News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @06:53PM (#19966074)
Privatization shifts the signaling game theory from pandering to government funding to pandering to consumers. Given that consumers don’t have nearly as much time to research options individually as governments do collectively, this can and likely will create far worse outcomes on average.

edit: This comment has gone from 8 points to 4 points in about 10 minutes, so I can only assume this thread has become the target of a downvote brigade from some other web site. The joys of discussing politics in the age of 4chan!

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by cobbzilla on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:06PM (#19966162)
By this logic, shouldn’t we nationalize most major industries? oil/energy, motor vehicles, the list is endless.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by joe_the_user on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:16PM (#19966235)
The role of private industry is to efficiently produce commodities for individuals or other companies - minus externalities, autos, chips or airplanes are great in private hands.

The role of the state is to regulate positive and negative externalities. And students learning something is actually a (positive) externality. Neither the student nor the parent or even the district directly care about everyone learning basic skills - that provides no relative advantage for them. Signals of being superior are worthwhile to the individual. Those might actually result in the individual being smarter but if an individual is "selfish" or thinking in pure "homo-economicus" terms, they are just happy being able to always seem competent rather than being competent.

So the state (or whatever institution can represent "all of society") is what is needed to increase the base competency of a society.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:15PM (#19966224)
At an abstract level, one of the major goals of regulation is to stop companies from doing things that consumers can only figure out are bad on a timescale long enough for them to have already done damage and made enormous profits. There are a ton of regulations around motor vehicles, like disclosing MPG, maintaining safety standards, and consistent odometer readings - things that consumers wouldn't necessarily be able to figure out on their own until it was too late. If a car just plain doesn't work, or craps out in less than a thousand miles, that's easy to remedy.

The problem with applying these standards to education is that the timeframe to assess damage is very long, and it's more or less irreversible.

If you spend a week driving a car and the engine dies, you can take it back and get a refund and then go get a new one.

If you put your kid in a charter school and they fail to learn math for a year, you can't get that time back. It's gone forever, and your child will be behind for anywhere from months to years to forever.

This is why we need to treat certain specific sectors differently. Consumer goods, sure, whatever, the government can make sure that toys don't contain lead and that our TVs wont randomly explode, and after that it's up to us to decide.

But education, healthcare, etc., the consequences of giving consumers "choice" and allowing those sectors to advertise freely and self-regulate are severe and often irreversible.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:29PM (#19966315)
My middle school and high school career was upended by an experimental math program that wasted an enormous amount of time forcing children to answer questions like "What is 2+3?" with a minimum of three sentences. The head of the department was later demoted for injuring a child when he sat on him as a form of punishment. He was later acquitted of assault charges. Did regulation work there? Could it have? Do government schools not need to be regulated by virtue of the fact that they're already promulgated by the government?

As an aside, while looking this up I found news stories that demonstrated the rumors about sex abuse were true and a few coaches-turned-principals got nailed. While your theory about regulation seems well-intentioned, I'm just not sure it is worth anything in practice. Lots of governmental theory seems revolutionary until it ends in failure (and, at worst, bloodshed).

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:40PM (#19966378)
The plural of anecdote is not data. And taking the furthest logical conclusion ("Government regulation ends in violence!") is utterly ridiculous and unnecessary in this context.

To be clear, the United States' public education system is BAD. It is sometimes VERY BAD. But it's not consistently bad; there are public schools that are quite good.

There are other countries with heavily regulated public education systems that are so much better than the United States - read up on Finland's remarkable public education system if you don't believe me. (And don't get tripped up on inconsistent usage of "public" and "private" to mean opposites in different countries!)

So logically, the problem isn't that government regulation of education is inherently bad; Rather, the problem is that we (in the United States) are doing a bad job of it. Splitting public education funding between public schools and charter schools and forcing public schools to compete with test scores and other proxy metrics is demonstrably making things worse, not better.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:52PM (#19966746)
"We" are not doing a very good job of it. I agree with you there. Both my parents (and their parents) are or were educators in public schools, from teachers to instructors to principals and coaches. By all accounts it is getting worse, not better.

