News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by derefr on Monday December 13, 2010 @08:13PM (#2002694)
As a (recent) student, my problem has always been ego depletion/"lack of willpower", not so much a lack of intrinsic motivation. In the times I could be spending working, I feel too burnt out to do much other than watch TV/read HN. Starting in on reading a new book would be an insurmountable task, let alone doing productive work. And the worst thing is, I've never found anything that will give me back my "mojo" except time. So, I wait, and sometimes I get lucky and feel a burst of energy before the deadline long enough to start (continuing once started is a lot easier, but no matter how little I tell myself I need to do to get started, there's always a constant factor that can't be subdivided.)

I seem to get this way more often in winter, so it seems like it could be something like Seasonal Affective Disorder (i.e. clinical depression), but I'm never depressed, just unable to convince myself to take any other path than the easiest one (e.g. fast food instead of home cooking, Short stories instead of novels, video games instead of hobby coding, organizing my computer rather than cleaning my house, etc.)

I have a feeling quite a lot of students could describe their problems with motivation in a similar way. It's not "I don't want to study right now, there's nothing fun about that," but rather "I can't study right now, because I am curled up in a ball of stress-avoidance." (If these students had an escapist crutch, like drinking to excess, this is when they would be doing it.)

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by ctl on Monday December 13, 2010 @11:15PM (#2003099)
I've had the same kind of experience since I started college -- my life's had the pattern of "work hard for several days, then recharge for several days," and the recharging days suck -- and although sleep and exercise help a bit I haven't been able to substantially reduce the amount of time I need to bounce back from the slumps. Until now, at least.

At the end of this past summer I took a meditation course with dhamma.org, and three weeks ago I started meditating again. (I went on the retreat for unrelated reasons -- mostly I was thinking, "Ten days doing absolutely nothing, that's crazy, maybe something really amazing will happen to my brain" -- and when I finished it I was, at first, mildly disappointed with the results, so I didn't keep meditating.)

Anyway, meditation has had a really pronounced effect on my overall level of mental energy. I only have three weeks of data so I can't say decisively what it can and can't do, but an hour of meditation seems to cancel out a day or two of accumulated burnout. I'm starting to think that meditation could be literally life-changing on a large scale for me. (Incidentally, it's also unbelievably effective at eliminating stress. I'm actually much more certain of its efficacy as stress-reducer than as energy-replenisher.)

I definitely think you should try out a meditation course next time you have ten days free -- it could really do you some good.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by dan00 on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @03:03AM (#2003492)
"... and the recharging days suck ..."

They don't have to suck. It's mostly a perception of what you should be doing. It's sucks, because you think that you should be doing something, that it's not right doing nothing. It's a social issue.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by gwern on Monday December 13, 2010 @10:21PM (#2002973)
> I seem to get this way more often in winter, so it seems like it could be something like Seasonal Affective Disorder (i.e. clinical depression), but I'm never depressed, just unable to convince myself to take any other path than the easiest one (e.g. fast food instead of home cooking, Short stories instead of novels, video games instead of hobby coding, organizing my computer rather than cleaning my house, etc.)

I would point out that things like SAD (and deficiencies in general like vitamin D) are not necessarily binary or even discrete states where you either suffer it or don't; you can have it in lesser or greater amounts. It's the diagnosis which is discrete - don't confuse the map with the territory.

Although I'm not sure SAD is your problem, you may just have general issues with 'akrasia'. You may find useful or enjoy some of the articles in http://lesswrong.com/tag/akrasia/ (such as http://lesswrong.com/lw/f1/beware_trivial_inconveniences/ or http://lesswrong.com/lw/fu/share_your_antiakrasia_tricks/ ).

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by derefr on Monday December 13, 2010 @10:26PM (#2002987)
I'll give you three guesses as to where I got the term "ego depletion" :)

If it was random or constant, I would agree that that would be simple akrasia—but it's time-modulated, having long periods where I'm willing to attempt high-activation-cost tasks with no particular mental effort, and then long periods where considering such things seems all but impossible. The down periods are greater in the low-sunlight days of the year, whereas a bright blue summer sky can almost be guaranteed to put me in a somewhat manic state. But that's just a correlation, and I might be suffering from some combination of placebo effect and confirmation bias there ("ooh, blue sky, those make me work" -> production of dopamine resulting from that thought -> ability to work.)

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by philwelch on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @01:40AM (#2003357)
"... but I'm never depressed, just unable to convince myself to take any other path than the easiest one (e.g. fast food instead of home cooking, Short stories instead of novels, video games instead of hobby coding, organizing my computer rather than cleaning my house, etc.)"

That sounds a lot like depression to me. Depression isn't always sad or melancholy, sometimes it's just like you said.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by dan00 on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @03:08AM (#2003498)
"That sounds a lot like depression to me. Depression isn't always sad or melancholy, sometimes it's just like you said."

