Actually not debunked at all.
Headline says "would struggle to cover a $400 emergency" and is perfectly accurate.
The guy doing the "debunking" (sic) looked at the table quoted in the study, isolated the percentage that could not pay the $400 at all (as opposed to the larger set that would struggle to pay it), and then "triumphantly" declared that the headline is moot because those are only ~ 12%.
But the headline was never about how many couldn't pay $400 at all at all. It was about how would struggle to pay it.
The funny thing is he himself quotes the full breakdown, that along with the 12% that won't be able to pay at all, includes people who would need to "borrow from a friend" to pay it (another 12%), "sell something" (8%), using a payday loan (2%) and so on.
Having adequate credit, and being able to pay that off within a month, with zero impact on your ability to pay other bills, doesn't sound like too much of a 'struggle' to me. Sure, people complain, it's inconvenient, some other discretionary expenditures will be clipped, you might pay some extra interest or late fees, boo-hoo. But it's not necessarily a symbol of notable hardship on either historical or international levels. (And if these people didn't have easy credit they're confident they could pay off: they'd have kept more hard cash around, like is common in other countries.)
Just like there's a 'hedonic treadmill', where things that used to bring pleasure wear out from familiarity, there's "complaint inflation", in a generally rich & comfortable place like the USA, where whatever remaining nuisances exist become headline news, and get described in grandiose language previously reserved for deathly serious hardships.
I'm sure something like 40% of Americans "struggle" to get out of bed some mornings. Or "struggle" to choose between a $400 and a $1200 smart phone. Or "can't even" achieve some imprecise euphemestic lifestyle goal like "making ends meet" or "the American Dream". It's mostly hyperbole.
1) At least a few of the possible responses don't really map to any conclusion. Take for example, "Put it on my credit card and pay it off in full at the next statement". Does this mean someone is struggling to pay the expense? Or just a normal way to pay for things? I mentioned in another comment - I keep a fairly large emergency fund and $400 would be trivial to cover, but I'd still pay for it on a card and then pay it off when it was due, so I'd select this option. I think it makes it hard to infer much from this.
2) The responses are multiple choice, so you can't really say "40% of people would struggle". In fact, the percentages sum to 140%, so I don't know what you really can conclude, other than it probably isn't as high as 40% or as low as 12%?
I think a big part of the problem is the structure of the survey that these stories (and the "debunking" are based on) - I don't think you can fully support either conclusion based on it, for a few reasons: 1) At least a few of the possible responses don't really map to any conclusion. Take for example, "Put it on my credit card and pay it off in full at the next statement". Does this mean someone is struggling to pay the expense? Or just a normal way to pay for things? I mentioned in another comment - I keep a fairly large emergency fund and $400 would be trivial to cover, but I'd still pay for it on a card and then pay it off when it was due, so I'd select this option. I think it makes it hard to infer much from this.*
I don't think that's the case with this answer. It's more, I'll need credit cause I don't have either cash or deposits to pay for it.
debunker: actually the data says 12%
data: 12% can't cover $400, 28% would have to borrow the money or sell something to cover $400.
original author: yeah, I added 12 and 28 to get 40 and said "struggle"
Newspapers definitely use narratives to sell papers (or get clicks these days). This is a thing that I don't deny. It has always been a thing.
But it wasn't quite the strong debunking that I expected
That data is garbage.
I personally use CC for all my payments unless it is not accepted.
1) I have the cash ready to spend right now or in liquid assets.
2) I can get the cash, but from an account/asset I'd rather not withdraw from (IRA, jewelry).
3) I can go into debt to pay it, and it wouldn't make a big difference over the next year.
4) I can go into debt to pay it, but my financial situation would be close to bankruptcy over the next year.
5) I can't access that kind of money by any means.
A good survey should iron out this spectrum of "affording" the expense to make the result robust and easy to interpret.
I'd say that both count as "struggle", though
The data is still sound, whether you think having to borrow or sell something to pay an expense is still not being able to pay that expense or not.
Further, pointing out the distinction between these two groups does not strongly debunk the data. That's nit-picking, at best. This should still be concerning, even if it's improved over the past few years.
Of course, whether cash or put on a credit card to be paid off at month's end, that doesn't really say anything about how painful that unexpected expense is. One can cover an expense and realize they're not going to be able to take a vacation this year. There's a continuum between "I can't pay this" and "Whatever."
But it's hard for me to see cash vs. checking account vs. credit card that will be paid off in a few weeks as materially different.
Here, he recognizes that there's double counting but still adds categories in a nonsensical way: https://twitter.com/p_millerd/status/1118071185311330309
The total of all responses is 140%, so there's way more overlap than he seems to account for. Isn't it likely that a lot of that overlap is between the only two answers that mean you have the full amount on hand?
Here, for example: https://twitter.com/p_millerd/status/1118071193393750016
Sure, 83% can still meet their other bills, but that's because, according to the other question he pulls out, half of them expect to borrow money to make it work. The other 15% lines up pretty neatly with the 12% who reported they couldn't beg, borrow or steal $400.
So yes, the newspaper headlines are overstated and imprecise, but the "debunking" is also pretty incoherent.
But I think that misses the point.
Only 41.8% have enough cash on hand. That is, a majority of Americans are living paycheck-to-paycheck. They're not saving money or building wealth - they're surviving.
Maybe this is the norm in other countries. Maybe it's the historical norm. But it doesn't bode well for wage earners.
I routinely pay everything through credit cards that give me cash back and a nice organized ledger or all purchases despite having plenty of cash. A significant portion of people I know do the same thing.
https://twitter.com/p_millerd/status/1118071142311288838
Highlights:
"After some digging I found the 2016 appendix (again, 2017 not to be found). Only 12% of people couldn't actually pay the expense"
"Another survey question not highlighted actually gives some direct clarity on this question. It turns out only about 15% of people would not be able to cover a $400 expense [without impacting their ability to pay other bills]."
Note that "12% couldn't actually pay" is about equal to the 2017 official poverty rate of 12.3%. I don't find it surprising that people counted as "in poverty" would have problems covering a $400 immediate cash expense.