The original iPad had 4x the resolution of the original Mac yet the iPad was full screen only and now supports some kind of tiling. Based on some historical writings I wonder if overlapping windows were a gimmick that became the default.
Re:A Tiling Desktop Environment
by tambourine_man on Saturday June 01, 2019 @11:24PM
(#20073258)
The original iPad screen physical size was actually rather similar to that of the original Mac.
And apps often felt way too big on it. The calculator was so comically stretched that they couldn’t bring themselves to ship it.
Full screen only is a simple yet overly contraining model.
The iPad is also single-app, and touch based. This is significantly different from multi-window/multi-app with a precision pointing device like a mouse. The windowing use-cases aren't the same.
Apple kind of invented the overlapping windows paradigm
They preceded the X Window System?They do, because X Windows System was the winner of the UNIX UI wars, there were plenty of more interesting UIs, even on UNIX world, like SunView.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_Window_System#Origin_and_ear... - X announced in June 1984
The Macintosh was introduced in January 1984
Also, dragging something from the desktop and dropping on a floating window was a major breakthrough, which is kind of incompatible with a split screen model.
Personally, on small screens like the original Mac, I think the floating/overlapping WM worked perfectly. On a 30” however, it’s a bit silly.