Anecdotes are not data, but it would be foolish to throw them away blindly. Anecdotes become data when they can be used to answer questions that can inform future decision making processes. For example, we could ask, "is more politics and political process positively impacting education?" If the answer is that no, one hundred years of American politics hasn't improved the situation [0] despite it costing far more than it used to per-student [1], then we should probably conclude that said process is a dead end and look elsewhere.

I never claimed that the anecdote I provided was data; I would rather like to know the answers to the questions I asked. Handwaving them away seems closer to arguing in bad faith than what you accused me of doing elsewhere. Further, I would suggest that the increased presence of School Resource Officers in schools, the increased usage of courts for school-related punishment, and the continued emotional and physical violence experienced by students from their peers show that, indeed, forced participation in government schools does indeed involve violence. That your experts have been unable to solve this problem (and that you hand wave it away) does not generate confidence in your position.

[0] https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/ltt_2012/summary.aspx [1] https://www.cato.org/blog/public-school-spending-theres-char...

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:10PM (#19967093)
"Further, I would suggest that the increased presence of School Resource Officers in schools, the increased usage of courts for school-related punishment, and the continued emotional and physical violence experienced by students from their peers show that, indeed, forced participation in government schools does indeed involve violence."

This is a pretty bad correlation/causation argument.

You're making arguments that only make sense if: 1: The United States is the only country in the entire world with a government-run education system and there are no other examples to look to 2: Every decision made that has negatively impacted our education is the only possible decision that could have been made under the circumstances

Neither of these are true.

Just because our government has made some really bad decisions doesn't mean that this is the only possible outcome of government-run education. If you look at education rankings globally, the United States is pretty far down the list, and most if not all of the countries above us use government-run education systems. The number one in the world, Finland, prohibits private schools all together.

It simply does. not. logically. follow. that the overreach of our criminal justice system is the inevitable result of a government-run education system.

You're ignoring so many political realities that are unique to this country.

There is nothing hand-waving about saying that your anecdotes are not data. I went to a school that had exactly zero teacher/child sex scandals, can I use that to "prove" that the system is working? No, I can't.

Our public education system delegates a LOT of responsibility down the line. The federal government offers some funding that is contingent on certain requirements being met, but the states are responsible for the execution. The states have elected officials and appointed boards of education, but they delegate a lot of decision-making to individual districts, which also have elected and appointed officials.

Finally, just because I am defending the idea of government-run education doesn't mean I am defending the implementation of it that we have. Please do not confuse those two distinct positions.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by danharaj on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:15PM (#19966221)
There might be a better way now than what was practical in 1900.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by emilfihlman on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:27PM (#19966303)
Of course.

It's a lie perpetuated by capitalists that the government can't do things efficiently. The government can absolutely do things efficiently, the costs are usually by having more protections for the employees, which is good. Additionally, we remove the need for a profit layer that would go to owners (the nation is the owner in this case) so to achieve the same results as nation owned companies

Not to mention that there is no exit to look for, nation owned companies cannot be stripped of assets and they cannot claw and scrape the consumer, which is how for-profit-private companies would operate.

Now am I saying that all things should be nation owned? Of course not. I'm saying that monopolies, infrastructure and huge old government companies should be and should stay as nation owned. Private companies will work with providing for these companies resources that they don't have and would pay more to develop themselves.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by tracker1 on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:22AM (#19967723)
While I will conceptually agree, that optimizing some things via the government can work better. In practice, however, it often leads to cronyism, corruption, bureaucracy and/or stagnation.

On the flip side, I'm also against certain things being incentivized by the government. I'm against private prisons on pure premise.

In the end, I'm pragmatic and prefer to optimize for those solutions which require the least oversight and ensure for the best competition practical. I'd also like to see an "open body" of course content made more widely available, so that districts and teachers may pull in said content for individualized courses. Educational publishing is about as corrupt as it gets IMHO.

