News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by brown9-2 on Friday December 10, 2010 @02:40PM (#1992846)
Interesting that they don't mention Google's vote "no".

The official comments of each party in the JCP on this vote are pretty interesting, even a large number of the "yes" votes clarify that they are voting only on the technical merits and they have deep concerns with the licensing.

http://jcp.org/en/jsr/results?id=5111

Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by bruceboughton on Friday December 10, 2010 @03:02PM (#1992948)
The Credit Suisse comments are particularly interesting:

On 2010-12-06 Credit Suisse voted Yes with the following comment:

Credit Suisse's vote is purely on the technical content. We strongly demand open standards and an active community around Java as we selected Java SE & EE as primary pillars for our application development (as many others in the industry do). The current battle around licensing term, however, reveals that Java never actually was an open standard. FOU restrictions clearly discriminate open source implementations and prevent competition, and with that, innovation in that space. While Java had a considerable head start, it lost a lot of momentum over the last years. Fragmentation (or a fork) of the language and its platforms are clearly not desired. But today, customers are already facing competing models for developing enterprise applications (e.g., Spring, OSGi, Java EE). The main problem, in our view, is the lack of modularization, clear delineation of Java IPs owned by Oracle and truly open standard extensions, and the ignorance of developments outside of the JCP (even though OSGi has a JCP blessing). The OpenJDK framework is not sufficient for all aspects of the language. Java must be kept interesting for researchers and universities: researchers not only contribute to the standards (e.g., Doug Lea for concurrency or Michael Ernst for type annotations) but also decide on the languages (and paradigms) that are taught at universities -- and this in the end determines the knowledge and mindset we acquire with our software engineers. While we recognize Oracle’s intellectual properties around Java, we strongly encourage Oracle to re-think its current position around licensing terms. We strongly support open source as a licensing model for contributions in the JCP.

Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by 6ren on Friday December 10, 2010 @03:30PM (#1993045)
> we selected Java SE & EE as primary pillars for our application development (as many others in the industry do)

Sadly, this is exactly Oracle's motivation.

Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by rbanffy on Friday December 10, 2010 @06:24PM (#1993603)
Can anyone explain clearly why OpenJDK is not enough?
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by wmf on Friday December 10, 2010 @06:50PM (#1993668)
OpenJDK is enough for 99% of people. The remaining objections are philosophical and strategic: To count as a true bona-fide 100% open standard, you should be able to implement Java from scratch (without using any OpenJDK code) using any license you want and get it certified. Also, the ASF is trying to build a completely ASL-licensed stack, either because of NIH or because it benefits IBM and Intel in some way.
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by parfe on Friday December 10, 2010 @10:17PM (#1994046)
I was under the impression it was the TCK that caused the issues. OpenJDK could be certified, but you weren't allowed to then run the "certified" version on a mobile device.

Which is an additional restriction onto of the GPL.

Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by rbanffy on Saturday December 11, 2010 @06:53AM (#1994663)
Since Sun distributed OpenJDK under GPLv2, they waived that restriction. GPL'ed software cannot have FOU restrictions. AFAIK, however, OpenJDK does not include J2ME, so, you would be able to run, say, NetBeans on your phone, but not Hexic.
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by jfager on Friday December 10, 2010 @09:20PM (#1993956)
For the same reasons any GPL'd software isn't enough. We could go back and forth forever about whether those reasons are good, but that's not a conversation unique to OpenJDK vs Harmony.
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by rbanffy on Saturday December 11, 2010 @06:58AM (#1994668)
I agree that releasing a GPL'ed derivative of OpenJDK may not make sense for every business plan I can think of, but, from a user point-of-view, would there be any difference?
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by jfager on Saturday December 11, 2010 @10:12AM (#1994920)
Like any two implementations of a spec, they probably have different performance and stability characteristics. As for what those differences actually are, or if there are others as well, I'm really not familiar enough with Harmony to say. My completely unsubstantiated guess is that end users will be more interested in OpenJDK, as it's derived from the mature, battle tested jvm Sun's been shipping for years.
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by uriel on Friday December 10, 2010 @09:12PM (#1993939)
Oracle has patents all over it, and will sue anyone that uses it in any way that they don't like.
Re:Oracle Asks Apache to Reconsider Java Committee Departure by jfager on Friday December 10, 2010 @09:24PM (#1993962)
OpenJDK comes with a patent grant, so that's not the issue. It's about the GPL and Sun/Oracle's control over the project.