News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by option on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:18PM (#19966851)
its 2019 and people in developed countries still care about (and support with their taxes) kings, queens, emperors and such?!
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by dang on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:26AM (#19967739)
Could you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? The discussion that results is generic, shallow, and boring.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by sdrothrock on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:02PM (#19967065)
It's 2019 and people still like to mock cultures and traditions blindly. The article does a pretty good job of explaining a lot of the situation in a grounded, rational way -- especially concerns over the uses and potential abuses of taxpayer money.

The US essentially deifies the Founding Fathers even though we're living in a world with influences and technologies they could never have anticipated. Why is it ok care so much about that history but not for other countries to care about their history?

The system of government also doesn't seem like a firm basis of argument to me. Yes, many governments have moved on from monarchies, but that doesn't mean that there may not be a monarchy in a country in the future, nor does it mean that a monarchy is an objectively terrible country to live in.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by TomMckenny on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:52PM (#19967247)
I'd say the grand parent view comes from an uneasiness at anything hereditary, although there's much less objection to hereditary wealth for some reason.

So I'd say it comes from a dichotomy between hereditary wealth and hereditary power, although it's well known that monarchs in democracies are tightly constrained while hereditary wealth brings hereditary power.

It might be the inevitable tie between monarchy and religion which creates a de facto most "correct" national religion. Along with the occasional claim that mythical origins are literally true.

And while comforting, historical and even stabilizing at the moment, it's worth noting that a great many monarchs were quick to join the wrong side of history in WWII.

So, for those without a monarch and the attendant enthusiasm, the institution looks like an extremely expensive and potentially dangerous embodiment of unfairness. Without commenting on the correctness of this view, one can see how it would make monarchies and monarchists incomprehensible to outsiders.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by mango7283 on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:57PM (#19967271)
Off the top of my head, most Western European monarchs headed governments in exile on the side of the allied powers, where are you getting that a great many sided with the wrong side of history?
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:37PM (#19967404)
Italy, Germany, Greece, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia and more:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_former_monarchies#Mode...

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by gdhbcc on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @02:46AM (#19968037)
Germany was not a monarchy during ww2. The Italian king fought for both axis and allies (and joining the allies was a big reason why he was voted out after the war). Yugoslavia was invaded by the axis, as was Greece.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @10:26AM (#19970424)
> The Italian king fought for both axis and allies (and joining the allies was a big reason why he was voted out after the war).

...I'm not sure that a monarch who can be voted out is really an autocrat in the way most people think of when they hear the term.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by dragonwriter on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:41PM (#19967421)
> So I'd say it comes from a dichotomy between hereditary wealth and hereditary power

Which is, of course, a false dichotomy, since wealth is power.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by option on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:56PM (#19967266)
Yes, very well said.
[dead]
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by tomhoward on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @12:48AM (#19967623)
Mockery is the antithesis to a dispassionate examination of how things evolved to be the way they are, and without an understanding of that, it's not really possible to bring about change in any orderly, lasting way.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by gumby on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @12:57AM (#19967644)
> its 2019 and people in developed countries still care about (and support with their taxes) kings, queens, emperors and such?!

It's the 21st century and people still seem to consider inheritance of aristocratic levels of wealth acceptable too.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by npsomaratna on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:49PM (#19967004)
People see the royal family as both a living link to their past and a unifying force for the nation that is above mere politics.

Add to this the fact that the Japanese royal line is by far the oldest in the world and that the Emperor is also the head of the Shinto religion.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by Lazare on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:09PM (#19967090)
You're very well aware this occurs. Are you trying to ask why, or to make some social commentary, or were you just deploying snark?
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by a_imho on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @03:10AM (#19968128)
I don't think it necessarily reflects what people think, average folks can do very little to shape the narrative.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by nine_k on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:27PM (#19966890)
You would be shocked to learn how much people willingly donate to churches, temples, cults, and other strictly irrational enterprises.

Kings and emperors are a very inexpensive symbolic flourish on top of that — and many of them do a reasonable job of unifying a nation.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by cataphract on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:35PM (#19967175)
I'd rather have a city full of churches/mosques/temples, which are at least generally interesting public use buildings, than a skyline dominated by glass towers occupied by banks, insurance and consulting companies.

And anyway at least as far as the Catholic church is concerned, most money ends up in social causes.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by rayiner on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:58PM (#19967040)
I think you mean “partly” rather than “strictly.” Even if you remove the supernatural element (the part that calls for faith, which is not rational), you’re still left with a political, philosophical, and moral framework. Such frameworks aren’t irrational any more than say “social democracy” as a political framework is irrational. The you have the utilitarian social functions. Serving as places for members of the community to interact, a place for children to be socialized, a place to help elderly people stay connected, a vehicle for addressing local social issues.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by nine_k on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:24PM (#19967137)
A political or philosophical framework needs not be rational to be efficient and useful.

The very idea of love (especially as in 2Cor13) is quite irrational, still it worked, and moved a lot of people over millennia.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by hbarka on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:30PM (#19966912)
I wonder, of civilizations that have lasted the longest, which ones had kings, queens, emperors and such versus the opposite?
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by lmm on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @06:23AM (#19968882)
The Republic of Venice was a rare exception in a world of kings/queens/emperors - and also exceptionally stable, prosperous, and quite possibly (depending on how one regards the Meiji Restoration, to return to topic) the long-lasting nation state in history.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by option on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:35PM (#19966935)
I think you are confusing correlation with causation there
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by geofft on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:19PM (#19967345)
That's not an argument that something is good. Civilizations willing to perpetuate genocide tend to survive longer and achieve more economic success than those unwilling to, for instance (they face fewer external threats).

To be clear I disagree with the person you're responding to - I just think we should be careful about counterarguments with significant collateral moral damage.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by hbarka on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @12:41AM (#19967600)
You’ve taken my response to another degree, but I wholeheartedly do not disagree with you. In fact I admire it. I think you want to remind us that we as humans are horrible when given power, irrespective of title.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by chrisseaton on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:07PM (#19967084)
In the UK I think about 70% of people support the Queen, our head of state. How many people in the US support their head of state? Less than 50%.

In practice, it seems to work well for us. We get a representative that most people support. The US republic fails to do that and their representative is always deeply divisive.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by mensetmanusman on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:35PM (#19967176)
The US president has a higher % of support than prime ministers in most EU countries due to the nature of the two party system. E.g. Trump has higher approval ratings than Macron amongst the relative populations. Each system has advantages/disadvantages.
Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by option on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:51PM (#19967241)
The queen is not your representative, but you are all her “subjects”. She is literally above the law and is thus, by law, some kind of “higher” human than others, which is hilarious.

I actually respect your current queen, Elizabeth 2, a person - she is doing great given the situation she was born into. But I despise royals as an institution of power and priveledge.

Re:Abdication, Succession and Japan’s Imperial Future: An Em... by chrisseaton on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @05:05AM (#19968585)
> you are all her “subjects”

This is not true - very few people are subjects.

https://www.gov.uk/types-of-british-nationality/british-subj...