Re:It’s Time to Hold American Elites Accountable for Their A...
by refurb on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @11:26AM
(#19970984)
Sorry, but I have a bone to pick with social mobility as measured in the cited articles.
Why do they only limit social mobility in terms of going from the bottom to the top quintile? That seems like one very limited measure.
Also, how does social mobility measure when you look at absolute gains? If America's top quintile is much higher than Europe's (which it is), you could have someone go from $20K to $200K per year in the US (bottom to 4th quintile) and that would be viewed as worse than someone going from $20K to $150K in Europe (bottom to top quintile).
Plus, you can't cherry pick social mobility papers, because they actually go both ways (US low or US high). It all depends on how you measure it.
Why do they only limit social mobility in terms of going from the bottom to the top quintile? That seems like one very limited measure.
Also, how does social mobility measure when you look at absolute gains? If America's top quintile is much higher than Europe's (which it is), you could have someone go from $20K to $200K per year in the US (bottom to 4th quintile) and that would be viewed as worse than someone going from $20K to $150K in Europe (bottom to top quintile).
Plus, you can't cherry pick social mobility papers, because they actually go both ways (US low or US high). It all depends on how you measure it.