I do think that for most things, there are ways to incentivize appropriate outcome from private businesses and initiatives with the government. This includes more appropriate provisioning and budgeting practices.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by syrrim on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:10PM (#19966187)
consumers have skin in the game
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by bunderbunder on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:15PM (#19966230)
If consumers having skin in the game were a sufficient condition for them to make good choices, we wouldn't have needed the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic act to ban radium water in order to get people to stop buying it.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by syrrim on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:27PM (#19966305)
Radium water has a tendency to infect the water supply, so that even people who don't buy it are affected by it. The principle of intolerance applies the other way for schools: people who are picky about schools will do lots of research, whereas people who aren't picky will just go where their friends go.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:55PM (#19966469)
What you're suggesting is building a system that actively punishes parents who are too busy to a ton of research because they're working multiple jobs, taking care of sick family members, etc. Characterizing people who don't have time to do this as merely "not picky" is ignoring and punishing a huge segment of the population.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by syrrim on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:27PM (#19966638)
The principle of skin in the game doesn't merely improve the situation for picky people, it brings up the average improving the situation for everyone. If picky people at large boycott a particular school, everyone who is friends with these people will boycott it by association, and it will lose too many students to remain solvent. If picky people prefer giving their business to certain proprietors, those proprietors will open more schools, increasing the likelihood that a person choosing schools using a dart board will strike such a school.

Your characterization of the difficulty of choosing a school is overdramatic. A person could devote fifteen minutes to googling "best schools in {area}", maybe even turning up a government sponsored list. If they ever notice the chosen school is bad, say from complaints of their ward or from bad grades, they would switch schools, improving the situation via negativa.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:13PM (#19967097)
Googling it? The whole point of this thread is that that can be gamed. Do you want to reward schools for having the best SEO? Or for doing a better job of incentivizing people to review their school on whatever web site?
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by syrrim on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:12PM (#19967322)
Google "best restaurants" and you'll find a list of decent restaurants. They may not be the best restaurants, but they also won't suck. That brings us par with the status quo, from 15 minutes of work.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @12:11PM (#19971545)
It only takes one meal to know if a restaurant is good. It takes a lot more than that to know if a school is good.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by tracker1 on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:26AM (#19967734)
I've often thought it would be a great idea to allow for parents to work one day a month at their child's school. This would put more parents in the circle. I think it would take time and some training to get to a good place on this, but would allow for a lot more insight and probably increase interaction dramatically.

One or two more sets of eyes in most classrooms each day, more people to help answer questions, etc. Far fewer WTF moments with some schools.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by JamesBarney on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:34AM (#19967780)
There a phds in education who are trying to figure out which schools do the best job teaching using more information and statistical information than a parent will have in their entire lives. And they have trouble figuring this out, how the hell is some random parent supposed to figure this out?
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by syrrim on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @06:13PM (#19975674)
An individual parent doesn't figure this out on their own. The market, composed of all parents, determines it. The market has access to more information than any phd will ever be privy, because it knows the individual feelings of every parent, child, teacher, and administrator. The market is unique in being able to perform randomized, controlled, double-blinded studies on the whole population, whereas phds are stuck looking at correlational data of small samples. The market performs continuous replication of every result ever identified, such that subgroups can be made arbitrarily small while maintaining significant p-values (and has no publication bias). And the market has access to the intellect of every phd, bachelors degree, or idiot that read a book once who ever had children or who wants to make a quick buck, conspiring in the greatest peer-review in history.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @12:12PM (#19971554)
Because “consumer choice” is one of those libertarian ideas that’s fueled entirely by theory and ideology and not by data.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:17PM (#19966246)
This is a very obvious argument for privatization of any industry, but check out my response in this same comment thread. Consumers OBVIOUSLY have skin in the game, but asking a consumer to figure out which charter schools are great and which are frauds and which are merely mediocre requires far more research than the average parent has time to do. The incentive for a charter school to misrepresent its achievements is very high, and once a parent has committed to putting their child in that school, the cost of moving them to another if/when they discover problems is very high. By that point, the charter school will have already taken the voucher funding and can use it to advertise to the next sucker.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by coredog64 on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:01PM (#19966508)
AFAICT, a public school has the same incentives and has even higher switching costs (approximately 6% of the value of your house, whatever transaction fees your local government tacks on, plus whatever it costs to pack up and move).
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:14PM (#19967102)
Charter schools can be for-profit enterprises, or can be structured in such a way that executives can make a lot of money (even if they are technically non-profits). This is what skews the incentives for charter schools versus public schools.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:43AM (#19967814)
Skin in the game doesn't make complex and often temporally distant utilities from sui generis non-repeated transactions any less opaque.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:15PM (#19966228)
Why would mere time to research options lead to better research being done? My five year old has effectively infinite time to research, say, efficacy of cancer treatments compared to an overworked researcher in a clinical setting. In fact, let's just shift all science to people in nursing homes who need to fill their time anyway. Utopia awaits?
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:22PM (#19966273)
This sounds like a complete nonsense argument. Can you explain what your point is? Are you saying that it's impossible to accurately research anything? Or that, given infinite time, parents would be so bad at researching charter schools that they would never be able to divine the best choice anyway?

