News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Civil War by dralley on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:04AM (#19953312)
So what you're saying is, employees shouldn't complain about (censorship, bosses tolerating sexual harassment, etc.), they should either put up with it or leave quietly (possibly to their own financial detriment)?

I can't say I agree with you. What you're suggesting is basically the Wall Street model where bad and unethical institutional behavior gets a suboptimal amount of pushback.

Re:Google's Civil War by herohamp on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:07AM (#19953332)
They should but they then also face the consequences
Re:Google's Civil War by jpdb on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:18AM (#19953379)
Employees who can't voice their dissatisfaction for the status quo without fear of repercussion can't truly voice their dissatisfaction.

There's an EXTREME amount of power imbalance between employer and employee; if employees have to fear retaliation for voicing their concerns it has a chilling effect.

I'm okay with consequences, but voicing your concerns in public isn't grounds for consequences.

Re:Google's Civil War by chii on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:23AM (#19953396)
This is where a platform for voicing anonymously is required.
Re:Google's Civil War by roenxi on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:45AM (#19953530)
> Employees who can't voice their dissatisfaction for the status quo without fear of repercussion can't truly voice their dissatisfaction.

Employees are signing up for a world where they don't wear significant risk in exchange for subordinating their decision making to a company.

Companies are fundamentally an organised group of people working to a common goal. I can understand very well if individual employees want to assert their individuality. However, at any moment, they have only and exactly 3 choices:

1) Cooperate enthusiastically.

2) Cooperate with complaint

3) Quit

Nobody is going to get sacked for quietly and politely voicing a concern. However, once employees start organising to influence management on business decisions they really need to pony up the capital and become shareholders. Deciding what management does is the privilege of shareholders, not employees.

Re:Google's Civil War by SolaceQuantum on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:52AM (#19953566)
> However, once employees start organising to influence management on business decisions they really need to pony up the capital and become shareholders. Deciding what management does is the privilege of shareholders, not employees.

Isn't this precisely describing why unions were originally generated, so that employees can also leverage power equal to the shareholders, and therefore have a say in their own working conditions?

Re:Google's Civil War by roenxi on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:04AM (#19953621)
There is a big difference between that and what is being discussed in this article though. Unions are dealing with pay and conditions - important, but ultimately just aggregating topics that employers and employees were going to negotiate around anyway.

This article is talking about:

* Amazon workers are demanding more action from the company on battling climate change

* Microsoft, employees say they don’t want to build technology for warfare

* Salesforce, a group has lobbied management to end its work with the U.S. Customs and Border Protection agency

* Google, [employees] want a say in and control over the products they build

Those are issues going way beyond what an employee can reasonably expect to influence. Being employed by a tech company is an achievement, but the end of the day tech workers aren't that special. They don't formally get to decide how the world works.

They absolutely can't take to social media to complain about these issues and expect to hold a job with the company they are complaining about. This type of activity isn't acceptable; they can't draw a wage and overrule strategic directions from people with capital at stake. The options are work or walk.

Re:Google's Civil War by kazagistar on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:17PM (#19954022)
You make a bunch of statements about what can and cannot be done, and back up none of them. What can be done is what you have power to do, and collectively, workers have power greater than capital. What should be done is what is moral, since the people with capital are institutionally unable to. It's really that simple.
Re:Google's Civil War by detaro on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:24PM (#19954347)
They clearly can at least temporarily, you can currently observe them doing so. Their employers now can decide if they want to call their "bluff" or not, and deal with the consequences of either choice.
Re:Google's Civil War by dralley on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:15AM (#19953364)
And many do. Are you suggesting otherwise?

But I don't think they "should" do so if they're calling out legitimately poor behavior that has been unaddressed by any other avenue. That wording is quite strange to me. Would you say that Rosa Parks "should" have faced the consequences of stirring things up as she did? Accepting that it is possible is a necessary part of civil disobedience, but the imposition of those consequences by higher powers is not.