Depression is a serious illness and shouldn't be equalized with an unmotivated mental state.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by philwelch on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @03:36AM (#2003548)
That's a very patronizing response. When I say that depression often manifests as an unmotivated mental state, rather than the overt sadness or melancholy one might assume, I'm speaking from personal experience. As someone who has been medicated for it, I'm the last person who needs to be told that depression is a "serious illness".
Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by dan00 on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @04:28AM (#2003653)
Sorry, if I have been a bit harsh. It's just when people all the time tell how depressed they are, but they're just in a pretty normal bad mood, which vanishes the next day.

If you're then trying to explain people what a depression is, how it feels, then they associate it with their "depressed" days.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by jackowayed on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @03:22AM (#2003522)
Depression is a complicated illness and shouldn't be assumed not to sometimes look like an unmotivated mental state.
Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by dan00 on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @03:39AM (#2003554)
If someone can't work for a few days, or even a week, just hangs around watching tv, playing video games or reading, and after this time is again able to work, then this isn't a depression, but just the need for a rest.

I have been suffering of depressions, and it's nothing like an unmotivated mental state. By equalizing it, you're trivializing depressions. They're real mental pain, they're about loosing any enjoyment.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by derefr on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @08:12AM (#2004024)
> If someone can't work for a few days, or even a week, just hangs around watching tv, playing video games or reading, and after this time is again able to work, then this isn't a depression, but just the need for a rest.

This isn't really what I was talking about, though. It's more being unable to work for months at a time, barely managing to push oneself to scrape by, and then having months of easy, limitless energy. Neither period is predictable—I don't become any more akrasic when I do difficult or stressful work, and no amount of pronounced, conscious "relaxing" (avoiding all stressors, doing only fun things, etc.) will give me energy back any more quickly.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by dan00 on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @08:40AM (#2004080)
Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by philwelch on Wednesday December 15, 2010 @02:10PM (#2009355)
A lot of mental illnesses work that way: there's a pattern of behavior that in and of itself isn't that uncommon, except it's to such a degree that it impairs one's ability to live a healthy life.

Everyone has ups and downs. Not everybody has a mood disorder.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by mitjak on Monday December 13, 2010 @08:18PM (#2002705)
Upvoting not necessarily because I think it relates to the topic at hand but because I always feel very similarly as well. Seems like exercise, proper nutrition, and doing studies at a library or outside of home where you are more likely to be inspired works. Of course, it's easier said than done..
Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by ramidarigaz on Monday December 13, 2010 @10:51PM (#2003037)
I get the same way. I've found that there's a huge boundary to getting started. I sit down and it seems like everything is in my way to getting started on a project. However, once I start writing code, it's not a problem. I did that all semester on my coding assignments. I'd dread them until about 2 weeks before they were due, then I'd sit down and start writing, and next thing I know it's 1AM and I'm almost done. Great feeling :)
Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by hbt on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @04:42AM (#2003681)
I know the feeling and one thing that really helped me is doing things related to a higher goal/purpose. I'm not talking about some spiritual stuff or convincing yourself with bullshit. Just something to aspire to, something you respect and admire or maybe the man you'd like to become. This helps aligning your goals... (but school will always destroy that with meaningless assignments... my approach to school is different)

Also, reducing the level of short-term pleasures for long-term ones really helps.

I don't personally enjoy a great range of activities. It's not depression or numbness but mostly carelessness caused by the lack of general meaning. So, when it comes to coding, it's mostly about working on something that frustrates me (or feel passionate about, the feeling is quite similar in my case) so I can reach a relaxed state again.

Happy, enjoyable are not exactly the words I'd use to describe my work. I feel stressed and anxious when I have a lot of undone things I actually care about, doing them is relaxing and when I'm done, using them or getting them out of my mind is satisfactory ;-)

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by peregrine on Monday December 13, 2010 @10:55PM (#2003048)
You nailed exactly how I feel. Its like rolling a ball up a hill, sometimes I get to the top and it rolls down easily, most times the hill appears to be so insurmountable that I cannot even think to try. I start exercise, eating well, studying, being proactive but it slowly dies as soon as I start getting stressed. The rock gets heavier, the hill gets higher, and the cycle repeats.
Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by psyklic on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @01:14AM (#2003309)
Does anyone know a name for the condition described by the parent post? (i.e. Getting started is the main problem; this sometimes makes complex tasks seem insurmountable or like you can't do them.)

It would be useful to read more about this on other websites.

Re:How to Hack the Psychology of Student Motivation by dan00 on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @03:22AM (#2003524)
The parent post isn't only about the 'getting started problem'. It's about accepting your unproductive days without forcing you to try nevertheless.

About the 'getting started problem', there's the german term 'Handlungs- und Lageorientierung'. People with the personality trait 'Lageorientierung' are very focused on the current emotions. If they currently don't feel doing something, then they don't start doing it.

If you nevertheless of your feelings start doing something, and then feel the enjoyment, then the friction decreases, you're just doing it. You need the initial force to get started.