News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Civil War by eropple on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:55PM (#19954799)
It is not "socialist" to expect a specially-treated organization to not act shitty if it wants to keep that special legal treatment. It just...isn't.

Not that you're right about your sweeping statement either, but it doesn't even begin to apply here except insofar as labor participation in direction can--not will, but can--discourage that shitty behavior.

Re:Google's Civil War by NotPaidToPost on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:16PM (#19954888)
You commented that employees should have a say on the direction of the company... That's a socialist concept.
Re:Google's Civil War by NeedMoreTea on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:22PM (#19954915)
For clarity, are Ireland and Germany socialist countries?

Both require employee representation on boards, as do many other not-socialist countries. Germany also has works councils.

Re:Google's Civil War by NotPaidToPost on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:44PM (#19955060)
The concept is socialist. You are trying a rhetoric trick by equating that to a socialist economy... That's bad faith.

The truth is that employees do not dictate the direction of the company in those countries. They have virtually no power and the system is used as a discussion platform on working conditions, pay, etc.

This is not quite the same as having employees decide what the company should produce and to whom it should sell it.

Re:Google's Civil War by NeedMoreTea on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:07PM (#19955197)
No I'm not, I was asking the question.

They both require one third of the board to be employee representatives. It might even be half for larger German companies. How does getting to vote on decisions and appointments equate to having virtually no power?

German work's councils, for all their imperfections and flaws, have often been looked at enviously by other Western countries - including US and UK. It is those which deal with conditions, pay and what have you.

Re:Google's Civil War by eropple on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:31PM (#19954987)
Policies are not "socialist" or "capitalist"; they're...policies. You pick what works. Judging from the pretty consistent success of labor participation on boards in other companies, it certainly seems to help make a good chunk of money, too.

That such organization tends to also have societal value--weird that thinking about societal value gets conflated with "socialism", I guess every man is an island--is a really nice side effect, though.