News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by spamizbad on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:28PM (#19923410)
Huh? The US has been very aggressive about shutting down websites that spread Al-Qaeda and ISIS propaganda on most websites. ISIS basically caught everyone with their pants down spreading their stuff on social media, but once people started noticing it, it was purged rapidly.

It's not my view, but you could make the argument than the original sin was censoring Al-Qaeda content post-9/11. Obviously, nobody complained. Now the same tactics are being turned against the far-right and people have discovered a new love for free speech.

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by Miner49er on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:32PM (#19923453)
Yeah, maybe I wasn't paying attention, but I didn't see any people protecting ISIS's free speech. Now that this censorship is targeting other hate speech, suddenly everyone is shouting "free speech". The fact is, most people calling for free speech don't truly believe in it, they just want to be able to spout their own version of hate.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by spamizbad on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:33PM (#19923464)
FWIW, there were a small group of people raising concerns about how the government went about shutting down "terrorist" websites after 9/11 but it largely fell on deaf ears. These people have been ideologically consistent, but they're outside of the political mainstream.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by brianmc21 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:39PM (#19923527)
Also consider the fact that even if you do support free speech speaking out against censorship of a terrorist organization is only going to lead to blowback because you are supporting the enemy.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by Joakal on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:56PM (#19924605)
First they came for al Qaeda content,

Then they came for ISIS comtent,

Then...

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by spamizbad on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:34PM (#19924804)
Basically this. It was Pandora’s Box.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by acct1771 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:11PM (#19925842)
We're the same people that think PayPal shouldn't be allowed to seize your funds for writing "ISIS Beer Fund" on a $40 toss over to your mate...
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by darkpuma on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:44PM (#19923587)
> "Huh? The US has been very aggressive about shutting down websites that spread Al-Qaeda and ISIS propaganda on most websites"

You mean like archive.org? That's the website I've seen hosting all the ISIS shit.

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by spamizbad on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:01PM (#19923726)
True, there's a few other "ISIS archives" that are used largely by intelligence analysts, journalists, historians, and academics for study. But I don't think NZ is saying "Hey journalists and academics, don't study a dump of 8chan!"
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by makomk on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:27PM (#19923940)
What NZ has been saying is that there should be no way for an ordinary, unaccredited member of the public to view any archived copies of any of the Christchurch killer's propaganda anywhere online, something normal internet users apparently can do with ISIS propaganda via archive.org. They've been quite consistent about this since day zero, from what I can tell.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by hulahoof on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:35PM (#19924008)
I wouldn't be so sure, following the aftermath of Christchurch my network (AU) and several others have not unblocked the Chan's. I don't believe they are planning to either.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by int_19h on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:08PM (#19925564)
Can you clarify if there are actual legal restrictions on that content in place, or is this still unilateral ISP action?
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by hulahoof on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:02AM (#19926536)
There are no current legal restrictions as I understand, it is the decision of my provider to continue restricting this access. The restrictions are not unilateral, the largest ISP has released the restrictions.

I will be changing providers as soon as my contract allows.

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by acct1771 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:12PM (#19925847)
No, they're just trying to be the sole group who decides who is part of those two groups.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by Miner49er on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:28PM (#19923411)
What do you mean? I was under the impression that ISIS was extremely censored online, particularly by the companies that signed this. Is that not the case? On the otherhand, I see white supremacist propganda basically daily at this point.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by dx87 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:40PM (#19923545)
A couple of years ago, Cloudflare refused to remove access to ISIS websites, and said it's not the job of ISPs or themselves to police content.

https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/anonymous-opisis-cloudflare-refuse...

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:19PM (#19923875)
The policy of one internet infrastructure firm doesn't validate the original claim of ISIS' online activity being 'ignored for well over a decade.'
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by DuskStar on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:21PM (#19924349)
It does imply they take it less seriously than stormfront, though.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:45PM (#19925447)
Do you mean Cloudfront? I suppose so, but I don't know enough about the company to reach a firm conclusion.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:52AM (#19926501)
No, stormfront was a ... racially charged... website that Cloudflare actually did refuse to host.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by anigbrowl on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:10AM (#19926574)
I meant to say Cloudflare, sorry. I know what Stormfront is.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by disordinary on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:47PM (#19923608)
But you already censor things much less damaging than the live streaming of a terror attack. Instead of creating a beach head on freedoms which are damaging you should look at why the US rates do low on freedom, civil liberties and democracy and why most of the signatories of this call rate so highly and try and inact positive improvements.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by notfromhere on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:26PM (#19923393)
The first amendment is against government censorship, not private companies providing platforms for free speech on their private networks.
[dead]
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by int_19h on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @10:10PM (#19925573)
This guy was a socialist who literally killed Nazis. Please, spare a couple of minutes, and read what he had to say, and note that this was originally written in 1945.

https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwel...

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by writepub on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:40PM (#19923538)
See how you setup the perfect straw-man here - "If you aren't on the side of our perfect, morality infused, turbo-boosted censorship, you must sympathize with Nazis!".

