Bing is nowhere near the market share as google. Azure competes with AWS and others. Xbox competes with Sony and Nintendo. Microsoft store competes with Steam. IE and edge are also being beaten by Chrome. I think the argument that Microsoft has a monopoly is much less feasible.
One acquaintance of mine that works at MS humorously remarked on the irony of situation along these lines, "Back in the day Microsoft was the Big Bad. But now we're not big in social media, we're not big in advertising or search. All these other companies are taking the heat now - not for our lack of trying to get into these spaces, though (laughs)."
Excel? I'm in the finance world and I can say with confidence that they've got 100% market share.
We use google sheet too. Every day even....for tracking everyone's QuizOfTheDay scores. Great track but not even close to Excel replacement.
>That means Microsoft has a better product, that doesn't mean it's a monopoly.
Actually that's the text book definition of monopoly.
Monopolies are thus characterized by
* a lack of economic competition to produce the good or service - nobody else is making commercial spreadsheet tools
* a lack of viable substitute goods - all the other stuff (google sheets, openoffice) isn't workable in practice
* high monopoly price well above the seller's marginal cost - a MS office download costs MS near nothing...selling price is still sky-high.
There are crazy network effects at play which create near insurmountable barriers to entry. Another sure sign of a monopoly vulnerable to monopoly pricing/profits.
For smaller datasets, there's online solutions like Google Sheets and Airtable. For larger datasets, there's thousands of different databases that work better than Excel. Either way, consumers have options.
This, currently on the front page...sure doesn't sound like Excel is a monopoly https://foundationinc.co/lab/the-saas-opportunity-of-unbundl...
FB has a monopolistic-power in the network effects like you said, but even then entrants like Snapchat show that the network effects can be gained for new competitors.
Now Google may not have done any of the above with search, but it's likely possible to argue that they have unfairly promoted their own products over others, or "unfairly" chose to not list certain websites.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law#Mo...:
"First, the alleged monopolist must possess sufficient power in an accurately defined market for its products or services. Second, the monopolist must have used its power in a prohibited way"
What's the difference between a monopoly/almost-monopoly and a really deep "moat?"
"...All these other companies are taking the heat now - not for our lack of trying to get into these spaces, though (laughs)."
We're #2. We try harder.
I mentioned them mostly since it seems odd excluding them more than specific actions they took.
Google is going to get wrecked on anti-trust somewhere though that's for sure. My money is on mobile or browser.
Apple, Facebook, and Google all have current practices that are questionable. Pointing fingers are companies that have already paid their dues is just useless noise.
They at least have shady sales tactics.
Apple's business was struggling a bit at the time, but with those cash reserves they were a long way from needing bailing out.
They're all kinda up to the same shenanigans really