EV's just don't match petrol cars in common capability in the eyes of shoppers.

Finally, there just isn't enough coverage of the type of vehicles people are buying let alone at any reasonable price. Don't get fixated on the average selling price of cars to determine where an EV should be priced. Vehicles not clean sheet designed to be EV show their failings right up front and cause people to price compare to the petrol version; this includes the Chevrolet Bolt, the Hyundai and Kia cars, and even the Audi and Jaguar cars. Those last two are both incredibly disappointing on range.

Range also is only considered valid for fair weather or better. Get into the 40F/4C ranges and watch your range go goodbye. I can travel anywhere in the US easily with the 3 without concern but not in winter, I do damn well better than any other maker's EV in that regard. Range needs to be much higher to offset any concern owners have, to let them be lazy in charging. Charging speeds aren't too much of an issue but will be once range comes up.

Another option in the range category is, get mid one hundred mile range models out but get them as close to 20k without tax incentives. that might get some of the local only crowd to jump but that is a very price sensitive area.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by larzang on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:41AM (#20093982)
Infrastructure is absolutely the deciding factor for those of us who are not suburban home owners. I live in a building which has 1 EV space for 200-something units. I work in an office building which has 2 EV spaces installed, but they're reserved for the Tesla-driving building owners. There are no public charging stations remotely convenient to either location.

My next car will absolutely be a Prius/Insight/Ioniq, but a full EV is not a reasonable consideration, and not because of range or habits but 100% because of infrastructure. Despite a majority-freeway commute I still pass 5 or 6 gas stations going to and from work every day. I ought to be passing at least one charging station.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by sokoloff on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:56AM (#20094489)
I daily drive an electric for the last 4.5 years. I can't see what possible good passing a charging station on my highway commute would do me. If the car isn't going to naturally rest there, that charging station is only useful for emergencies, IMO.

(I bought the LEAF with the intent to mostly charge at home. Since then, our company moved and we have chargepoints at work, but I agree with your overall point that no charging at home or work is a deal-breaker. I disagree that that is meaningfully ameliorated if there was an intra-commute charging station.)

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by xienze on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:37AM (#20094855)
> I can't see what possible good passing a charging station on my highway commute would do me.

Helping people not driving an electric understand that charging stations exist and are in abundance, thereby alleviating concerns that an electric will leave them stranded. I know where at least ten gas stations are in my normal driving radius, and where some are in adjacent towns. I have no clue where the nearest charging station is, even though I'm aware that some exist. To the average person, it appears as though charging stations don't exist at all and gas stations are in abundance. It's a mindshare thing.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by sokoloff on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:12AM (#20095199)
I'm not sure that "here's a place where you could park and charge for 2 hours in the middle of your commute home" is a positive influence for adoption.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by Klathmon on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @12:40PM (#20096698)
well to be fair, with a Tesla Model 3 it's not "park and charge for 2 hours", it's "park and charge for <20 minutes" in most cases. (assuming it's at a tesla supercharger)

I feel like throwing out exact numbers is disingenuous at best since a lot of things vary charge rate (state of charge, temperature, type of charger, etc...), but 20 minutes will almost always get you to the next charger or a destination in the Model 3.

And while I agree it's not quite "charge on your way home from work", it is something that at least Tesla is working on. Their "Supercharger v3" stalls cuts the stop times roughly in half in the ideal situations. And IMO "stop for 10 minutes on the way home" is absolutely acceptable.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by sokoloff on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @01:02PM (#20096945)
Yes, but the Tesla Model 3 already has enough range for most to charge 2x per week at most. It's the $20K 80 mile electrics that have legitimate range anxiety issues, not the $40K 200 mile electrics.

My LEAF has a fast charger (CHAdeMO) and a 6.6kW Level 2 charger. My car has seen a CHAdeMO charger exactly once in its lifetime and that was before delivery. Most non-Teslas are charging at 3.3 or 6.6 kW (~12 or ~24 miles per hour of charge).

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by xienze on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:22AM (#20095270)
Well, remember that "range anxiety" is more about "I wouldn't buy an electric because what if I have to make a 200 mile trip?" than "I'm worried it won't make it to my office 15 miles away." The fact that electric charging stations are essentially hidden from view reinforces the notion that an electric car would be a horrible choice because it would be unable to handle anything other than in-city commuting (and remember that not everyone has the luxury of buying a car for tooling around town and one for lengthier trips, hence the desire to have one car that "does it all").

