News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by Xixi on Thursday May 16, 2019 @04:39PM (#19932954)
I have no idea how reliable it is, but quoting wikipedia [1]:

"Testing has found that overall "input lag" (from controller input to display response) times of approximately 200 ms are distracting to the user. It also appears that (excluding the monitor/television display lag) 133 ms is an average response time and the most sensitive games (fighting games, first person shooters and rhythm games) achieve response times of 67 ms (excluding display lag)."

These numbers are from the PS3/XBox 360 area, which certainly sold massively well. Since display lag is not included in these 67ms, this is what these streaming services would have to aim for. It doesn't sound completely insane given the 30ms round trip latencies of home connections.

On a more subjective note, I think it's going to be really hard hunting down high end gamer PCs. On the other hand lots of games don't run particularly smoothly on consoles (especially "normal" PS4 and XBox One, rather than PS4 Pro or XBox One S) that these services are directly aiming at. I can perfectly imagine a stadia version of The Witcher 3 running circles around the PS4 version that lags so much... But I don't think it would hold against the PC version.

But I don't game much at all anymore, so my knowledge is mostly outdated. The last games I played were 80 days and A Dark Room on my iPhone (both pretty good games). So I guess I'm now more in the target demographics of Apple Arcade.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Input_lag

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by davemp on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:57PM (#19933798)
I followed up on the wiki article. The citation was a just eurogamer article that had little to with human perception of latency. It did have this nugget: “Criterion said it was aiming for 50ms latency [for burnout paradise]” which agrees with what I’ve heard making handheld electronics. The goal was always <50ms latency.

Personally I noticed a significant improvement switching to a 165hz monitor in basically every first person game. The only difference here is going from 16ms to 6ms frame granularity (10ms off the worst case). I’m not sure how much is visual smoothness or latency, but I’d gladly take refresh rate/fps over UHD.

I’m definitely in the enthusiast group though. I didn’t even realize that console players dealt with such high latency. It will be very interesting to see how the market plays out.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by gmueckl on Thursday May 16, 2019 @08:31PM (#19934928)
Hm... the topic is quite complex. Human perception is actually much slower than many people want to believe. Parts of the human vision system react no faster than around 1/25th of a second (other parts are faster - its complicated!). Hearing is similarly divided. AFAIK, auditory and visuak stimuli are processed together and merged over a rather large time window (to the point where one system can induce illusions in the other). But we are able to perceive time delays within a complex stimulus with very high precision.

I am not totally convinced that a high refresh rate monitor allows human vision to respond faster. I would rather suspect that most game loops are VSync-locked and a higher refresh rate leads to better input sampling and processing.

Maybe I should set up a simple test where I show a non-interactive sequence at various framerates and ask users to identify the highest framerate. And then repeat with interactive camera controls.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by hnuser123456 on Friday May 17, 2019 @04:08AM (#19937375)
>I am not totally convinced that a high refresh rate monitor allows human vision to respond faster.

Have you ever watched a high-level FPS player? They can aim and shoot in the span of about ~1/5 of a second, occasionally even faster. That's 200ms. At 25hz, that's 40ms. A big part of it is going to be increased input processing, but a lot of it is muscle memory at that skill level. At 165hz, that's 6ms. With two equally skilled players, one will see the other up to a whole 34 ms sooner, in a process that takes about 200ms total. That's going to show up as a highly statistically significant advantage. Of course, the increased sense of connectedness to the game at higher rates is another big advantage, but these effects combine. Pit one skilled shooter against another at equal refresh rates, but with one dealing with 34ms of additional input latency, and they're not going to play as well as they should.

Competitive players explicitly disable vsync, because the higher the game framerate, the faster it processes input. Also, the sooner you see updated information on the screen mid-refresh, but that doesn't help as much as a wholly higher refresh rate.