Re:Google's Civil War by NotPaidToPost on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:25AM (#19953408)
That's how employment works.

As an employee you are paid to execute the company's strategy.

If you disagree you can of course, and even should, voice your disagreement but that should be done in a professional in diplomatic way, in private.

If you cannot do that or cannot accept the company's strategy then yes, your alternative is to leave quietly.

The new "red guards" of the left may not like it, but that's what professionalism (not to mention a free society) is. Tough.

Re:Google's Civil War by eropple on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:03AM (#19953618)
This is an extremely...one-sided...view of things. Consider a more healthy one: capital and labor should be partners, and labor gets to have a say in the direction of the company, too.

It must be said, again and again: corporations exist at the sufferance of the society that grants them their charter and only exist for the benefit of that society. A company that can't do that should have its charter revoked. And its labor force is part of that society.

Re:Google's Civil War by AlexB138 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:43AM (#19953827)
> It must be said, again and again: corporations exist at the sufferance of the society that grants them their charter and only exist for the benefit of that society.

I'm assuming you're talking about the US.

We are not subjects of our government, or of some other sovereign, whether that be society or anything else. Our society is founded on individual pursuit of happiness, not collectivism.

Put another way, corporations exist for whatever reason their creators decide. So long as they operate within the law and are able to sustain themselves, societal good is a side effect and a concern of the State, not the corporation itself.

Re:Google's Civil War by eropple on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:52PM (#19954783)
"Corporations exist for whatever reason their creators decide" - the state is the creator of a corporation! They don't just spring out of nowhere. Corporate entities, LLCs, etc. exist literally because the government in whose territory they operate grant them a charter that allows them to enter contracts and make agreements independent of the personal liability of the owners. That government can revoke that charter (and it has happened in American history--it's not a theoretical thing, it is real and an extant power (one that goes unused, but extant nonetheless).

We, as the actual owners of that government that grants this special exception, can--and should--expect better than the barest bare minimum out of such fictional persons if they want to keep their fictional personhood. This is a transaction: "we grant you the right to operate a fictional person and you don't act like shitheads in our society."

We don't do this, largely because of the weird little melty fears that led to you going off about collectivism when it doesn't apply here except insofar that labor participation can encourage, though does not guarantee, better behavior. But we can, and we should, keep this tool at the ready because corporate entities will be good citizens only so long as you keep the proverbial fist of an angry god ready to strike; sociopaths (and your standard corporation is a sociopath by definition) only, only, respect consequences and so those consequences must be severe and always at the ready.

A careful reader might note that I said nothing about such companies operating as unlimited-liability partnerships. Because yes, fair is fair, and people (who, unlike fictive entities, have rights and freedoms even if the results of those rights and freedoms suck) have the right to do as they please so long as they aren't harming other people. But they wouldn't take that option and we all know why.

Re:Google's Civil War by nmcfarl on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:16PM (#19954018)
The state licenses corporations. Corporations exist for whatever reason their creators and the state decide on.
Re:Google's Civil War by nmcfarl on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:43PM (#19955397)
Continuing

I live in the US, and sit on the the board of a governmental organization, a nonprofit corporation and an LLC.

It is incredibly obvious from this perspective that the regulations the state chooses to apply greatly constrain what it is possible for your organization to do. And this goes beyond the day to day all the way up to the mission of the org.

The state definitely has a large influence on weather organizations exists, their form and the reasons for which and methods they operate.

Re:Google's Civil War by geodel on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:42PM (#19954427)
Labor can and should form a cooperative. There are many in US. This hypothetical cooperative can put all the policies in place which they want but do not get from Google.

> It must be said, again and again: corporations exist at the sufferance of the society that grants them their charter and only exist for the benefit of that society. A company that can't do that should have its charter revoked.

This sounds like BS to me. I see all the companies doing serious harm to humanity, environment, ecology are running just fine. Do you have examples of charter getting revoked?