What do you think MY argument was? I suspect you misread.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by joe_the_user on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:28PM (#19966307)
I believe the gp is engaged in the bad-faith approach of taking your comment about the state having more time as being literally the only argument you're making, where it's of course obvious the state has more advantages than simple time (including trained personnel, institutional practices, etc, etc).
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:35PM (#19966347)
Why is that a bad-faith approach to response? That's the argument being presented, and there are myriad reasons it's entirely without merit. If the argument is that the state has more advantages, they can also be presented one-by-one and weighed. Politics often fails precisely because it smashes far too many decisions into one do-or-die package. Why should we repeat that unproductive pattern here?
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by tanderson92 on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:45PM (#19966404)
It's a bad-faith fallacy because the OP's point holds even if the playing field is level and the state doesn't have an advantage in any other component than the stated one (time). The bad-faith comment (yours) instead reversed it, implicitly claiming the state was negatively positioned with respect to factors other than time, and pretended that was the OP's argument.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:12PM (#19966567)
The state is negatively positioned; it has poor-to-no feedback with regard to the personal outcomes of its implementations. Parents and students do, on an ongoing and daily basis. The idea that I "pretended" that this was anyone else's argument but my own seems completely absurd.

While I'm glad you're able to infer implications, it would be wonderful if you could take it a step further to find that an argument cannot be true if a necessary premises is false. That's not bad faith, that's logic.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:47PM (#19966420)
You're not doing the bare minimum of even attempting to understand the purpose of my argument and instead taking the dumbest possible literal interpretation and then responding to that. That is the very definition of a bad-faith argument.

Governments can hire experts to determine standards by doing research, and then can apply those standards over time to the schools they regulate. They can also collect massive amounts of data and compare performance between schools, across time, determine means and check for outliers, etc. etc. etc.

My argument is that consumers don't have time to do any of that. They have time to do what they do with colleges: Read a limited number pamphlets, thumb through Newsweek's annual "best colleges" report, maybe spend a few minutes here and there checking data online.

We can, as a society, devote more resources to making sure the government regulation side of things improves. What we can't do is collectively give OURSELVES more time to do that research individually.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by souprock on Monday May 20, 2019 @10:18PM (#19967111)
Although "Governments can hire experts to determine standards by doing research, and then can apply those standards over time to the schools they regulate.", those supposed experts can be pretty bad.

Richard Feynman relates a fascinating account of this in his book "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!". Aside from him, every "expert" gave good scores to books that were entirely blank.

Some quotes from that: https://fs.blog/2016/07/richard-feynman-teaching-math-kids/ http://whyhomeschool.blogspot.com/2006/08/richard-feynman-on...

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:18AM (#19967713)
The argument that “we could screw this up” is not the same as “we will screw this up and therefore should not do it.”
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:24PM (#19966620)
Oh no, I understand your argument full well. I just think it's extremely shallow. Parents and students have plenty of time to research important aspects of their lives, starting with the experiential reality of the school they're subjected to for several years. One of your argument's shortcomings is the implication that only an a priori decision making process is possible for the over-a-decade process of going to school.

I would argue that these experiential data are more valid than metrics like standardized test scores by ethnicity or "letter grades" that the government gives itself for its school. Ultimately I question the motives behind many of these testing methodologies, because when they're not meant to satisfy the motivation of the student and/or their parents, the student (and their parents) become the product.