The only time free speech matters is when the nature of speech is controversial! "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it." is a more accurate summation of the U.S. govt., and the history behind the first amendment.

Also worth noting that an actual incitement of violence is expressly illegal under U.S. law, and the ChristChurch shooter's manifesto et.al. is probably already illegal, without requiring a new speech police

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by Nadya on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:47PM (#19924110)
Incitement of violence is actually mostly legal under U.S law except when it calls for imminent action that is likely to happen, which is a surprisingly high bar to meet. See Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969) [0]. Take note that this ruling was in defense of the KKK, but that it was later cited to protect the speech of the former NAACP Leader, Charles Evers [1].

>The conditions that must be met to impose criminal liability for speech that incites others to illegal actions are imminent harm, a likelihood that the incited illegal action will occur, and an intent by the speaker to cause imminent illegal actions. This precedent remains the principal standard in this area of First Amendment law, since the Supreme Court has not revisited it.

[0] https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/395/444/

[1] https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-speech/free-speech-can-be-mes...

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:53PM (#19924159)
Also worth noting that an actual incitement of violence is expressly illegal under U.S. law, and the ChristChurch shooter's manifesto et.al. is probably already illegal, without requiring a new speech police

Your understanding of the law is wrong. Incitement is assessed (in federal law) by the standard set in Brandenburg v. Ohio which requires both the intention to produce imminent lawless action and the likelihood that it will be produced.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/brandenburg_test

Let us consider a document whose entire text is "Reader, please commit a crime as soon as humanly possible." It is targeted (to the reader), specifically encourages lawless behavior, and has a sense of immediacy.

But does it produce imminent lawlessness? If I say those words to you in person, the time between my utterance and your hearing of it is negligible. If you find me sufficiently inspiring or intimidating you may be moved to act upon my exhortation. But when you read a document, it might have been written 5 minutes ago or 5000 years ago. It may have been produced near to you or on the other side of the world. You may know and care who the writer is, or have no clue. Conversely, as the writer of a document my ability to predict when and where it will be read, and by whom, is similarly limited. Thus, a document by itself lacks temporal, spatial, or social proximity compared to an interpersonal interaction - making imminence virtually impossible to prove.

Likelihood of producing action is very subjective (and thereby also hard to prove). In this case I have offered no incentives or specificity to my exhortations, so you probably feel little motivation to select and carry out a crime and put yourself in legal jeopardy. If you were to cite this document as an exculpatory factor few people would take you seriously. Even if I offered an elaborate rationale and specific directions for committing a crime, when they're in documentary form I don't really know who will read it and have even less knowledge of how readers will react to it; it's very hard to say how anyone could assert a definite probability of 0.5 or greater that the crime will be carried out within any given period.

tl;dr it's almost impossible to prove the US standard of incitement outside of a very narrow range of circumstances, so making the 'incitement is already illegal' argument is the legal equivalent of sweeping dirt underneath a rug and then forgetting about it.

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by northwest65 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:49PM (#19924126)
It's Christchurch, not ChristChurch. I wasn't going to say anything but you've done it twice so I assume it's not a typo.
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by deogeo on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:48PM (#19924553)
Personally, I'm in favour of christ_church.
[dead]
Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by writepub on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:20PM (#19924347)
> When the discussion comes to any other topic such as police brutality, racism, discrimination etc. these voices are conspicuously absent.

Patently untrue, and a baseless accusation. If anything, the recent spate in enforcing compulsory body-cams for cops, and livestreams of actual police brutality have faced ZERO calls for censorship, especially from free speech advocates.

> things are illegal but let's not make any laws or have any clear legal mechanisms to effectively enforcing this

What does this even mean? If something is illegal, those with standing can obviously enforce the law.

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by fzeroracer on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:11PM (#19925288)
Digging up the profoundly dirty history and reality of the US is unfortunately not taken very seriously, and actions by the police towards minorities etc are excused as justified by the same people that would argue against government tyranny.

It's easier to claim that the US is an absolute bastion of free speech when you can conveniently hand wave all of the instances where it is not. Especially when it never actually affects you. It came to absolutely no surprise when i saw almost zero reaction from the 'free speech' crowd when a woman was prosecuted for laughing at Sessions.

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by writepub on Thursday May 16, 2019 @04:22AM (#19927130)
The case you cite [1] should only strengthen the argument for free speech.

The first amendment is likely what saved the lady from a frivolous lawsuit/censorship from those who abuse the power to regulate other's speech.

What you want is that power to reside with a cabal that aligns with your politics, you want a thought-police you approve of, all while citing a case where someone was literally sued for a thought-crime. I hope you see the irony, and that power often shifts with wild swings. Someday, you might find yourself at the wrong end of a thought-policing policy you shilled for, because those in power aren't aligned. Hence the case for constitutional free speech protections.

[1]: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/11/08/562823691...

Re:Tech companies and governments sign up to Christchurch Ca... by Taniwha on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @05:54PM (#19924167)
No, I think the US administration, Trump in particular, sympathise with actual nazis - we saw this in Trump's reaction to the nazis marching in Charlottesville - "very fine people" he said