In fact, upward mobility is much better in places like France and the UK[1].
Most people like me, who pay attention to history and current social issues, see the American dream and the myth of meritocracy as a way to keep the poor from seeing that the system is rigged against them and becoming restless.
1. https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2018/02/14/american...
Why do they only limit social mobility in terms of going from the bottom to the top quintile? That seems like one very limited measure.
Also, how does social mobility measure when you look at absolute gains? If America's top quintile is much higher than Europe's (which it is), you could have someone go from $20K to $200K per year in the US (bottom to 4th quintile) and that would be viewed as worse than someone going from $20K to $150K in Europe (bottom to top quintile).
Plus, you can't cherry pick social mobility papers, because they actually go both ways (US low or US high). It all depends on how you measure it.
Meritocracy? GTFO! Companies do nothing but virtue signal these days.
They have such high upward mobility because of high tax rates since high tax rates allow funding more public institutions (health care, education, housing, child care) that make upward mobility possible. By the time you're wealthy enough to "have the rug pulled our from under you" you're already in the top 10% - top 1%. Getting the rug pulled at that point just means you make a little less money.
It also means you have a much harder time saving for a house, funding a company etc. The top 10% are also the most important part of a society from an economic perspective.
So basically its easier to get into the top 10% in Europe while its easier to get into the very top in America.
The are much more selfmade Billionaires in America , i suspect its the same for Millionaires
https://www.citylab.com/life/2016/05/world-billionaire-wealt...
From my perspective there's no reason to value the ability to become a 'self-made' billionaire if it leaves more of the 'precariat', and I prefer a society that reduces the number of people that are part of it.
Unfortunately i think that the more "unfair" society would be more dominant and will outcompete it over time, thereby making it worse.
So i think in the end some unfairness will isnecessary, but maybe less then we have today
Taxes are used to finance and subsidize common services such as heathcare, public transport and education, which people with a disadvantaged background otherwise could not afford.
Thus, it is more likely that those which were born in a low income family (and are willing to improve their situation) can move upwards, since they don't have to worry so much about basic needs.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility
https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2018/02/14/american...
Which might suggest that the high tax rate isn't inherently linked to upward mobility, or at least that it's much more complicated; that taxing high-earners isn't inherently anti-mobility.
What do you mean with that?
I don't actually want to put words into the other posters mouth. There is, however, a sizeable number of people in America who act like the only the that matters is the rules around getting rich and that having social services that allow anyone to take a gamble on entrepreneurship don't count as helping a meritocracy get in place
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legacy_preferences