But even if parents could choose between multiple public school pedagogical methodologies, many can't simply because it requires selling the family's house and relocating to a different district. It's hard to have time to impact a situation when the situation is already fixed before the fact, but of course then it's not a time issue at all.

Ultimately I was responding to a two-sentence comment from you. I don't think complaining that my response was "bare minimum" is an appropriate way to handle the challenge, and I find the resort to name-calling about the "age of 4chan" particularly off putting.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by joe_the_user on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @02:58PM (#19973586)
You originally make a completely bad-faith that compares the state to a two year old. Showing a more developed argument now, regardless of its truth, doesn't make the original argument better.

I don't agree with your developed argument either but that's a different matter.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:55PM (#19966761)
"Oh no, I understand your argument full well. I just think it's extremely shallow."

Maybe you should poke around the rest of the comments for the article, because I've gone into a lot of detail about it.

"Parents and students have plenty of time to research important aspects of their lives"

I've addressed this elsewhere in the thread, but this assumption penalizes the children of parents who are poor, working multiple jobs, or dealing with health issues. It penalizes single parents as well. Basically, if you put the onus on parents to do the research, parents with more disposable time will make better decisions for their children, thus exacerbating the existing inequalities in the system. The whole point of the public education system is to level the playing field; what you're suggesting will increase the gap between the haves and the have-nots.

"...starting with the experiential reality of the school they're subjected to for several years. One of your argument's shortcomings is the implication that only an a priori decision making process is possible for the over-a-decade process of going to school."

What you're suggesting is that it's okay to have a system where parents and students make the decision about whether or not schools are good or bad by spending time at them. That is a ludicrously impractical suggestion. What happens if your kid hates their first day of school? Their first week? Their first month? How do you decide when they can make decent decision about it? What if they just hate going to school? Are you going to go sit in the classroom and watch the teacher for hours or days at a time?

Experiential data is not particularly useful on an individual basis; There are so many kids who just have a bad time at school no matter what, often for reasons that don't implicate the school directly as good or bad. And there are plenty of kids who have a great time at school precisely because they're not getting a very good education. (IE they're ignored, the work is too easy, etc.) Their experience is going to be fantastic, and they will enter college completely unprepared.

I'm not arguing that the EXISTING methods for measuring school performance are perfect; I am arguing that theoretically, the best possible version is mass-collection and analysis of data. Relying on individual decisions based purely on experience is a recipe for chaos; Kids would be begging their parents to change teachers and schools all the time, and how would parents have any idea if the kids were right?

I didn't complain that your response was the bare minimum, I complained that it was LESS than the bare minimum. And my 4chan comment was about the downvoting, not about your comment. Please read more carefully.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @12:26AM (#19967560)
As these things tend to do, the issues balloon and it becomes impractical to respond to every point.

The idea that parents who don't care are penalized is simply a fact of life. Should we make the same argument about diet— that the state has the resources to appoint Top Dietitians and mandate a uniform State Diet? In fact, the experts that the state has hired have been corrupted by players like the corn and dairy lobbies and the nutritional advice they've given in the past has been roundly derided as terrible. Further, obesity has gotten worse since that advice has been given. Why would we think that the same state mandating institutional assignment would produce better results? Apparently, according to you, because other State education departments in other cultures and parts of the world have had comparatively more success by state-reported metrics? Again, I'm unimpressed at this justification for property taxes.

"What you're suggesting is that it's okay to have a system where parents and students make the decision about whether or not schools are good or bad by spending time at them"

In part, Yes! The way every other cooperative voluntary arrangement works! Do you even have children? I do. I have had babysitters that have made me uncomfortable on the first day. Yes, I have fired them and made the necessary decisions for my children. Why you think I should be legally prevented from doing that in the case of decades of dubious-quality education is a complete mystery to me at this point.