Keeping charging stations hidden from view reinforces the notion that you're SOL for long-range trips. Having them be visible and in abundance, even though they wouldn't need them often, would go a long way towards reassuring people that charging stations aren't these incredibly rare things that you won't be able to find when you really need one.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by sokoloff on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @12:24PM (#20096523)
If you have an 80 mile electric (as I do), take your second ICE car or rent an ICE car. No one is going to add 2 3-hour charging sessions (at 24 miles of charge per hour) into a 200 mile road trip and be happy about it.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by fragmede on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:16AM (#20094654)
How sure are you that you aren't? Compared to gas stations, which require a large underground tank to hold gasoline (and diesel), a small electric charging station may require little additional infrastructure and are often rather utilitarian - no awning and no convenience store, just a charger behind a parking spot or two. They are often tucked away behind a restaurant in rest stops next to gas stations, and not always visible from the main road. (Fortunately the Tesla's dashboard knows where they are.)
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by xienze on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:36AM (#20094843)
> hey are often tucked away behind a restaurant in rest stops next to gas stations, and not always visible from the main road.

Perhaps they need to be, because to the average person it seems as if there is a complete dearth of charging stations.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by leetcrew on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:39AM (#20096012)
another issue is, even if there are charging stations in convenient locations, what do you do if you get there and all the slots are being used. I rarely, if ever, have to wait to fill up at the gas station, and when I do it takes less than five minutes for the car in front of me to finish filling up. worse case scenario is I wait for the other person to buy a bag of chips inside the station.

it takes about an hour to charge a tesla most of the way full at a supercharger. no one is gonna wait that long with their car. who knows when they'll be back?

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by Klathmon on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @12:48PM (#20096789)
>it takes about an hour to charge a tesla most of the way full at a supercharger.

while you aren't wrong (it's actually much longer than an hour from low-charge to 100%!), there is a caveat that charging in the 20-80% range is significantly faster, so stopping at a supercharger for more than 30 minutes is almost always slower than only charging the range which can charge most quickly and move on to the next one or your destination. And because of that Tesla has begun limiting max charge at busy supercharger locations to help prevent the issue of no stalls being available in the first place.

The superchargers are also networked and you can see how many stalls are open at any time, which really helps relieve any anxiety i had about it. Many other charging networks (like Chargepoint) are networked as well, and can show you how many are available, and even peak usage times.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by b1daly on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:33AM (#20094810)
I thought GM did a great job with the Volt. My Dad has one. He usually only drives around town, so he never needs gas. But the car has a range of 400+ miles on a full charge and tank of gas. He says the switch from the electric motor is seamless.

It seemed like it really solved the range issue while being a true “plug-in” electric vehicle for daily use.

I think he paid $33k.

It completely failed in the market.

Not sure what to make of that.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by technofiend on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:23AM (#20094719)
>Range also is only considered valid for fair weather or better. Get into the 40F/4C ranges and watch your range go goodbye.

This is the biggest concern for me and by extension I assume many others who live in the South of the United States. It's May and temperatures are not yet topping 40C but they're 32+ at the high and projected to stay that way for months. Even with Tesla's heat management and water cooling for their batteries this potentially means slowed charging rates at superchargers and less range because you have to constantly cool the interior.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by jsight on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:43AM (#20095479)
That is a nice analysis, but tbh, I think it overlooks the big pricing problem that is really at the core of it all. Make the SR+ a 20K car and people would flock to it. As it is, it might struggle to sell more than 300K units per year. But then again, the BMW 3 series only sells about 400k per year at similar price points. The Model Y looks sort of like a cheaper BMW X6. The X6 moves ~50K units per year.

The price points, models, and distribution/service channel limit unit volume more than differences in the operating model of EVs.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by fit2rule on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @06:45AM (#20093703)
>the article says demand for electric cars is not there

I'd see it more as, the demand for electric utility vehicles and industrial transportation systems (truck, etc.) is so great that the demand for personal EV transportation cannot supplant the economies of maintaining an ICE production line.

But, as the article explains this may change in the close to near future, and indeed the technology to supplant the former segments of transportation is definitely on the horizon.

Take this with a grain of salt, but I happen to know that automobile clubs around the world expect that within 5 years, the automotive industry will be radically different to what it is today - they, too, are hedging their bets, and investing in social-sharing technology for the clubs to be promoting when the tech, and consumer expectations around personal transportation, inevitably changes.

Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by DeonPenny on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:35AM (#20095404)
Sounds like it works perfectly. A huge new all america car company is reaping large benefits while research and developing world class EVs up and into the point it kills off some of the legacy automakers.
Re:GM and Fiat Chrysler Unmasked as Tesla’s Source of Cash by benj111 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:47AM (#20094416)
The carbon credits market is designed to impose a cap on the level of CO2 of the car fleet. I would hope that it's agnostic about specific technologies, as it's meant to incentivise manufacturers to find the best way of meeting the cap, eg another option would be to produce smaller cars like they use in the rest of the world, rather than massive trucks.

The fact that companies are going out, buying credits, subsidising lower emitters says to me that the systems working perfectly.