News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost 40% of Americans Would Struggle to Cover a $400 Em... by coldtea on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:56PM (#19994767)
>Headline strongly debunked here:

Actually not debunked at all.

Headline says "would struggle to cover a $400 emergency" and is perfectly accurate.

The guy doing the "debunking" (sic) looked at the table quoted in the study, isolated the percentage that could not pay the $400 at all (as opposed to the larger set that would struggle to pay it), and then "triumphantly" declared that the headline is moot because those are only ~ 12%.

But the headline was never about how many couldn't pay $400 at all at all. It was about how would struggle to pay it.

The funny thing is he himself quotes the full breakdown, that along with the 12% that won't be able to pay at all, includes people who would need to "borrow from a friend" to pay it (another 12%), "sell something" (8%), using a payday loan (2%) and so on.

Re:Almost 40% of Americans Would Struggle to Cover a $400 Em... by gojomo on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:31PM (#19995119)
I guess a lot hinges on the elasticity of 'struggle' here.

Having adequate credit, and being able to pay that off within a month, with zero impact on your ability to pay other bills, doesn't sound like too much of a 'struggle' to me. Sure, people complain, it's inconvenient, some other discretionary expenditures will be clipped, you might pay some extra interest or late fees, boo-hoo. But it's not necessarily a symbol of notable hardship on either historical or international levels. (And if these people didn't have easy credit they're confident they could pay off: they'd have kept more hard cash around, like is common in other countries.)

Just like there's a 'hedonic treadmill', where things that used to bring pleasure wear out from familiarity, there's "complaint inflation", in a generally rich & comfortable place like the USA, where whatever remaining nuisances exist become headline news, and get described in grandiose language previously reserved for deathly serious hardships.

I'm sure something like 40% of Americans "struggle" to get out of bed some mornings. Or "struggle" to choose between a $400 and a $1200 smart phone. Or "can't even" achieve some imprecise euphemestic lifestyle goal like "making ends meet" or "the American Dream". It's mostly hyperbole.

Re:Almost 40% of Americans Would Struggle to Cover a $400 Em... by suresk on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:26PM (#19995084)
I think a big part of the problem is the structure of the survey that these stories (and the "debunking" are based on) - I don't think you can fully support either conclusion based on it, for a few reasons:

1) At least a few of the possible responses don't really map to any conclusion. Take for example, "Put it on my credit card and pay it off in full at the next statement". Does this mean someone is struggling to pay the expense? Or just a normal way to pay for things? I mentioned in another comment - I keep a fairly large emergency fund and $400 would be trivial to cover, but I'd still pay for it on a card and then pay it off when it was due, so I'd select this option. I think it makes it hard to infer much from this.

2) The responses are multiple choice, so you can't really say "40% of people would struggle". In fact, the percentages sum to 140%, so I don't know what you really can conclude, other than it probably isn't as high as 40% or as low as 12%?

Re:Almost 40% of Americans Would Struggle to Cover a $400 Em... by coldtea on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:53PM (#19995798)
>* suresk 1 hour ago [-]

I think a big part of the problem is the structure of the survey that these stories (and the "debunking" are based on) - I don't think you can fully support either conclusion based on it, for a few reasons: 1) At least a few of the possible responses don't really map to any conclusion. Take for example, "Put it on my credit card and pay it off in full at the next statement". Does this mean someone is struggling to pay the expense? Or just a normal way to pay for things? I mentioned in another comment - I keep a fairly large emergency fund and $400 would be trivial to cover, but I'd still pay for it on a card and then pay it off when it was due, so I'd select this option. I think it makes it hard to infer much from this.*

I don't think that's the case with this answer. It's more, I'll need credit cause I don't have either cash or deposits to pay for it.

Re:Almost 40% of Americans Would Struggle to Cover a $400 Em... by woobar on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:39PM (#19995190)
If you looked at that table you would notice that the total is more than 100%. So the analysis in your last paragraph is not better than his.