News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by jdietrich on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:34AM (#19999297)
It's far more ambitious than that.

In the developing world, we've seen a leapfrog effect in telecoms - they skipped over fixed-line phones and went straight to mobile phones. It's far easier to blanket a rural area or a dense slum with 3G signal than to run wires to every house.

That poses a problem when you need fast fixed broadband - there's only so much mobile spectrum to go around, you can't really cheat the Shannon-Hartley theorem, so you end up with tight data caps and unreliable performance. Rolling out fixed infrastructure can be prohibitively expensive, so a lot of areas are stuck on mobile-only.

Low-orbit satellite broadband potentially breaks this dilemma. The low orbit provides tolerable latency (within 30ms of fixed broadband), there's an abundance of spectrum in the Ku and Ka bands and you can steer a tight beam with a phased array. Starlink and OneWeb could potentially offer a satellite broadband product that is competitive with fixed-line broadband on cost, latency and bandwidth, but that is available almost anywhere on earth. Becoming the default broadband provider for half the world's population is Kind Of A Big Deal - maybe enough of a big deal to bankroll a Mars mission.

I think there's obvious potential for this to be Kind Of A Big Deal on a purely personal level. Is your local cable monopoly absolutely terrible? Within a couple of years, it might not be a monopoly any more. Huge amounts of rural real estate becomes a heck of a lot more attractive if literally everywhere has good broadband. This might just be one of those once-in-a-generation technologies that meaningfully changes human geography.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by ecpottinger on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:39AM (#19999645)
I am part of a group setting a tiny house community. We found being more than a hour from any major city center was not a problem for most of the people interested in our setup.

But limited mobile phone service and no high speed internet limits a lot of people. StarLink hopefully comes along by the time we start our planned future expansion.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by mcny on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:04AM (#19999754)
How big is the project? Have you looked at running your own fiber? I imagine the residents wouldn't mind not having to manage their own WiFi...
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by ecpottinger on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:23AM (#19999842)
We are at South River Ontario Canada.

At present we are three owners each building own house, we have 5 different people interested right now joining us to build their homes and our planning is no more than either 50 quarter acre or half acre lots which will let us leave about 15 acres untouched.

The real short term is just Wifi, with ethernet cables for the further homes. Once we get more people, we will look into fiber for everybody.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by richardkmichael on Friday May 24, 2019 @08:08AM (#20000642)
How can I find out more about your project? I am in the area, and this sounds very appealing.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by cheez on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:40AM (#20000475)
How did you get together to build this community?
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by Empact on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:21PM (#20004028)
Point-to-point Wifi is powerful and is being deployed as an alternative to fixed lines in some places. E.g. see the Ubiquiti products. https://www.ui.com/products/#airmax
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by jen729w on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:11AM (#19999491)
I had to check that the Kind Of A Big Deal wasn’t a GSV.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by DuskStar on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:14PM (#20003973)
Obviously, this means that we need to advance technologically to the point that we can fix that problem.

By building a GSV and naming it Kind Of A Big Deal.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by monkeycantype on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:23AM (#20000093)
.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by woile on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:03AM (#19999453)
I want to add that self driving cars, plus high available broadband, might mean a lot of people moving back to rural areas.

With self driving cars you can go out, drink alcohol, socialize, and get back home whenever you want, you can even sleep in the car

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by sharcerer on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:07AM (#20001029)
Could this lead to low population density cities?
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by westpfelia on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:49AM (#20001411)
Not a chance. People will still live in the cities. It just means that city which went from 5,000 people to 2,000 people in the last 20 years might go back to 5,000.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by baq on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:11AM (#20000040)
sleep in the car and not pay hotel tax or property tax? travesty.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by dexterdog on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:02AM (#20002231)
Not for long
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by seniorivn on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:50AM (#20002765)
live in a country without hotel, property and all the other stupid taxes? What a nonsense...
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by grandinj on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:04AM (#19999755)
> you can't really cheat the Shannon-Hartley theorem

No, but you can work within it's limits to achieve some fairly spectacular things.

I predict that if low-orbit sat service starts bringing competition to rural areas, we will see the cell companies start using spatial diversity antennae to dramatically up the available bandwidth.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by vvanders on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:34AM (#20002624)
I'm not sure how solving problems with multi-path and/or LOS helps here. The fundamental problem with rural is that the $ invested : customers served($ out) is drastically lower as population density diminishes.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by grandinj on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:57PM (#20003846)
Spatial diversity does more than help with multi-path issues. It multiplies your available bandwidth by sub-dividing the space around the base-station.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by vvanders on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:47PM (#20005577)
Bandwidth doesn't help you with HAAT[1] and the fact that you need to build out towers every couple miles or more depending on your terrain.

Towers are not cheap to build or maintain, if you only get a couple hundred people per tower it may not make sense to do(and why you don't see a lot of community WISPs except in unique cases).