All of this only matters if cloud gamers were playing against locally-rendered players in the same match though.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by imtringued on Friday May 17, 2019 @06:11AM (#19938041)
There is a reaction delay but it is added on top of all the other delays. If the monitor is delayed by 1/25th of a second and your perception is delayed by 1/25th of a second then the worst case latency is 2/25th of a second. That is a 100% increase in reaction delay. If you think a 100% increase isn't significant what do you think about the 250% (or more) increase that streaming will cause?
Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by gmueckl on Friday May 17, 2019 @06:50AM (#19938257)
I am not arguing against the existence of such an effect. I am loathe to state that the cause is that your eyes see more images per second on screen. I am not convinced that a higher framerate improves perception of the image content when over ~50Hz. I'm rather suspecting that the traditional coupling of game simulation and input processing rates to screen refresh rate is the cause: games seem more responsive because input sampling is more precise when the game loop runs faster.
Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by romwell on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:52PM (#19934263)
>I have no idea how reliable it is

This is not reliable at all. You can really feel 100ms latency.

That's why in the world of pro music, barely anything above 10ms keypress-to-sound latency is deemed acceptable.

Quake III will make all these streamed games feel slow.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by _nedR on Friday May 17, 2019 @02:47AM (#19936918)
Console gamers have long been conditioned to accept high input lag with laggy televisions, controllers and low-dexterity games and game mechanics.

Quake III makes all modern games feel slow. But that hasn't had the slightest effect on the typical gamers mindset. If only certain type of games work with cloud gaming then AAA publishers will only make those type of games. Exactly like the case with EA and microtransactions.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by DontGiveTwoFlux on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:56PM (#19934297)
Well sound uses different neural pathways than audio, so it's not a totally fair comparison.
Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by tlear on Thursday May 16, 2019 @07:15PM (#19934432)
100ms is pretty bad in shooter. Around 60-70 is where I cant distinguish the difference. But I am very far from a great player.

I can see this working very well for games like Total War where hardware specs are super high but response time is not critical

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by kibibu on Thursday May 16, 2019 @07:00PM (#19934328)
Is this a typo? Anyway, audio feedback is a critical part of games. Pressing the "fire" button and waiting 100ms for the sound of the gun would be insanely noticeable
Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by josephg on Thursday May 16, 2019 @07:51PM (#19934676)
The inverse is also true. Sound triggers and local animations are often used to mask latency in games like DOTA which need a server round trip before your commands have any affect on the game world. It works remarkably well to make games feel responsive even when they’re not.

However, with these streaming systems I’m not sure developers will be able to use tricks like that. It seems like these tech stacks are running all code remotely. I feel pretty skeptical about whether they can make the game feel good enough this way.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by vincnetas on Friday May 17, 2019 @04:23AM (#19937435)
you mean video? "pathways than audio"
Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by TheOperator on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:32PM (#19933519)
Actual video gamers right now go out of their way to get displays with very low input lags. 1080p144hz TN low input lag displays are used quite a bit in esports to shave a few msec. You literally win more often if you react faster. People aim to get TVs with sub 16ms input lag.

However that's not most of the market. The appeal of cloud gaming is for single player non-competitive games. These are the most pirated games and the games where input lag matters the least.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by voldacar on Thursday May 16, 2019 @07:31PM (#19934536)
In arena shooters like quake and similar games, input lag of 10ms (1-2 frames) is noticeable. 200ms would be an absolute joke.
Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by ehsankia on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:28PM (#19933473)
You can probably do even better than 20-30ms round trip if you're one of the large Cloud companies with data centers everywhere. Amazon so far doesn't seem interested, but Google and Microsoft definitely have the infrastructure to pull it off.

Sure you won't get high end PC gamers, that's not really the target demographic here. It's the millions of console and mobile gamers.

Re:Sony and Microsoft set rivalry aside for cloud gaming all... by borkt on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:51PM (#19933729)
I can easily notice the difference between 20 and 40 ms in FPS games. I have gotten out of FPS's due to keeping up with the hardware requirements, but a streaming service like this could make it possible. That being said, if they cant stay below 50ms I probably wouldn't waste my time.