Re:Google's Civil War by eropple on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:59PM (#19954816)
Corporate death penalties exist in the United States. This article includes a Google Books link to New York doing so in 1890: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_dissolution

It sounds like bullshit because some elements of the civic discourse have expended a lot of effort to make the idea inconceivable.

Re:Google's Civil War by NotPaidToPost on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:02PM (#19953937)
Employment is one-sided: You get paid to work for someone, not to do as you please. If you do not like what you are paid to do, no-one forces you...

Socialism does not work. It ends in chaos and failure.

Re:Google's Civil War by dang on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:10PM (#19955844)
Would you please not take HN threads further into generic ideological flamewar? First you posted flamebait above ("red guards of the left") and now head straight into the most generic and therefore most boring possible direction ("socialism does not work"). Maybe it doesn't, but all these discussions are the same, and tedious repetition is not what HN is for, so please don't do this here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Google's Civil War by NotPaidToPost on Monday May 20, 2019 @03:34AM (#19958223)
I felt important to repeat that socialism does not work since we keep reading people advocating it. That is not generic, that's quite the crux to the issue here. I maintain the term "red guard" because that's exactly how they behave. See the reactions to me daring to contradict.

I am very surprised that a moderator would take side and use a rather rude and condescending tone in replying to a commenter that hasn't do anything beyond voicing a legitimate point.

Is that what HN is for?

Re:Google's Civil War by dang on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @11:02AM (#19970762)
I'm sorry that my comment sounded rude and condescending. I try to avoid that, but haven't yet mastered the art.

Generic ideological arguments are simply off topic on HN. If you like, you can think of that as an arbitrary moderation decision. I think of it as following from the site principle of curiosity. Either way, please don't post any more of those.

Re:Google's Civil War by kazagistar on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:21PM (#19954039)
Plenty of far more socialist policies than the status quo work perfectly well. The whole anti socialism ideology is bullshit pedaled by the powerful to enforce the status quo.
Re:Google's Civil War by eropple on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:55PM (#19954799)
It is not "socialist" to expect a specially-treated organization to not act shitty if it wants to keep that special legal treatment. It just...isn't.

Not that you're right about your sweeping statement either, but it doesn't even begin to apply here except insofar as labor participation in direction can--not will, but can--discourage that shitty behavior.

Re:Google's Civil War by NotPaidToPost on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:16PM (#19954888)
You commented that employees should have a say on the direction of the company... That's a socialist concept.
Re:Google's Civil War by NeedMoreTea on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:22PM (#19954915)
For clarity, are Ireland and Germany socialist countries?

Both require employee representation on boards, as do many other not-socialist countries. Germany also has works councils.

Re:Google's Civil War by NotPaidToPost on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:44PM (#19955060)
The concept is socialist. You are trying a rhetoric trick by equating that to a socialist economy... That's bad faith.

The truth is that employees do not dictate the direction of the company in those countries. They have virtually no power and the system is used as a discussion platform on working conditions, pay, etc.

This is not quite the same as having employees decide what the company should produce and to whom it should sell it.

Re:Google's Civil War by NeedMoreTea on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:07PM (#19955197)
No I'm not, I was asking the question.

They both require one third of the board to be employee representatives. It might even be half for larger German companies. How does getting to vote on decisions and appointments equate to having virtually no power?

German work's councils, for all their imperfections and flaws, have often been looked at enviously by other Western countries - including US and UK. It is those which deal with conditions, pay and what have you.

Re:Google's Civil War by eropple on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:31PM (#19954987)
Policies are not "socialist" or "capitalist"; they're...policies. You pick what works. Judging from the pretty consistent success of labor participation on boards in other companies, it certainly seems to help make a good chunk of money, too.

That such organization tends to also have societal value--weird that thinking about societal value gets conflated with "socialism", I guess every man is an island--is a really nice side effect, though.

Re:Google's Civil War by faissaloo on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:49AM (#19953866)
If your company is going to super power the surveillance state and plunge the world into tyranny like we've never seen before why would you make things easy for them?