[1] https://www.fcc.gov/media/radio/haat-calculator

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by indolering on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:43AM (#19999676)
> Low-orbit satellite broadband potentially breaks this dilemma. ... Starlink and OneWeb could potentially offer a satellite broadband product that is competitive with fixed-line broadband on cost, latency and bandwidth.

But it doesn't, despite the marketing of Starlink as a "broadband" network they simply can't service high population density areas.

So it might be a backbone to a 4G tower and possibly usable by consumers in rural areas, but it won't be installed on the roof of a car nor offer connectivity to individual consumers in urban regions.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by jdietrich on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:54AM (#19999982)
SpaceX are planning on launching a lot of satellites - 2800 Ku/Ka-band satellites at 1150km and 7500 V-band satellites at 340km. Both will be capable of steering a 1.5 degree spot beam.

I'm not saying that you're definitely wrong, but Starlink is designed to provide a truly phenomenal amount of throughput. The V-band VLEO constellation is clearly intended to serve urban areas.

https://licensing.fcc.gov/myibfs/download.do?attachment_key=...

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by dsr_ on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:10AM (#20000286)
At 340Km, a 1.5 degree beam covers a circle of just under 9Km diameter. Let's call it 50 square Km.

Population density in Boston is over 5000/sqKm, so 250,000 people have to share that satellite. If 10% are subscribers and they use it 10% of the time, that's 2500 simultaneous users.

Starlink has claimed 20Gb/s per satellite, which gives 1 Gb/s per 125 simultaneous users in this high-density area. That's not great, but it's also not awful.

In any less population-dense area, it can be reasonably competitive, especially as the end-user deployment model is expected to be "here's a pizza-box sized antenna: make sure it's pointed in this general direction of the sky, and give it power and ethernet."

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by tiernano on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:41AM (#20000478)
> which gives 1 Gb/s per 125 simultaneous users in this high-density area. That's not great, but it's also not awful.

thats per satellite... wouldnt you, in theory, have access to multiple satellites? i though the theory was overlap, etc...

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by SEJeff on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:19AM (#20001788)
Yes. I seem to recall either Elon or more likely Gwynne Shotwell saying they're shooting for three or more satellites in view for the system to truly work the way it has been designed.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by earenndil on Saturday May 25, 2019 @12:56AM (#20007162)
3 satellites makes for 24 mb/s per person. Except—I think it's actually 20 Gbps per satellite, so 24 mbps per person, so really only 3 mb/s, which is...usable, but slow.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by ryanmarsh on Friday May 24, 2019 @08:21AM (#20000707)
Reasonably competitive? The competition is non existent in most of the inhabited world. In addition I have a friend on a farm in the US who can’t get a reliable internet connection in spite of the Sprint fiber that runs right in front of his house. This would be a no brainer for a lot of the population. Starlink could have more customers than ATT and Vodaphone combined.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by nabla9 on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:21AM (#20001138)
Starlink satellites spend most of their time above sea and other uninhabited areas.

If I remember correctly, Starlink could potentially serve roughly 40 million customers globally in far to reach areas. Including ships and aircraft. It's not economic solution for the urban population.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by newaccoutnas on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:13AM (#19999787)
> but it won't be installed on the roof of a car

How come?

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by LeonM on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:24AM (#20001157)
It won't be a reliable connection because the car moves around. Stuff like trees, tall building, bridges and tunnels will disrupt the signal. So for cars, a ground based cellular connection will work more reliable.

Antenna alignment could also be a factor, which becomes more difficult if the antenna is attached to a moving object.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by skykooler on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:06AM (#20002291)
The antenna has to constantly realign anyway due to how fast the satellites in low earth orbit move. Given that they're using phased array antennas, which can be steered electronically nearly instantaneously, there should be no issue tracking a satellite from a moving vehicle.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by SEJeff on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:15AM (#20002382)
As mentioned earlier by dsr_, at 340km, a 1.5 degree beam covers a circle of just under 9km diameter. Let's call it 50 square km.

If a single satellite can cover a 9km diameter, I think it will be just fine for vehicles. Especially so as the idea is for overlapping satellites. Also, much of the starlink bandwidth will be used for extra cellular / wireless / internet backbone areas. Areas that need long haul fiber optics to have bandwidth suddenly won't, so it will actually improve existing internet service providers as well since their addressable market will increase.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by indolering on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:23AM (#19999845)
Because it won't work in high-density urban areas.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by woliveirajr on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:33PM (#20003175)
What will it mean to youtube, facebook, google, amazon, netflix, if all those sparse clients with slow internet become a broadband client... And, even more, a client that is driven away by some sort of capping? Of redirection to another site? Ads from another company?

Because net neutrality isn't exactly a thing everywhere, worldwide.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by hairytrog on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:55PM (#20003824)
It'll just be a new monopoly owned by SpaceX. Great
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:38AM (#20001288)
I read an HN comment before that convinced me it's physically impossible for this system to work for more than a couple million devices at VERY low bandwidth (I think the quote was like 0.1mbps). Is this true?

