If we had a reasonable micropayments system so I could spend a few cents per article I read online from non-subscription sites, I'd be thrilled. I do not want to see ads, ever. I do not want companies collecting or selling my activity patterns. If I've signed up for something, I don't want my personal details sold to someone else in order to fund the service. I will gladly pay my proportion of what's necessary to keep the service running in order to avoid the "you're not the customer, you're the product" mentality.
I totally understand that probably most people don't think the way I do. They are happy to exchange their privacy for free stuff, and in some cases wouldn't be able to afford to pay if this wasn't an option. But it's just sad that's the case.
5 bucks a month??!?! You were making 5 bucks a month off JUST ME WITH ADS?!!!!
But it's not that at all. It's simply that credit cards are so heinously inefficient and unreliable and costly to manage that they need to charge that amount of money to not lose money on average. Dealing with fraud and charge backs and the cut the banks take and the cost per transaction. It's just how terrible of a payment system credit cards really are.
If we were getting charged the actual price of the product, most people would happily pay! Load your browser up with 20 bucks and you'll have unobstructed internet for months.
I think this goal is pretty much what Brave is going for, they get a lot of criticism for their implementation here. Of course I'm not shocked, this is a hard problem, and the demand for the solution is irrationally low.
Therefore, to offset this, subscription fees needs to be much higher than the average ad revenue per user.
You'd create two internets: a bourgeoisie sphere of corporate sites with enough influence to be included in the micropayment system, and the unwashed masses, the sites deemed unworthy of monetization, forced to survive on crippled ad market. The handful of large corporate microtransaction payment processors would get to pick and choose who gets to be on the "good internet" without any oversight.
The problems so far with micropayments infra is that publications don't believe their readers will prefer payment over ads. Which is unfortunately largely true, so anyone starting a micropayments company will have a lot of trouble developing the network effects (both on payer and payee side) to be successful.
I don't know the solution to this, but I'd hope it's not legislation. Well -- a possible solution might be legislation that makes it economically infeasible to run sites on ad revenue and selling data. If we make it onerous or impossible to allow sites to collect and sell data, and make it harder for ad networks to target people, sites will have little choice but to implement subscription schemes, or, hopefully, adopt a micropayments-type structure.
Since both are complementary and independent revenue streams, why do you assume that you paying cash for something does not mean you will be monetized in other ways as well?
Tiered to nominal standards of use.
Centrally collected over a large set of services.
With an open and public process of service determination and interest advocacy.
With a disinterested-party dispute resolution process.
Predicated on ability to pay.
Taxes.
> I really don't understand the extreme hostility to data collection and data markets.
I can easily explain my extreme hostility to this: that it happens without my consent and that companies put so much work into actively evading the defenses I put up against it.
> No one likes ads
This isn't about ads. This is about data collection. If ads existed without the spying, I wouldn't have an issue.
> What's really great is that it can really help small businesses and startups over large corporations.
No, that's not really great. I'm all for helping small businesses, but not by allowing them to abuse me.
> I can understand the need for treating data carefully and making sure the data is sufficiently scrubbed for personal identification
That's important too, but it doesn't address the issue of consent.
If data is being collected about me or my use of my machines without my informed consent, that's spying, period. I will treat anybody doing that as the attackers that they are.
I'm sympathetic to the fact that "don't use services that track you" is easier said than done, but all the same, you do have that option.
No, really, you cannot.
FB maintains shadow profles, even for nonusers.
Google tracks virtually all Web traffic. And most email.
Amazon backs or provisions a tremendous amount on online sevices.
Comcast, TimeWarner, AT&T, and Verizon have absolute local, and effective national, monopolies on point-of-presence service across the US. Indigenous telco monopolies operate similarly elsewhere.
Cloudfront, Limelight, Akamai. and other CDN, DNS, and interconnectivity providers see requests and traffic aggregated across huge opulations.
Visa and Mastercard see a huge fraction of financial activity.
And this doesn't even start to touch the vast B2B data services markets in advertising, marketing, finance, credit, risk, tol collection, healthcare (denial) systems, licence plate scanner, retail backends, payments processing, debt collection, and more.
There really is no effective possibility of opting out. Even with denying yourself an effective role in modern society.
data about you is private. The same as your business behind the bathroom door is private. Revealing it creates the "same" harm.
This sounds like snark, but I don't intend it that way. I genuinely want to know.
Who are the good actors? I really can't see any.
I think though that appropriate regulation is going to seriously hamper if not utterly destroy the business models of some really big players.
I want to pay for the ones I use! It is increasingly becoming clear that free stuff is horrible.
It's not a problem with ads. It's a problem with tracking and data collection.
I do not want any company can follow my habits and have a list of my preferences, at least without my consent.
I like general ads (with moderation), not customized based on my past purchases, where I can find out something new and interesting. Like it is on magazines.
https://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/fra-co...
There are plenty of opportunities for abuse here in the US, and we're all reminded of them constantly. The proliferation of ad-blockers and anti-tracking software shows that 'extreme hostility' is widespread. I have yet to see any substantial animus in the EU over the reasonable measures they've taken. Hopefully action on a state-by-state basis in the US will encourage the industry to demand explicit legal restrictions.
What's really great is that it can really help small businesses and startups over large corporations. Brands like Coca Cola can afford to canvas the world with their logo, but a business with a handful of employees must use their marketing budget very carefully. User data and profiling makes it realistic to find those people naturally through their internet habits.
Even if this is being used by politicians, I don't see the harm. If you think people can't think for themselves in the face of political advertising campaigns, then I don't see why you'd also believe that those same people can be trusted with the responsibility of the vote.
I can understand the need for treating data carefully and making sure the data is sufficiently scrubbed for personal identification, but this issue is something different.