Experiential data are extremely useful on individual bases. Children who enjoy school because they don't have to do anything have been taught that education is painful. Anyone without that supposition would simply be bored, which would be a negative complaint rather than a positive review. The fact that we culturally accept common utterances like "school sucks" should tell you everything you need to know about a one-size-fits-all approach to educating a population. The argument here is to walk back the do-this-or-lose-your-house force-based approach and move toward a competitive and innovative approach toward improving individuals' quality of life. Your argument against this seems to be that, while it hasn't worked here, it theoretically (under some theory you've yet to elucidate) could, because infinite resources by fiat magically translate to infinite productivity and efficiency in real life. I don't think you've just done a poor job at defending that claim, I think you've simply done the best job you could of defending a bad idea.

Now what's that they say about ideas being so good the have to be mandatory?

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:38AM (#19967801)
Look, I can see that this is coming down more to an ideological and theoretical argument than a fact-based one. You dismissed any evidence that other countries have done this better out of hand because in theory those statistics can be corrupted, and you've dismissed the idea that state experts could make the system better because they could also be corrupted.

This is the core conservative argument for abolishing just about every government service: "We screwed it up in the past. Rather than trying to fix our past mistakes, we should instead give up."

And I am well aware of the problems with the "food pyramid." Your example here ignores the fact that the government has since acknowledged that the original recommendations were wrong, and has been updating them over time to reflect the best research. The argument that "the process can be corrupted therefore we should give up" ignores that it can also be improved over time, and that governments are accountable.

"Your argument against this seems to be that, while it hasn't worked here, it theoretically (under some theory you've yet to elucidate) could, because infinite resources by fiat magically translate to infinite productivity and efficiency in real life."

I did provide evidence that it could work, which was that it has worked in numerous other countries. You just chose to dismiss that evidence out of hand because you'd rather come up with an excuse to disbelieve it rather than accept that a system you fundamentally disagree with can work. Whether you mean it to or not, it comes off as utterly and completely bad-faith argument to dismiss the evidence I provided out of hand and then tell me several paragraphs later that I haven't adequately described how it can be done. I pointed you in the direction of a perfect example, and yet apparently you haven't even checked to see if it's a valid example.

The short version is this: Finland had a crappy education system, and they made a decision as a country to fix it. They approached it with open minds, willing to throw out any ideas that were outdated and not backed up with evidence. What they ended up with was little to no homework, fresh-made school lunches, and the abolition of private schools. (The reason for the last bit is that as long as wealthy people can use private schools as an escape hatch for their own kids, they have zero political incentive to fix the public schools.)

You mentioned in another comment that you would absolutely accept a system that rewarded parents who spent more time researching schools, and I think this is where we fundamentally disagree. You want a system that allows people succeed if they have the time and resources to do so. I want a system that does its best for all people, even though that takes a lot more work and coordination.

Now, I'm not exactly sure what your motivation for this is. Pessimistically, it looks like a very selfish line of reasoning: Since you have the time and resources and think you're smart enough to choose wisely, you want the choice to do so, and if other people don't have the same opportunities then too bad for them. Or, more optimistically, you just can't imagine a system that works adequately the way I describe, so you just think your way is safer.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by ultrarunner on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @10:28PM (#19977203)
Frankly I think you're either misunderstanding or misrepresenting my positions. We have been arguing from efficiency right along, but you're now shifting to an argument from morality. You posit that it's acceptable for the state to take ownership of its citizens (subjects at that point?) Ultimately that's a position I have to entirely reject. There comes a point where the removal of autonomy to improve a person's life deprives them of what it means to be alive. Your elitist position that you and your experts know so much more than the little people that you can't "allow" them to make their own choices comes off rather poorly. It also comes off as rather short sighted, as politics is often inherently unstable, and all it takes is a "bad politician" to take your well-meaning but authoritarian system and take it full-blown authoritarian.

I appreciate your extrapolation on your ideas. While I'm sure neither of us have changed our minds, I find your position interesting and I'm sure others reading have been able to see a small amount of the breadth of the topic at hand.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by swivelmaster on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:35PM (#19966344)
Sounds like it.

I really miss the good old days of Hacker News when there was literally none of that kind of nonsense.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by tracker1 on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:27AM (#19967743)
Sounds like they're saying that poor parents are too stupid to know the difference.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by stale2002 on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:58PM (#19966490)
Consumers are the ones paying for it. So I see nothing wrong with providing what they want.