I was all aboard the SpaceX hype train until that comment. I remember looking into his argument, and it seemed like everything checked out.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by eutropia on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:46AM (#20001372)
I'm sure that very smart person thought of problems in 5 minutes in an internet comment that the engineers who just put 60 satellites in orbit with didn't consider about their total addressable market...
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by westpfelia on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:45AM (#20001357)
I mean if you live in a place where you just dont get internet even 100 kbps can be game changing. Sure you cant stream netflix. But being able to some degree go on the internet is pretty big.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by superkuh on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:45AM (#20001358)
Did the arguement stem from the problems of sharing bandwidth due to free space broadcast (instead of wires where everyone can re-use the same bandwidth)? Because, if so, the spot beams for the Starlink sats down to the ground terminal are only ~15 km in diameter. The uplink back to the sats may be a bit more constrained and won't scale. But downstream should be fine.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by thebigspacefuck on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:22AM (#20001822)
Satellite internet is already available in rural areas and it doesn't seem to make that big of a difference. Most people care more about the culture that populated areas provide more than internet speeds.

Personally I pay $30 a month for 15 Mbps. I remember EarthLink or Prodigy being like $15-20 a month for 56Kbps. I remember leaving the modem on all night to download a 30MB demo of Monster Truck Madness in Elementary School. Now speeds are ~250 times what they were and the price has only doubled in the past 20 years? That's f-ing amazing. Prices are not getting out of control if you stick to the bottom end. I'm not even sure what I'd do with gig internet.

For areas going from no internet to satellite internet it's probably going to be amazing, but going from high latency satellite internet to low latency satellite internet will not be a huge game changer.

Adoption of http2 would probably help the quality of existing satellite internet more and be cheaper than this endeavor. As everyone started moving to HTTPS, the handshakes take much longer on a high latency connection and multiplexing would help alleviate that issue.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by sithadmin on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:51AM (#20002131)
>Satellite internet is already available in rural areas and it doesn't seem to make that big of a difference.

It absolutely makes a difference. Rural/isolated communities are being left behind in terms of access to what are now basic staples of modern life: inexpensive, high-quality VoIP and video telecom, diverse sources of streaming video and audio media, real-time online gaming, telecommuting, etc.

The satellite internet available to most consumers today is cost-prohibitive garbage. Most options are doing satellite downlink paired to dialup uplink, and even the stuff that does two-way satellite links provides abysmal performance. All of it usually has a $100+ USD per month cost. Compared against 3G mobile, the latter is a far better deal.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by thebigspacefuck on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:04AM (#20002261)
Just to be clear, I don't think anyone is not moving to a rural area because of the internet speeds.

I'm not sure if you're talking about the U.S. or not, but my parents have satellite internet and they don't even notice a difference unless the dish is full of snow, which I'm not sure is a problem Starlink will solve. They stream, use Skype, and wifi calling. I don't notice much of a difference when I visit. If I try to log into a remote terminal, sure, but I'm not doing that. Internet might be more expensive, but rural properties are cheaper.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by adrianpike on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:15PM (#20003020)
> I don't think anyone is not moving to a rural area because of the internet speeds.

Hi, I'm your counterexample. I held out moving to a rural area until the internet situation got better. It's great out here with a yagi on the roof.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by topspin on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:29PM (#20003145)
What type of RF service is that? I'd appreciate any specifics you care to share. Thanks.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by clarky07 on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:27PM (#20004082)
>I don't think anyone is not moving to a rural area because of the internet speeds.

Definitely not true. It is a big decision point for a lot of people.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by pergadad on Saturday May 25, 2019 @09:16AM (#20008863)
Even within cities a check of "does this have fast internet" is a check for many people before they rent or even buy.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by epicide on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:35AM (#20001963)
> I'm not even sure what I'd do with gig internet.

We're going to find out and that's the most interesting part.

Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by thebigspacefuck on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:49AM (#20002108)
Agreed, but at this point in time I can't think of any "killer apps" for it. It seems silly to pay so much for something I wouldn't be able to use today.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by Kye on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:06AM (#20002295)
I couldn't imagine replacing TV with streaming HD video or downloading free multi-gigabyte sample packs just to see what's in them before before multi-megabyte connections and affordable half terabyte hard drives. Most new or improved technology is speculative. No one knows what people will use it for 10 years later. Guesses rarely pan out.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by thebigspacefuck on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:29AM (#20002563)
That's a good point, but as gig internet is already widely available, I'm not sure the technology is what's holding anyone back.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by Kye on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:41AM (#20002682)
Widespread gigabit is a recent development, and it's still expensive. Whatever technology takes advantage of it is a few years out. I had megabyte cable ~5 years before YouTube launched.
Re:Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system by epicide on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:12PM (#20004469)
> gig internet is already widely available

I don't have it available and I live in an urban area. Hell, I don't even have a viable alternative to my cable company. There's a ton of bureaucracy around all of it.

Political nonsense aside, we rarely see the use for something when it first comes out. That includes really useful things. e.g. all of the super important inventions that were straight up accidents.

Sure, it could take years, but I can't imagine having faster communication between more people not having a huge effect.